Skip to main content

Fair Workweek Law in Fast Food: Frequently Asked Questions (NYC DCWP, September 2023) (Part 2 of 2)

Part 2 of 2

If a worker accepts a new shift that overlaps with an existing shift, does an employer have to award the new shift to the worker?

Yes. If an employer completes its process for awarding shifts and an available shift remains which a worker with an overlapping shift accepted, the employer must award the new shift in place of the worker’s existing shift. The employer may allow the worker to continue to work the nonoverlapping hours of the original shift. Or, the employer may choose to assign the original shift to another current employee or to advertise it.

Natasha works at Caliente Dogs, a fast food establishment. Her regular schedule includes a shift on Mondays from 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Caliente Dogs posted a notice to all of its employees about an additional recurring shift at her worksite on Mondays from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., a shift that overlaps with Natasha’s existing recurring shift. Natasha accepts the 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. shift because it will allow her to drop her child off at school in the morning without reducing her overall hours. No other worker requests the shift. Is Natasha entitled to the new recurring shift?

Yes. Caliente Dogs must award the new recurring shift to Natasha. In this case, Natasha is an existing worker at the location where the recurring shift is available. Since an existing worker accepted the shift, Caliente Dogs cannot hire a new fast food worker to work the shift even if it prefers not to change Natasha’s regular schedule.

If more than one worker accepts an available shift, what criteria can an employer use to determine how to award shifts when multiple workers accept the same shift?

The employer can use any criteria it wants, as long as the criteria are not discriminatory or otherwise unlawful.

For instance, an employer can choose to rely on job tenure, performance, or training concerns. However, employers must put in the posted notice the criteria for awarding available shifts. If no employees who meet the criteria accept the shifts, the employer must award shifts to employees who do not meet the criteria but accepted the shifts.

If a worker accepts a new shift that would put the worker’s weekly hours into overtime, does an employer need to award the shift to the worker?

No. Employers do not need to award available shifts to workers when it would require the employer to pay that worker overtime. However, employers do need to award the greatest number of hours possible without triggering the overtime requirement.

If a worker accepts a new shift that would entitle the worker to an extra hour of pay for working a long day under New York State law, the employer must still award the shift to the worker.

An employer advertises a shift on Wednesday from 12:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. to its employees. The notice states that the employer will give priority in awarding the shift to workers who work less than 32 hours a week. A worker whose regular schedule totals 37 hours is the only worker who accepts the shift. Does the employer have to award the worker the shift?

No. The employer does not have to award the six-hour shift to the employee because working more than 40 hours would make the employee eligible for overtime pay.

On the other hand, if a worker with a regular schedule of 34 hours or less had accepted the shift, the employer would have to award the shift to that worker.

If an employee who accepts a shift offer is on a leave of absence, must the employer award the shift to that employee?

No, unless the employee is scheduled to return to work within 14 days of the date of the offer.

If an employee accepts a shift offer and is awarded the available shift on a regular, recurring basis, should the employer add the shift to the employee’s regular schedule? Yes.

If an employee accepts a shift offer and is awarded the available shift on a temporary, nonpermanent basis, should the employer add the shift to the employee’s regular schedule?

No. A shift that is temporary is not considered part of an employee’s regular schedule. However, the access to hours procedures apply: an employer may not include the shift in a new hire’s regular schedule without first offering the shift to current employees.

A fast food employer posts and emails current employees a notice about available shifts on specific dates only. No current employee accepts the temporary shifts. The employer hires three new employees and includes in their regular schedules recurring shifts, not the temporary ones advertised in the notice. Has the employer violated the law?

Yes. The employer hired new employees and included in their regular schedules recurring shifts that the employer did not offer to current employees. The employer misrepresented the available shifts in the notice to current employees.

Do an employer’s responsibilities change if the employer hires a new worker through a subcontractor?

No. The requirements to advertise available shifts to current employees remain the same as long as the new worker is considered a fast food worker under the law. See I. b. Who is a Fast Food Employee? on page 2 .

How long do employees have to accept open shifts?

After an employer has provided notice of open recurring shifts to existing workers, those workers have three days to accept the shifts.

What are employers’ responsibilities when they learn they need to fill a newly open shift in less than three days?

When an employer has less than three days’ notice to fill an open shift, the employer must post notice of the shift as soon as practicable (possible), but no less than 24 hours after learning of the need. The employer may

offer an existing employee the opportunity to work the shift temporarily during the three-day notice period. In this situation, the employer will need to pay the worker any applicable schedule change premiums and get written consent. See II. b. Changes to Work Schedules and Schedule Change Premiums on page 15 .

Can employers transfer workers between stores to cover shifts?

Yes, if certain conditions are met. Workers at all locations managed by the employer may express their willingness and availability to work available shifts. However, the employer must first award shifts to workers who responded in time and already work at the location where shifts are available. If shifts still remain open, the employer must award them to workers from other locations who responded in time to accept shifts.

If an employer wants to transfer existing employees before the end of three days (or the time in which workers had to respond), all existing workers at the location of the available shift(s) must have either accepted or turned down the opportunity in writing.

The law applies regardless of whether the employer would normally transfer workers between fast food locations.

If employers receive timely confirmation from all current workers at the location that they don’t want the available shifts, do employers still have to wait until the posting deadline before they can award the open shifts to workers from other locations or to new workers?

No. If all of the workers at the location with open shifts confirm in writing that they do not want the shifts before the posting deadline, the employer may immediately award the shifts to workers from other locations who accepted. If existing workers at all other locations provide written confirmation that they do not want the available shifts, the employer may immediately hire new workers.

If no current workers accept an open shift, can employers reconfigure the shift or change the job they are looking to fill when they hire a new employee?

No. The employer must offer new employees the shifts and the jobs that were advertised in the notice to existing workers.

What are an employer’s responsibilities once they fill available shifts?

Employers must notify all employees who accepted shifts that the shifts are filled as soon as possible after awarding them in the same way they had advertised open shifts.

Upon awarding a recurring shift to an employee, the employer must include the shift in the employee’s updated regular schedule and transmit the updated schedule to the employee in a timely manner.

Upon awarding a temporary shift to an employee, the employer must include the shift in the relevant work schedule and post and transmit the updated work schedule at least 14 days before the first shift on the work schedule. If the employee receives notice of the awarded shift less than 14 days before the shift begins, the employer must pay the employee a schedule change premium.

What happens if employers do not offer available shifts to current workers?

Employers may be obligated to pay current workers $300 for each shift that was not genuinely offered to them, and they may be ordered to comply with the law.

Employers may also be obligated to pay compensatory damages to current workers.

Employers may also be subject to fines of $500 for first violations, up to $750 for second violations within a two-year period, and up to $1,000 for subsequent violations.

Jill’s Place, a chain of fast food establishments, is extending their hours for the summer and will be adding more shifts. Niki, the manager of the Brooklyn location, posts notices about two available shifts at the Brooklyn location and sends the notice to all Jill’s Place workers throughout the city, telling them that they have one day to respond. Steve, an employee at the Manhattan Jill’s Place, responds within a day, telling Niki that he would like one of the shifts. Sam, an employee at the Brooklyn Jill’s Place location, responds after two days to accept both available shifts. Ingrid, another Brooklyn employee, did not see the notice until the next day, but she did not respond because she believed it was too late. Steve, Sam, and Ingrid all meet the criteria established in Niki’s notice. Niki gives one available shift to Steve and hires Peter, a new worker, for the other shift. Did Jill’s Place violate NYC’s Fair Workweek Law?

Yes. Jill’s Place failed to give existing workers, including Ingrid, three days to respond to the notice of available shifts before hiring a new worker. The employer also violated the law by not giving Sam first priority to work the open shifts.

III. Progressive Discipline, Layoffs, and Retaliation

a. Overview

What is a “discharge” under the law?

The law defines a discharge broadly and includes:

1. any time an employer ends an employee’s employment for any reason (termination, firing, layoff, suspension);

2. “constructive” discharges (when certain working conditions make continuing to work intolerable or impossible, forcing an employee to quit); and

3. reductions of more than 15% to an employee’s hours compared to the baseline regular schedule or a work schedule.

A reduction in hours is not a discharge when an employee requests or consents to it.

When is it legal to fire an employee?

Once an employee has been employed for 30 days, an employer may only fire the employee if:

1. there is just cause to fire the worker; or

2. the business is suffering financially and employees with the least seniority are laid off as a result.

When is it legal to reduce an employee’s hours?

Reductions in hours are treated the same way as terminations from employment. After 30 days of employment, an employer cannot reduce an employee’s hours by more than 15% without just cause or unless the business is suffering financially and employees with the least seniority have their hours reduced first.

When an employee is fired or laid off, does the employer have to explain the reason ? Yes. Whenever an employee is discharged, the employer must give the employee a notice of discharge in writing. The notice must include:

  • The date the employer gave the notice to the employee and the date of discharge
  • Whether the discharge was for just cause or a bona fide economic reason
  • The precise reason for the discharge
  • Each instance of progressive discipline issued, if any, and the dates
  • (if the discharge was for a bona fide economic reason only) A statement informing the employee of the right to reinstatement or restoration of hours if new shifts become available; the employee’s last-known phone number and email address which the employer will use to notify the employee about new shifts; contact information if the employee needs to update the phone number or email address on file

If the employee challenges the discharge, the reasons that appear in the notice are the only ones that can be considered in court or arbitration. The employer cannot give a different justification for the discharge later.

Maria joined Fast Food Express in January. One day in August, her manager hands her a piece of paper titled “Notice of Discharge.” The notice states that Maria is being terminated because she “does not fit in with the work culture at Fast Food Express.” Maria immediately files a lawsuit claiming that Fast Food Express failed to use progressive discipline before terminating her. In its response to the suit, Fast Food Express alleges that Maria was terminated because she was late to work 27 times and had received multiple warnings about her lateness. Fast Food Express includes timekeeping records to show Maria’s persistent lateness and copies of the warnings. Has Fast Food Express proved that Maria’s discharge was lawful?

No. Fast Food Express’s termination of Maria was unlawful. Even though Fast Food Express appears to have used progressive discipline to address Maria’s lateness, the Notice of Discharge did not cite Maria’s lateness as the reason for her termination. Instead, the notice gave the vague reason that she did “not fit in with the work culture,” something for which Maria never received progressive discipline.

When and how must an employer provide a notice of discharge to an employee ?

The employer must give written notice to the employee within five days of the discharge. It is best practice to provide the notice by email. However, the employer may provide notice using any method that will reasonably ensure the employee receives it; for example, in person or Certified Mail.

What happens if a worker’s hours are cut unlawfully or a worker is fired unlawfully? Employers may be required to return workers to their prior schedule and pay workers money, including lost wages and benefits. Employers may be required to erase any unlawful discipline, as well.

What are an employer’s obligations to employees when selling a fast food location? If an employer sells a fast food location, its obligations to the employees depend on:

  • the terms of its agreement with the buyer; and
  • whether it owns other fast food locations in New York City.

If the buyer hires some or all of the employees as part of the sale agreement :

  • The seller (original employer) has no further obligations to the transferred employees under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law.

If the buyer does NOT hire some or all of the employees AND the seller has other fast food locations in New York City:

  • The seller (original employer) must offer these employees available shifts at its other New York City locations.
  • Employees with the most seniority must have the first opportunity to accept available shifts, so that the least senior employees are the first ones discharged.
  • Any employee not offered shifts at another location at the time of the sale is considered discharged, and the original employer must offer that employee any shifts that become available at its other New York City locations within the next 12 months.

If the buyer does NOT hire some or all of the employees AND the seller does NOT have other fast food locations in New York City:

  • The seller (original employer) must offer to rehire the discharged employees if it opens or buys any fast food locations in New York City within the next 12 months.

See page 41 for FAQs that cover the process an employer must follow to reinstate discharged employees.

Jaime, Bart, and Majid are employed at Duke Burger, a national fast food chain restaurant with multiple locations in New York City. Duke Burger decides to sell one store to franchisee Empire Food. Duke Burger retains ownership of its other New York City locations. Empire Food hires Jamie, but not Bart or Majid. Bart worked for Duke Burger for three years, and Majid worked for Duke Burger for one year. Does Duke Burger have any responsibilities to Bart or Majid under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law?

Yes. Duke Burger must offer Bart and Majid shifts that become available at its other New York City locations within 12 months. Duke Burger must give priority to Bart because he has more seniority. As discharged employees, Bart and Majid have priority for reinstatement over other Duke Burger employees.

Aishah and Zach work for Jasmine Dragon, a bubble tea chain with one location in New York City. Following a decrease in business, Jasmine Dragon decides to sell its café to Pao’s Teas. Pao’s Teas hires Aishah, but not Zach. After nine months, Jasmine Dragon opens a new location in Queens. Does Jasmine Dragon have any responsibilities to Zach upon opening its new location?

Yes. Because Jasmine Dragon opened a new fast food location within 12 months of the sale, Jasmine Dragon must offer to rehire Zach at the new Queens location.

b. Just Cause and Progressive Discipline

What is just cause for a discharge?

There is just cause to fire an employee, or reduce the employee’s total hours, when the employee repeatedly fails to perform job duties or engages in misconduct. However, unless an employee does something egregious, the employer must give the employee an opportunity to improve. If the employee does not improve, the employer can only fire the employee after giving multiple disciplinary warnings within a one-year period.

What is a progressive discipline policy?

It is a policy that contains a series of disciplinary responses when an employee fails to perform job duties. The disciplinary measures must range from mild to severe, depending on the frequency and degree of the failure to perform duties. Every employer must have a written progressive discipline policy that complies with the law and that the employer follows. Visit nyc.gov/dcwp for Progressive Discipline Policies: What Fast Food Employers Need to Know.

What must a progressive discipline policy include?

The progressive discipline policy must:

  • let employees know what conduct will lead to discipline under the policy;
  • describe graduated steps or responses (accrual of points, strikes) and how the employer applies them to different types of conduct and subsequent infractions.

Fast Food Express’ written progressive discipline policy describes two categories of infractions: minor and major. Examples of minor infractions include lateness of one hour or more, cash register undercounts or overcounts of less than $50, and improper cleaning. Examples of major infractions include insulting customers, refusing to perform an assigned task, and missing a scheduled shift for a reason unrelated to safe and sick leave. Minor infractions result in 1 point. Major infractions result in 3 points. An employee may be terminated after receiving 6 points. The policy requires a manager to document in writing all points in the employee’s personnel file, and the employee has an opportunity to respond. Does Fast Food Express’ progressive discipline policy comply with the law?

Yes. The policy is written and gives employees reasonable notice of what conduct will lead to discipline and how the employer applies points and graduated responses to different types of conduct and subsequent infractions.

However, if the employer did not distribute the written policy to all employees, then the employer would be in violation of the law.

Do employees have access to the progressive discipline policy?

Yes. Employers must distribute the written progressive discipline policy to employees when they are hired and within 14 days of changes to the policy. Employees also have a right to request it.

Can an employer terminate an employee right away for just cause?

Except in cases of egregious misconduct or egregious failure to perform job duties or during an employee’s probation period, an employer does not have just cause to terminate an employee right away. The employer must first follow the written progressive discipline policy and give the employee an opportunity to improve. If the employee does not improve, then the employer may follow the procedures in the progressive discipline policy to end the employee’s employment.

How long is a probation period?

An employer decides the length of the probation period, but it cannot be longer than 30 calendar days from a worker’s first day of work.

How must an employer use a progressive discipline policy?

Employers must tell employees why they are being disciplined and the consequence, if any, and they must give employees an opportunity to respond. Employers may not count discipline from more than a year ago toward future disciplinary action, including termination.

Muhammad’s first day of work at Fast Food Express is June 1. As a new employee, he receives a handbook with his employer’s attendance policy and progressive discipline policy. The attendance policy requires employees to give two hours’ advance notice when they will miss a shift, unless the absence relates to an unforeseeable need to use safe and sick leave. The progressive discipline policy states that after three written warnings for violating a company policy or procedure, an employee may be terminated for cause.

On August 1, Muhammad does not come to work for his scheduled shift. It is a very busy day and, because of Muhammad’s absence, customers have to wait a long time for their orders. Although Fast Food Express has an established progressive discipline policy, it decides it wants to terminate Muhammad right away because of the negative impact his absence had on business. Can Fast Food Express terminate Muhammad?

No. Under Fast Food Express’ progressive discipline policy, the company may give Muhammad a first written warning but cannot terminate him.

Can an employer be more lenient with some employees than others?

No. Employers must apply the progressive discipline policy to all employees consistently.

What does it mean for a progressive discipline policy to be applied consistently?

An employer applies a progressive discipline policy consistently when all employees are subject to the same progressive discipline and employees who commit similar infractions receive equal treatment .

If an employer issues a regular or work schedule that violates NYC’s Fair Workweek Law, may the employer discipline or discharge employees who do not comply with the unlawful portions of the schedule?

No. An employer may not punish an employee who does not follow an unlawful schedule or part of a schedule.

Maria’s regular schedule at Fast Food Express is Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. On Monday, August 1, 2022, Maria’s manager gives her a work schedule for the week of Monday, August 15 that includes a shift on Thursday, August 18 from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Maria tells her manager that she is not able to work on Thursdays because of her class schedule. Maria’s manager informs her that if she wants to keep her job, she better show up to work on Thursday, August 18. Maria does not come to work on August 18, and her manager issues her a warning letter. Has the employer violated the law?

Yes. Because the work schedule varied from the regular schedule by more than 15%, Fast Food Express had to get Maria’s written consent before making the schedule change. Maria did not give written consent, so the change was illegal. The discipline Maria received was also unlawful.

What is the lookback period for discipline?

Employers may not consider discipline from more than 12 months (365 days) ago as a step toward applying more serious future discipline. An employer must provide an employee with a copy of any discipline issued to the employee within the past 12 months upon the employee’s request.

Johannes begins working for Grab and Go, a fast food establishment, on July 1, 2021. In 2021, Johannes is more than one hour late for work on August 15 and again on August 30. Johannes receives 1 point each time. On September 30, 2022, more than a year after his last lateness, Johannes is late again and receives 1 point. Assuming 3 points may lead to termination under Grab and Go’s progressive discipline policy, can Grab and Go count Johannes’ 2 points from 2021 when determining its disciplinary response in 2022?

No. Grab and Go may not count any lateness that occurred more than 12 months prior toward present discipline. In other words, Grab and Go can only apply the appropriate response for 1 point—not 3 points which could result in termination.

Food in a Flash, a fast food establishment, has a progressive discipline policy with the following steps for employee performance deficiencies:

Step 1: oral reprimand for the first occurrence Step 2: written warning for the second occurrence Step 3: mandatory retraining for the third occurrence Step 4: final written warning for the fourth occurrence

Alex received an oral reprimand 13 months ago, a written warning 10 months ago, mandatory retraining three months ago, and has again failed to perform as expected. Can Food in a Flash count the Step 1 oral reprimand toward a Step 4 final written warning?

No. Food in a Flash may not count the oral reprimand since that discipline occurred more than a year ago. Since they cannot consider that step, they cannot proceed to a Step 4 final written warning for Alex.

However, Food in a Flash may consider the written warning as Step 1 and the mandatory retraining as Step 2 to apply another mandatory retraining (Step 3) for Alex. Those disciplines occurred within a year.

What employee conduct or behavior cannot be included in an employer’s progressive discipline policy?

An employer cannot discipline employees for exercising rights they have under local, state, or federal law.

Food in a Flash’s progressive discipline policy requires an oral reprimand when an employee calls out of work less than two hours before the employee’s shift. Fran has worked for Food in a Flash for four months. Her child wakes up sick one morning, and Fran notifies her manager 1 ½ hours before her shift that she needs time off work to care for her child. Can Food in a Flash give Fran an oral reprimand?

No. Fran has rights under NYC’s Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law. Under that law, employers may only require notice of the need to use safe and sick leave for unforeseeable reasons as soon as practicable. Fran provided notice as soon as she became aware that she needed to use sick leave. Food in a Flash cannot discipline Fran for exercising and using a protected right. Visit nyc.gov/workers for more information about NYC’s Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law.

Fast Food Express’s progressive discipline policy authorizes a written warning when an employee is insubordinate to the manager on duty. Heather is finishing up her shift when Alejandro, the manager on duty, tells her that an employee scheduled to work the next day just called out sick. Alejandro tells Heather she needs to report to work the next day at 12:00 p.m. instead of her scheduled start time of 3:00 p.m. Heather says she cannot work the additional hours before her scheduled 3:00 p.m. shift because she has lunch plans with her friends. Can Fast Food Express write up Heather for insubordination?

No. Heather has rights under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law. Under the law, employers may not require employees to work additional hours offered less than 14 days in advance. Heather had the right to decline the additional hours. Fast Food Express cannot discipline her for exercising her rights.

Are there any exceptions to the requirement to follow a progressive discipline policy when there is just cause to discharge an employee?

Yes. An employer may fire a fast food worker for just cause for egregious failure to perform job duties or for egregious misconduct. The employer does not have to apply a progressive discipline policy in these circumstances.

What is egregious failure to perform job duties?

Egregious failure to perform job duties is when an employee willfully refuses to perform work for the majority of time on a shift.

An employee’s lateness or failure to appear for a scheduled work shift is not an egregious failure to perform job duties.

What is egregious misconduct?

Egregious misconduct is workplace conduct that is so outrageous, dangerous, or illegal that an employer cannot reasonably expect to correct it through progressive discipline. Depending on the circumstances, examples may include:

  • violence or threats of violence;
  • theft;
  • sexual harassment;
  • race discrimination;
  • willful destruction of property.

An employee’s lateness or failure to appear for a scheduled work shift is not egregious misconduct.

Fast Food Express takes customer relations very seriously. Mica had been working for Fast Food Express for five months when a customer complains that she said, “just deal with it,” when the customer reported being given the wrong size soda cup during the lunch rush. Can Fast Food Express terminate Mica right away for egregious misconduct?

No. Egregious misconduct is workplace conduct that is so outrageous, dangerous, or illegal that an employer cannot reasonably expect to correct it through progressive discipline. If, after conducting a fair and objective investigation, Fast Food Express determines that the customer report is true, Fast Food Express may begin applying its progressive discipline policy. However, it cannot terminate Mica since her conduct did not rise to the level of egregious misconduct.

Jacob, an employee, sexually assaults his colleague, Miranda, after a closing shift. The employer’s fair and objective investigation confirms this allegation, but the police investigation is still ongoing. Can Jacob's employer fire him for egregious misconduct? Or must the employer wait for the conclusion of any police investigation?

Jacob’s employer does not have to wait for the conclusion of a police investigation to fire him for egregious misconduct. Jacob’s conduct was so outrageous, dangerous, or illegal that his employer cannot reasonably expect to correct it through progressive discipline.

What factors are considered in an enforcement action or court case when an employee challenges a discharge?

If the employer claims the discharge was for just cause, factors that are considered include:

  • The employee knew or should have known the employer’s policy, rule, or practice that is the basis for the discipline. AND
  • The employer provided relevant and adequate training to the employee. AND
  • The employer’s policy, rule, or practice, including the use of progressive discipline, was reasonable and applied consistently. AND
  • The employer undertook a fair and objective investigation into the job performance or misconduct. AND
  • • The employee violated the policy, rule, or practice or committed the misconduct that is the basis for the discipline or discharge.

Other relevant factors may also be considered in a “just cause” determination.

See III. c. Layoffs for Bona Fide Economic Reasons on page 39 for factors that are considered if the employer claims that the discharge was for a bona fide economic reason.

What is relevant and adequate training?

Relevant and adequate training is an initial and ongoing instruction on how the employer expects the employee to perform job duties, to conduct themselves in the fast food establishment, and to comply with workplace policies and procedures. It may include training on:

  • preparing and serving food;
  • cleaning;
  • using tools and equipment;
  • handling payments;
  • interacting with customers;
  • other typical job duties;
  • workplace policies and procedures regarding attendance, punctuality, cooperation, and other standards of conduct;
  • specific job duties or conduct where the employee failed to meet expectations.

What is a fair and objective investigation?

A fair and objective investigation requires that an employer issue discipline based on accurate information. The scope of investigation depends on the circumstances of the situation.

In some cases, a conversation with the employee may be enough.

In other cases, the employer may need to take additional relevant steps, such as speaking with other employees, observing the worksite, or reviewing documents.

How can an employer know whether an employee “knew or should have known” of the employer’s policy, rule, or practice?

Some policies, rules, or practices are written in employee handbooks or other training materials. Others may be conveyed orally. During the progressive discipline process, the employer should make sure the employee understands the relevant policy, rule, or practice that led to the disciplinary response and include a written summary of the conversation in the record of discipline.

c. Layoffs for Bona Fide Economic Reasons

When can an employer lay off an employee?

An employer can only lay off employees if the employer closes all or part of the business because it is experiencing a drop in profit, sales, or production.

The employer must lay off employees in reverse order of seniority, with longest-serving workers laid off last.

What is a “bona fide economic reason” to lay off an employee?

An employer has a “bona fide economic reason” to discharge a worker (or reduce a worker’s hours) if the employer can no longer employ the worker because the employer has experienced a downturn in business (i.e., a reduction in volume of production, sales, or profit) and needs to close all or part of the business, downsize, or reorganize.

A discharge due to a bona fide economic reason is also known as a layoff.

How must an employer prove that a discharge was for a bona fide economic reason?

Employers must use business records to prove that a discharge was the result of a business’s closing, downsizing, or organizational change in response to a reduction in volume of production, sales, or profit. Records may include:

  • a. financial records, such as tax returns, income statements, data showing historical trends in the industry, profit and loss statements, monthly gross revenue schedules, and balance sheets;
  • b. records showing a reduction in business or a full or partial closing to comply with government-issued orders or health and safety guidelines; or
  • c. records showing that operations could not continue due to: threats to employees or the employer’s property; failure of a public utility or shutdown of public transportation; fire, flood, or other natural disaster; government-declared state of emergency; severe weather conditions that pose a threat to employee safety.

Can employers with seasonal business reduce the hours on employees’ regular schedules in a slow season?

An employer must give a single regular schedule to each employee, regardless of how busy the employer is or the seasonality of the business’s labor needs. An employer may only reduce an employee’s hours by more than 15% in a slow season if:

  • the employer has records to show that the employee requested or consented to the change; or
  • • the employer has a bona fide economic reason; that is, it has fully or partially closed operations or made technological or organizational changes to the business in response to a reduction in volume of production, sales, or profit.

An employer may not lay off employees during its less busy seasons without meeting one of these requirements for reducing employees’ hours. An employer who lays off employees for a bona fide economic reason must do so in reverse order of seniority and rehire laid-off employees in order of seniority if it begins hiring again.

Can an employer give a worker two different regular schedules, one for slow season and another for busy season? No.

When an employer needs to cut shifts from its schedule, which employees may the employer discharge?

If an employer needs to discharge an employee or reduce an employee’s regular schedule for a bona fide economic reason, the employer must choose the employee with the least seniority at the affected location.

What is seniority?

Seniority is the ranking of workers based on length of employment, starting from the first day of work, including any probation period.

If a worker’s employment is interrupted by more than six months, the calculation for seniority restarts when the worker resumes work. However, the following interruptions do not restart the calculation:

  • military service;
  • illness;
  • educational leave;
  • any other leave protected by law;
  • layoff due to a bona fide economic reason;
  • unlawful discharge.

Visit nyc.gov/dcwp for a seniority tracking tool.

Fast Food Express hires Jaysen on January 1, 2022. Jaysen quits on March 1, 2022 and moves to California. After several months, he returns to New York, and Fast Food Express rehires him on July 1, 2022.

Fast Food Express hires Anthony on February 1, 2022.

Fast Food Express hires Yesenia on June 1, 2022.

Fast Food Express has no other employees at the location where Jaysen, Anthony, and Yesenia work. Jaysen works Saturdays and Sundays, Anthony works Mondays and Tuesdays, and Yesenia works Wednesdays and Thursdays. Due to a reduction in revenue on the weekends, Fast Food Express plans to close on Saturdays and Sundays and lay off one employee. Which employee can Fast Food Express discharge?

Fast Food Express can discharge Yesenia because she is the least senior. Jaysen is the most senior, followed by Anthony, and then Yesenia. Even though Jaysen separated from employment on March 1, 2022, his break from employment was less than six months, so his length of employment is still the longest.

Even though Jaysen had worked weekends, Fast Food Express is not obligated to give Jaysen his regular schedule since it is no longer open on Saturdays and Sundays.

Who has the burden of proof to show that a discharge was lawful?

The employer must prove that a discharge was based on just cause or a bona fide economic reason.

What information must the employer collect from employees upon discharge?

The employer must request updated contact information from all laid-off employees within five days of discharge so the employer can send offers of reinstatement or restoration of hours over the next 12 months.

If an employer lays off workers and later anticipates hiring new ones, what are the employer’s obligations?

Before an employer can offer newly available regular shifts to current workers or hire new workers, the employer must make reasonable efforts, including by email, text, or phone, to offer the shifts to employees who were laid off within the last 12 months in order of seniority.

Must employers offer shifts to all employees who were discharged for bona fide economic reasons? An employer does not need to offer reinstatement or restoration of hours to employees discharged for bona fide economic reasons who:

  • have been discharged for longer than 12 months (365 days);
  • notified the employer in writing that they do not want future shifts or, when applicable, do not want shifts for certain days, times, or locations;
  • have not provided updated contact information and their phone number and email address on file are no longer operational;
  • have already been reinstated or had at least 85% of their baseline regular schedule before discharge restored;
  • refused reinstatement or restoration of hours at their previous location.

An employer also does not need to offer reinstatement or restoration of hours to employees discharged for bona fide economic reasons if the available shifts are temporary and not recurring.

How much time do discharged workers have to accept shifts offered by employers? Discharged workers have seven days to accept an offer of reinstatement or restoration of hours.

How much time do discharged workers have to return to work following an offer of reinstatement or restoration of hours?

An employer may not condition reinstatement or restoration of hours on an employee’s ability to return to work or work the additional hours less than 14 days from the date of the offer. If necessary, the employer may schedule a current employee to work the shift temporarily.

What information must employers provide when notifying discharged employees of available shifts? Employers must include the following in the notification to discharged workers:

  • days, times, and locations of the shifts;
  • how the worker can accept the shifts;
  • that the worker has seven days to accept any of the shifts;
  • • that shifts will be awarded to the worker with the most seniority who accepts the shifts (if shifts are being offered to more than one worker).

What efforts must an employer make to offer shifts to an employee who was discharged for a bona fide economic reason?

Using the most updated contact information employees provided when they were laid off, an employer must email, text, or call employees to offer available shifts.

Shifts become available within 12 months of a layoff for bona fide economic reason. Employer notifies laid-off workers about available shifts and the criteria for assignment. Workers respond to accept the shifts or a portion of shifts. Employer awards shifts to workers with the most seniority. Employer offers any remaining shifts to current employees before hiring new employees. <!-- End of picture text -->

d. Retaliation

What is retaliation?

Retaliation is any action by an employer—or on an employer’s behalf—that could penalize or deter a worker or group of workers from exercising or attempting to exercise any right protected by the law. Retaliation includes:

  • threats
  • intimidation
  • discipline
  • discharge
  • demotion
  • suspension
  • harassment
  • cutting hours
  • informing other employers about a worker’s actions under the law
  • discrimination
  • actions related to immigration status

Retaliation is illegal under the law. Employers may not retaliate against workers exercising their rights under the law, even if workers do not explicitly refer to any specific law.

Retaliation exists when the protected activity was a motivating factor for a retaliatory act, even if other factors also motivated the retaliatory act.

Scenario :

Stanley manages the Bushwick branch of McDougal’s, part of a chain of fast food restaurants in Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey. Stanley tells Jack that he must work a 12-hour shift the next day. When Jack refuses, Stanley fires Jack and tells him he better leave before Stanley “clocks him one.” Janet and Peggy witness Jack’s firing. Which McDougal’s workers experienced retaliation?

Jack, Peggy, and Janet all have experienced retaliation. Stanley penalized Jack by firing him and threatened him with physical harm. Janet and Peggy could have been reasonably deterred from exercising their rights after witnessing the incident between Stanley and Jack.

What does it mean for a fast food worker to “exercise their rights”? Workers may exercise their rights under the law in a variety of ways. This list gives some examples but is not exhaustive:

  • Refusing to work a shift that was scheduled in violation of the law, such as: o a shift they did not consent to work or for which they were not given 14 days’ advance notice o two shifts over two days with fewer than 11 hours between shifts
  • Requesting premium pay for a shift that was scheduled with less than 14 days’ notice
  • Requesting a copy of their schedule or a current version of all workers’ schedules at the fast food establishment where they work
  • Saying NO to a lawful request to take another shift with less than 14 days’ notice
  • Asking where the current written schedule is posted
  • Pointing out that the required notice of rights isn’t posted
  • Filing a complaint with DCWP for alleged violations of the law
  • Communicating with any person, including coworkers, about any violation of the law
  • Participating in a court or administrative proceeding about an alleged violation of the law
  • Informing another person of that person’s potential rights under the law
  • Telling an employer that they believe the employer is not applying the progressive discipline policy properly or consistently
  • Raising concerns about discrepancies between the regular schedule and the work schedule

What should employees do if an employer retaliates or the employee fears retaliation?

Workers should contact DCWP or an attorney if they fear retaliation or have experienced retaliation recently. DCWP takes reports of employer retaliation very seriously. Depending on the circumstances, DCWP may require an employer not to take retaliatory action, to reinstate a worker, and to comply with the law going forward. Workers may also receive payments of back wages, premium pay, and other relief.

Does the law protect workers from retaliation if workers mistakenly, but in good faith, exercise their rights?

Yes.

IV. Notice and Recordkeeping

a. Notice of Rights_How must covered employers inform workers about NYC’s Fair Workweek Law?

The required notice “NYC FAST FOOD WORKERS’ RIGHTS” is available on the DCWP website at nyc.gov/workers . Covered employers must post the notice where employees can easily see it at each NYC workplace. Notices should be printed on and scaled to fill an 11” x 17” paper.

In which language must an employer post the notice?

Employers must post the notice in English and in any other language that is the primary language of at least 5% of the workers at a workplace (1 out of 20, 5 out of 100, 10 out of 200, etc.), if the notice is available in that other language on the DCWP website.

There are 10 workers at a fast food establishment. Four workers speak Spanish primarily, and one worker speaks Polish primarily. All have limited English ability. In which languages must the employer post the required notice?

Forty percent (40%) of the workers primarily speak Spanish, and 10% of the workers primarily speak Polish. Because Spanish and Polish are the primary languages of more than 5% of the workers at the worksite, the employer must get the required notice in English, as well as Spanish and Polish (if available), from the DCWP website and post the notices where workers can see them.

b. Recordkeeping

What records must employers keep under the law?

Covered employers must retain electronic records documenting their compliance with each of the requirements of NYC’s Fair Workweek Law. Employers should carefully review Section 7-603 of the Rules of the City of New York to ensure they are creating and keeping all required records.

How long must employers maintain records under the law?

Covered employers must retain records for a period of three years.

Must an employer provide its records to DCWP?

Yes. If DCWP requests records as part of an investigation into compliance with or violations of NYC’s Fair Workweek Law, employers must provide the records.

What happens if a covered employer does not maintain records as required by the law?

An employer’s failure to maintain or produce records to DCWP may result in a “rebuttable presumption” against the employer in the event of a lawsuit or enforcement action. This means that the burden will be on the employer to show that the employer did not violate the law.

May employers maintain required records electronically?

Yes. Employers may create or maintain any of the required records in a scheduling application or other electronic recordkeeping system. Employers must ensure that:

  • electronically stored records are maintained in their original format for three years;
  • records can be exported to a nonproprietary, machine-readable data format;
  • there are no restrictions in the recordkeeping system that would limit the employer’s ability to produce required records to DCWP; and
  • the electronic recordkeeping system does not overwrite or destroy any of the records an employer is required by law to maintain.

For example, scheduling applications must be configured so that when an employer makes updates to a work schedule, the system retains and does not overwrite the original version of the work schedule and the date it was provided to employees.

V. Enforcement

Who enforces NYC’s Fair Workweek Law?

DCWP enforces the law. Workers can contact DCWP to:

  • File a complaint.
  • Find out more about the law.
  • Get a referral for other resources to protect and enforce their rights under the law.

DCWP is committed to maintaining the confidentiality of complainants.

Who can file a complaint about a potential violation of NYC’s Fair Workweek Law?

Any person, including fast food workers and their representatives, or related organizations, may file a complaint about a possible violation of the law.

Where can I file a complaint?

You can file a complaint with DCWP. To reach DCWP:

  • Call 311 (212-NEW-YORK outside NYC). Ask for “Fair Workweek Law.”
  • Email OLPS@dcwp.nyc.gov
  • Visit nyc.gov/workers

DCWP can also give complainants information about employee rights or how to bring a private legal action in court against an employer.

How long do I have to file a complaint?

You must file a complaint within two years of when you learned (or should have learned) of the violation of the law.

What happens after I file a complaint?

DCWP investigates the complaint. DCWP may request information or documents from an employer under investigation and interview witnesses. If DCWP determines that an employer violated the law, the employer may be responsible for money damages and other forms of relief to affected workers, as well as fines to the City.

Are complainants’ identities kept confidential?

DCWP will keep the identity of complainants confidential unless disclosure is required by law. DCWP will notify complainants before disclosing their identity whenever possible and generally attempts to keep identities of workers confidential unless the worker consents.

Does my immigration status affect my ability to file a complaint?

No. All workers have the same rights and protections under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law, regardless of immigration status. DCWP does not collect any information about a worker’s immigration status to pursue a complaint.

Must DCWP receive a complaint in order to investigate an employer?

No. DCWP can also investigate employers on its own initiative.

What does DCWP do to ensure that employers comply with the law?

DCWP conducts investigations that may include document requests, interviews with witnesses, and visits to worksites. If, as a result of an investigation, DCWP determines that an employer has violated one or more provisions of NYC’s Fair Workweek Law, DCWP may seek monetary relief for workers, civil penalties, and/or commitments to future compliance through settlement or through litigation at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH).

As of January 1, 2022, workers who believe they were fired without just cause or laid off without a bona fide economic reason can request arbitration through a program administered by DCWP.

DCWP also regularly conducts outreach and education to employers, workers, and the public about NYC’s Fair Workweek Law.

What happens if an employer violates the law?

Workers may be entitled to monetary relief for an employer’s violations. Employees whose hours were cut unlawfully or who were terminated without just cause may be entitled to back pay or reinstatement. In addition to payments owed to an employee, an employer may be liable for fines payable to the City for violations of the law.

An employer might receive a court order requiring it to comply with the requirements of the law.

What types of fines could covered employers have to pay for violating the law?

Employers may also be subject to the following fines:

  • $500 for a first violation
  • up to $750 for a second violation within a two-year period
  • up to $1,000 for subsequent violations within a two-year period

If an employer had a worker sign a document saying that the worker gave up the right to relief under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law, can the worker still file a complaint with DCWP against the employer? Yes. Any agreement to limit fast food workers’ rights under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law is invalid. Also, DCWP might investigate the employer on its own initiative whether or not workers file a complaint.

What if an employer repeatedly violates the law?

When there is reason to believe that an employer is engaged in a pattern or practice of violations, the NYC Law Department may file an action in court against that employer seeking relief for workers, fines (including an additional fine of up to $15,000), and injunctive relief.

VI. Private Right of Action and Arbitration_Can individuals bring their own action in court against an employer? Yes.

Any person or organization alleging a violation of NYC’s Fair Workweek Law may bring a civil action in court to seek damages and other relief.

Individuals must bring an action under NYC’s Fair Workweek Law within two years of the date that the individual learned, or should have learned, of the violation.

Can individuals file private arbitrations instead of going to court or filing a complaint with DCWP? Yes.

As of January 1, 2022, DCWP administers a private arbitration program that employees alleging wrongful discharge may use instead of the DCWP complaint or civil litigation process. This arbitration process is only available for wrongful discharge cases.

Can an individual file a complaint with DCWP and bring a civil action or arbitration at the same time? No.

If individuals file a complaint with DCWP first, they cannot bring their own lawsuit or seek arbitration unless they withdraw the complaint in writing or DCWP dismisses the complaint “without prejudice,” generally meaning that the complaint was neither decided nor settled.

If individuals file a civil action in court or arbitration first, they cannot file a complaint with DCWP unless the civil action or arbitration is withdrawn or dismissed without prejudice. When a party files suit in court, the party must give notice of the lawsuit to DCWP.

DCWP may still investigate and pursue a case against an employer, even when a worker has a case pending against that employer in court.