Managing Leave Under New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (Practical Law Practice Note, Thomson Reuters, 2026)
A Practice Note that describes a New York City employer's obligations under the Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (ESSTA), also known as the Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law. This Practice Note outlines key compliance requirements for employers, including the amount of paid or unpaid leave owed based on employer size and net income. It details the rules for different types of leave, such as safe time for victims of domestic violence or stalking, sick time for health-related needs, and the separate bank of paid prenatal leave. This resource also explains methods for granting leave, like accrual and front-loading, and addresses essential recordkeeping, notice, and written policy requirements. Crucially, this Practice Note explores the interaction between ESSTA and other leave laws, including the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and New York State's Paid Family Leave (NYPFL), and discusses the anti-retaliation provisions, enforcement by the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP), and the private right of action available to employees.
New York City employers must set and enforce manageable policies in compliance with New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (ESSTA), also known as the Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law. New York City employers must also abide by a variety of other federal, state, and local medical or disability leave laws. Employers that do not comply with applicable safe and sick time and leave laws face potentially significant legal and financial liability.
This Note describes an employer's obligations regarding safe and sick leave governed by the ESSTA. Specifically, this Note addresses:
- New York City rules governing safe and sick leave.
- The affirmative duty that requires employers to notify employees of the law and its entitlements.
- New York City's Department of Consumer Affairs' (DCA) interpretation of safe and sick leave issues not clearly addressed by the city's laws.
- Other potentially applicable leave laws.
Overview of New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Law
The rights of New York City employees to accrue and take paid sick leave under the Earned Sick Time Act became effective on April 1, 2014. As of May 1, 2014, covered employers were required to give written notice to employees of their rights and entitlements under the new law (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a); see Employer Notice and Recordkeeping Requirements). On May 5, 2018, the law was renamed the Earned Safe and Sick Time Act and amended to require covered employers to also provide paid "safe" time off for circumstances resulting from the employee or a covered family member of the employee being the victim of a family offense matter, a sexual offense, stalking, or human trafficking (see Legal Update: New York City Paid Sick Leave Safe Time Amendments Effective May 5, 2018). Effective September 30, 2020, the ESSTA was amended to conform to New York State's recently enacted Paid Sick Leave Law (PSSL), with some provisions going into effect upon amendment and all provisions effective January 1, 2021 (see Legal Update, New York City Amends Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (ESSTA)). In late 2021, the New York City Counsel passed a temporary amendment to the ESSTA requiring employers to provide up to four hours of additional leave to employees to accompany their child to receive a COVID-19 vaccination or care for their child who cannot attend school or childcare due to vaccine side effects. This temporary leave applied from November 6, 2021 to December 31, 2022 (see Legal Update, New York City Enacts Paid COVID-19 Child Vaccination Leave).
On July 2, 2025, amendments to the ESSTA's accompanying rules went into effect providing for 20 hours of paid prenatal care leave in response to the analagous New York State law (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216; see also N.Y. Lab. Law § 196-b(4-a)). Effective February 22, 2026, amendments to ESSTA require all New York City employers regardless of size to provide employees with a baseline level of 32 hours of unpaid sick and safe leave, frontloaded at the beginning of each year, and expanding the permitted uses of safe and sick leave (see N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(k)). Implementing rules regarding this new unpaid leave requirement become effective July 23, 2026 (Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP): Protected Time Off Under the Earned Safe and Sick Time Act).
Beyond the required paid prenatal leave and baseline bank of unpaid leave, the ESSTA requires all employers with employees working in New York City to provide additional safe and sick time based on the employer's size, as follows:
- All employers that employ fewer than five employees and had a net income of less than one million dollars in the last tax year must provide employees with up to 40 hours of unpaid safe and sick leave.
-
- Employers must provide up to 40 hours of paid safe and sick leave if they:
- employ fewer than five employees and had a net income of more than one million dollars in the last tax year;
- employ one or more domestic workers; or
- employ between five and 99 employees, regardless of net income of the business.
- Employers that employ 100 or more employees must provide up to 56 hours of paid safe and sick leave.
Because all but the smallest employers are required to pay employees for this leave, this Practice Note generally refers to this time as "paid safe and sick leave." (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(a) and (b).)
Domestic workers are subject to special rules (see Paid Safe and Sick Leave for Domestic Workers).
Employers maintaining paid time off (PTO) policies which combine paid vacation and sick leave benefits should evaluate whether their policies are economically viable because they must comply with all aspects of the ESSTA.
At minimum, employers should:
- Have a written policy showing compliance with the ESSTA, including placing any limits on safe and sick leave as allowed. The safe and sick leave policy can be stand-alone or included in an employee handbook provided to new hires.
- Obtain a signed and dated employee acknowledgment of receipt and review.
- When a change is made to the leave policy, notify all employees of the change by highlighting the change and re-issuing an updated policy.
For information on written ESSTA policy requirements, see Written Safe and Sick Leave Policy Requirements and Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP): Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(35).
Compliance with Other Federal and State Laws
Employers must also ensure they comply with any applicable New York state and federal leave laws, including the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and New York State's Paid Family Leave (NYPFL) and Paid Sick Leave Law (PSLL) (see Interaction with Other Protected Leaves). Under the ESSTA, whichever law provides greater rights or protections to the employee is the one that applies (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-923).
In addition to state and federal laws:
- Employers must abide by all contracts, CBAs, employee benefit plans, or any other agreements that provide greater sick leave benefits than the ESSTA, although construction and grocery industry employees covered by a CBA may waive the ESSTA's provisions (N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§ 20-916(a) and 20-922(b)).
- Employers serving as federal government contractors or subcontractors on construction and other covered types of contracts and engage in new or replacement contracts must provide up to 56 hours (seven days) of paid sick leave per year (Executive Order 13706, Establishing Paid Sick Leave for Federal Contractors). The Final Rule implementing the Executive Order, required posting, and Questions and Answers are available on the U.S. Department of Labor 's website.
Understanding the interaction of other state and federal leave laws with the ESSTA is crucial because many of those laws may provide more generous benefits and protections, while the ESSTA is more generous in other respects. For example, one leave law may apply to all employees, while another provides benefits to only nonexempt employees meeting certain eligibility requirements.
Covered EmployersManaging Leave Under New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (NY), Practical Law Practice Note w-018-0164
The ESSTA applies to all private, nonprofit, and household employers employing any individual in New York City. The ESSTA does not cover governmental agencies. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions I(4) and II(2).)
All New York City employers are covered by the prenatal leave requirements (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l)). After February 22, 2026, all covered employers regardless of size must provide employees with a baseline 32 hours of unpaid leave annually (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(k)).
Employers must also provide accrual based safe and sick leave according to their size as follows:
- All employers that employ fewer than five employees and had a net income of less than one million dollars in the last tax year must provide employees with up to 40 hours of unpaid safe and sick time.
-
- Employers must provide up to 40 hours of paid safe and sick time if they:
- employ fewer than five employees and had a net income of more than one million dollars in the last tax year;
- employ one or more domestic workers; or
- employ between five and 99 employees, regardless of net income of the business.
- Employers that employ 100 or more employees must provide up to 56 hours of paid safe and sick leave.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a) and (b).)
Evaluating Employer Size
When counting employees to determine employer size, employers must count all employees who work for pay on a full-time, part-time, seasonal, or temporary basis, whether the employees work for the employer in New York City or elsewhere. Joint employers must each count joint employees towards their own total number of employees. (DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions I(6) and (9)-(13).)
If employer size increases from fewer than five employees to between five and 99 employees, the employer's duty to provide paid safe and sick leave begins on the date of the increase. Similarly, if employer size increases from 99 or fewer to 100 or more employees, an employee's right to use additional paid safe and sick leave (up to 56 hours versus up to 40 hours) starts on the date of the increase. Any decrease in the total number of employees does not reduce the number of safe and sick leave hours employees are entitled to until the following calendar year. (DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question I(8).)
Under the ESSTA, "calendar year" means any consecutive 12-month period of time as determined by the employer (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a) (definition of "calendar year")).
An employer that is part of a chain business or that has multiple locations must count all employees at each business or location if:
- The employer owns at least 30% of each location.
- Each location is engaged in the same business or operates under a franchise agreement.
- The multiple locations collectively employ at least five employees.
(DCA: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question I(9).)
Covered Employees
Most employees who work in New York City are covered by the ESSTA. Employees covered include:
- Full-time employees.
- Part-time employees.
- Temporary and seasonal employees.
- Per diem and "on call" employees.
- Domestic workers.
- Transitional jobs program employees.
- Undocumented employees.
- Employees who are family members but not owners.
- Employees who live outside New York City but work in New York City.
- Employees who telecommute or work remotely from New York City.
- Owners who are considered employees under New York State Labor Law (NYLL).
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a) (definition of "employee"); see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions II(1)(7).)
Employees Not Covered by the ESSTA
The ESSTA does not cover certain individuals, including:
- Federal, state, or local government employees.
- Independent contractors .
- Participants in work experience programs under New York's social services law.
- Participants in federal work-study programs and those compensated by qualified scholarship programs.
- Certain employees subject to a collective bargaining agreement .
-
- Certain hourly professional employees that:
- are licensed by the New York State Department of Education;
- call in for work assignments;
- have requisite independence; and
- are paid an average hourly wage which is at least four times the federal minimum wage for hours worked during the calendar year.
- Business owners not meeting the definition of an employee under the NYLL.
- Employees telecommuting and not living in New York City, except telecommuting employees are covered for any work hours when they are physically in New York City.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§ 20-912(a), 20-913(a)(f), and 20-916(a); see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions II(9)-(11).)
Eligibility to Use Safe and Sick Leave
A covered employee is granted baseline unpaid leave and eligible to begin accruing additional leave starting on the employee's first day of employment. Employees may take leave as soon as it accrues. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(d) and (k).) Employers cannot require an employee to find a replacement worker as a condition to use safe and sick leave (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(e)).
If an employee is rehired by the same employer within six months of the employee's departure, the employer must reinstate previously accrued unused leave, unless it paid the employee for unused sick and safe leave before the employee's departure (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(i) and (j); see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(20)).
Paid Safe and Sick Leave for Domestic Workers
Domestic workers are workers who provide care, companionship, housekeeping, or any other domestic service in a home, whether employed by an agency or a household (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question II(3)). Domestic workers are entitled to accrue leave based on employer size as follows:
- Employers of one or more domestic workers must provide paid leave up to 40 hours per calendar year.
- Employers of domestic workers that employ 100 or more employees must provide paid leave up to 56 hour per calendar year.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question II(3).)
Beyond being entitled to paid leave regardless of the size of the employer, domestic workers are entitled to all the same benefits and subject to the same restrictions as all other employees under the ESSTA.
Paid Prenatal Leave
All New York employers must provide employees with 20 hours of paid leave per 52-week period to be used for prenatal healthcare service appointments, including fertility treatments, during or related to the employee's pregnancy. Only employees directly receiving health care related to pregnancy can use prenatal leave, employees who are not the pregnant parent are not eligible (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216; DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(3)). Paid prenatal leave must be included in employers' safe and sick leave policies under ESSTA. Policies must be contained in a single document, whether it is a stand-alone written policy or a section of a policy manual, such as an employee handbook (see R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-211(a); DCWP: Rules for Safe and Sick Leave Policies).
Prenatal leave is a stand-alone benefit, so employers cannot require this leave to be used concurrently or instead of leave under ESSTA or any other applicable leave law or policy (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(6) and (7); and N.Y. Lab. Law § 196-b(4-a)). All employers, regardless of size, are required to provide prenatal leave to their employees (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(1)). Where prenatal healthcare appointments could fall under multiple available leave entitlements or policies, the employer cannot require an employee to choose to use one type of leave over another, or to exhaust one type of leave before using another.
Using Paid Prenatal Leave
Employees are entitled to 20 hours of leave per 52-week period. The 52-week period begins on the first day an employee uses prenatal leave. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216(b); and DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(4).)
Employees are eligible for paid prenatal leave for health care services and appointments during pregnancy or related to pregnancy, specifically including:
- Physical examinations.
- Medical procedures.
- Monitoring and testing.
- Discussions with a health care provider related to a pregnancy.
- End of pregnancy care.
- Fertility treatment.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-201(c); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(2); N.Y. Lab. Law § 196-b(4-a).)
NYSDOL guidance clarifies that post-pregnancy care does not qualify for prenatal leave. However, end of pregnancy care (not defined) is a qualifying reason. (NYSDOL: New York State Paid Prenatal Leave: Frequently Asked Questions.)
Prenatal leave must be paid at an employee's regular rate of pay, or the minimum wage, whichever is greater (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216 and N.Y. Lab. Law § 196-b(4-a)).
Carryover of Paid Prenatal Leave
Prenatal leave differs from safe and sick leave as to carryover. Employers need not carry over unused paid prenatal leave to a subsequent 52-week period, although they may do so if they wish (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216; DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(4) and N.Y. Lab. Law § 196-b(4-a)).
How to Grant Paid Safe and Sick Leave
Beginning February 22, 2026, all employers must provide employees with a baseline 32 hours of unpaid safe and sick leave upon hire and annually thereafter. This frontloaded leave is separate from any additional paid leave that may be accrued throughout the year as required by ESSTA.
Employers can grant additional safe and sick leave required under the ESSTA using one of three methods:
- Using an accrual basis (see Accrual Basis).
- "Front-loading" a lump sum, which is less administratively burdensome (see Front-Loading Method).
- Implementing their own leave policy if it meets certain requirements (see Using the Employer's Own Leave Policies).
Because additional leave beyond the baseline 32 unpaid hours is generally required to be paid leave for all but the smallest employers (see Covered Employers), employers should consider the relative advantages and disadvantages of the various methods for granting this type of leave.
Granting and Carryover of Baseline Unpaid Leave
Beginning February 22, 2026, all covered employers, regardless of size, are required to provide employees with a baseline 32 hours of unpaid safe and sick leave. This leave must be granted in a "front-loading" manner, meaning it becomes available to employees all at once:
- On February 22, 2026.
- On the employee's first day of employment for employees starting after February 22, 2026.
- At the beginning of each calendar year after February 22, 2026.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(k).)
Employers are not required to carry over these unpaid leave hours into subsequent years if the employee does not use them during the calendar year in which they are granted (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(k)).
Accrual Basis
Under the accrual basis, employers must grant additional paid safe and sick leave throughout the year at a minimum rate of one hour for every 30 hours, up to a maximum of 40 or 56 hours per calendar year (depending on employer size), on their employees' first day of employment (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(b)).
Under this option, exempt employees are presumed to work 40 hours per workweek. If their normal workweek is less than 40 hours, then accrual is based on their normal workweek. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(e).)
For nonexempt employees, both regular and overtime hours are counted toward the accrual rate of one hour for every 30 hours worked (see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(5)).
Annual Carryover and Limits on Annual Use of Safe and Sick Leave
When employers use the accrual method, an employee may carry over up to 40 or 56 hours of unused paid safe and sick leave from one calendar year to the next (depending on employer size), unless the employer both:
- Has a policy of paying employees for accrued but unused paid safe and sick leave at the end of the calendar year.
- Front-loads 40 or 56 hours of paid safe and sick leave (depending on employer size) on the first day of the next calendar year (see Front-Loading Method).
(N.Y.C. Admin Code § 20-913(a)(h); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-214(f); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions VI(12)–(14).)
If an employee's paid safe and sick leave time balance exceeds 40 or 56 hours in a single calendar year due to carryover, the employer is only required to allow the employee to use up to 40 or 56 hours in the calendar year, depending on the employer size and accrual limit (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(b).) Employees continue to accrue leave at the rate of one hour for every 30 hours worked up to the annual accrual limit of 40 or 56 hours, depending on employer size.
Employers are not required to carry over unpaid safe and sick leave balances from year to year (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-214(f)).
The employer's counsel should also consider potential tax consequences when evaluating carryover provisions (see Tax Considerations).
Front-Loading Method
Alternatively, employers may grant paid safe and sick leave by providing each eligible employee with 40 or 56 hours of paid safe and sick leave at the start of each calendar year, depending on employer size (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(b); see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(17)).
This approach can be easier to administer since employers can avoid tracking the accrual of paid safe and sick leave for each covered employee if they front-load the full 40 or 56 hours at the time of hire and at the beginning of every calendar year. (For more information, see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions VI(17) and (18).)
For part-time employees, an employer can front-load the hours of paid safe and sick leave those employees can accrue based on the hours they are anticipated to work. However, if the employer front-loads less than 40 or 56 hours (depending on employer size), it must still track the employees' hours worked and accrual of paid safe and sick leave because the part-time employees can work more hours than anticipated. Employers must allow employees who are front-loaded less than 40 or 56 hours to use up to 40 or 56 hours of paid safe and sick leave in a calendar year if they have accrued it. (For more information, see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(18).)
Employers who front-load paid safe and sick leave must either:
- Carry over all unused paid safe and sick leave to the next calendar year.
- Pay out all unused paid safe and sick leave at the end of the year before front-loading 40 or 56 hours of leave (depending on employer size) at the beginning of the next calendar year.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(h); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VI(14).)
Deciding on Using the Front-Loading or Accrual Method
The main advantage of the front-loading method is it can be easier for employers to administer and be in legal compliance.
The potential disadvantage in using front-loading instead of accrual is in a workforce with a high turnover rate, employees may take all their sick leave right after receiving it and then terminate their employment soon afterwards.
For employers using the accrual method, they may find it important to designate a calendar year or 12-month period where paid safe and sick leave use may be less prone to abuse by employees. For example, employers that need employees to work during the busy year-end holiday season may find that using the January-December calendar year designation is problematic as employees can wait to bank up the accrued paid safe and sick leave and take it all at the end of the year.
Employers do not have to use one particular method for their entire workforce. For example, they can decide on using the frontloading method for their regular full-time employees and the accrual method for their part-time and seasonal employees. They may also wish to have a hybrid approach, such as front-loading a certain amount of paid safe and sick leave each year and then accruing the rest. Employers should consult with counsel to assure compliance with all applicable laws and that the written policy is clear and accurate.
Using the Employer's Own Leave Policies
Employers implementing their own paid safe and sick leave or PTO policies, including for paid vacation or personal days, may continue them if they satisfy certain requirements under the ESSTA. This includes:
- Providing at least the statutory minimum amount of paid and unpaid safe and sick leave.
- Allowing its use for all ESSTA purposes and under the same conditions. Employers do not have to provide additional time for safe and sick leave if their PTO policy meets these requirements.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(c).)
An employer's leave policies must satisfy the ESSTA rules for both annual use and total accrual of paid leave. Employers may provide a faster accrual rate for leave than the ESSTA requires. Additionally, employer policies must account for the 32 hours of unpaid leave also required by ESSTA. Employers may choose to grant these as paid hours, but either way must ensure that employees are granted the required number of hours that they are eligible for under ESSTA. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(b).)
Employers with PTO policies may want to consider whether to eliminate PTO and provide separate banks of sick and vacation leave to simplify and ensure compliance with all the ESSTA's requirements. For more information on PTO policies, see Standard Clause, Paid Time Off/Vacation and Sick Leave Policy Clause (NY). For information on written ESSTA policy requirements, see Written Safe and Sick Leave Policy Requirements and DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(35). For a sample ESSTA policy, see Standard Document, New York City Safe and Sick Leave Policy (NY).
Tax Considerations
Employers must consider tax implications when designing their paid time off policies, including on safe and sick leave. If the employer front-loads paid safe and sick leave and any unused time is paid out and not carried over at year's end, the safe and sick time is taxed currently. Where a paid time off policy allows employees to carry over unused time from one year to the next or to cash out unused time at termination of employment, employers must analyze the policy for possible constructive receipt issues.
Also, while most traditional paid time off policies qualify as "bona fide vacation leave, sick leave and compensatory time off" under Treasury Regulation § 1.409A-1(a)(5) and are therefore exempt from the requirements of Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code, a policy that permits substantial carryovers or that contains overly generous features may be considered deferred compensation for purposes of Section 409A and may result in substantial penalties to the employee if not structured properly. For more information on Section 409A, see Practice Note, Section 409A: Deferred Compensation Tax Rules: Overview.
Permitted Uses of Safe and Sick Leave
Employees may use sick leave for:
- An employee's:
- mental or physical illness, injury, or health condition;
- need for medical diagnosis, care, or treatment of a mental or physical illness, injury, or health condition; or
- preventative care.
- Care of a family member who needs medical diagnosis, care, treatment of a mental or physical illness, injury, or health condition, or preventative care.
- Closure of an employee's place of business by order of a public official due to a public health emergency or public disaster or the employee's need to care for a child whose school or childcare provider has been closed by order of a public official due to a public health emergency.
- Inability to travel to work due to a public official's order to remain indoors or avoid travel during a public disaster.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(a).)
Employees may use safe leave if the employee or family member is a victim of:
- Domestic violence under New York state law (N.Y. Exec. Law § 292(34)).
- A family offense matter, which is an act or threat that may constitute a criminal offense and occurs between spouses, former spouses, parent and child, or members of the same family or household (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a)).
- A sexual offense.
- Stalking.
- Workplace violence, defined as any act or threat of violence against an employee that occurs at a place of employment (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a)).
- Human trafficking.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(b)(1).)
Safe time covers absences from work to:
- Obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, rape crisis center, or other shelter or services program for relief from a family offense matter, sexual offense, stalking, or human trafficking.
- Participate in safety planning, temporarily or permanently relocate, or take other actions to increase the safety of the employee or employee's family members from future family offense matters, sexual offenses, stalking, or human trafficking.
- Meet with a legal or social service provider for information and advice on, or to prepare or participate in a criminal or civil proceeding, including matters related to:
- a family offense;
- a sexual offense;
- stalking;
- human trafficking;
- custody;
- visitation;
- matrimonial issues;
- orders of protection;
- immigration;
- housing; or
- discrimination.
- File a complaint or domestic incident report with law enforcement.
- Meet with a district attorney's office.
- Enroll children in a new school.
- Take other actions necessary to maintain, improve, or restore the physical, psychological, or economic health or safety of the employee or employee's family member, or to protect those associating or working with the employee.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(b)(1)(a).)
Employees may also use safe time unrelated to any incident of crime or violence if the employee:
- Is a caregiver for a minor child or care recipient and needs to provide care to that individual. Care recipients are defined as any person suffering from a disability that resides in the employee's home and relies on the employee caregiver for medical care or to meet the needs of daily living (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a)).
- Is applying for, maintaining, restoring, or involved in a legal proceeding related to subsistence benefits, housing, or shelter for the employee, a family member, or a care recipient.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(b)(1)(b) and (c).)
Care for Covered Family Members
Employees are entitled to take safe and sick leave to care for a covered family member or to assist a family member who has been the victim of domestic violence, a family offense, a sexual offense, stalking, or human trafficking. The family member must be the employee's:
- Child. The child must be biological, adopted, foster, step, legal ward, a son or daughter of a spouse or domestic partner, or a child to which the employee stands in loco parentis .
- Parent. The parent must be biological, adoptive, foster, step, legal guardian, or a person that was in loco parentis when the employee was a minor.
- Parent-in-law, through a spouse or registered domestic partner.
- Spouse.
- Registered domestic partner.
- Grandparent.
- Grandchild.
- Sibling. The sibling must be a brother or sister, half-sibling, step-sibling, foster sibling, or related through adoption.
- Blood relatives.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a).)
The ESSTA also covers any other individual whose close association with the employee is the equivalent of a family relationship (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-912(a)).
Under the ESSTA, employees can use the full amount of safe and sick leave for a qualifying family member.
Employers may require the use of safe and sick leave when an employee qualifies for leave under the FMLA or NYPFL. However, employers must recognize that:
- The ESSTA is broader than the FMLA or NYPFL because it covers:
- siblings;
- blood relatives; and
- any other individual whose close association with the employee is the equivalent of a family relationship.
- The ESSTA and NYPFL cover registered domestic partners, but the FMLA does not.
Calculating Safe and Sick Leave Payment
Employers must calculate the rate of safe and sick leave pay as follows:
- For hourly employees, the regular rate of pay the employee was to earn when the employee took paid safe and sick leave (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(a)(1)). If the employee uses paid safe and sick time for hours that were to have been classified as overtime, the employer is not required to pay the overtime rate of pay (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-208(a)-(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(2).)
- For employees that are paid a flat rate regardless of the amount of hours actually worked, the most recent hourly rate paid for the applicable pay period, calculated by:
- adding together the employee's total earnings (including tips, commissions, and supplements (for example, bonuses)) for the most recent workweek in which the employee did not take paid sick time or other leave; and
- dividing that sum by the total number of hours the employee worked that week or 40 hours, whichever amount is less.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-208(d); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(7).)
- For tipped employees, at least the full minimum wage for hours taken as sick leave. Employees are not entitled to tips they were likely to have earned during the leave. (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-208(c); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(3).)
- For commissioned employees, an hourly rate that is the greater of the base wage or the minimum wage (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-208(d); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(6)).
Employers must pay employees at least the minimum wage for paid sick time (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-208(h); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(1)).
Employees must be paid no later than the payday for the next regular payroll period after the safe or sick leave is taken (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-209(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave FAQs, Question VII(9)).
Employer Notice and Recordkeeping RequirementsManaging Leave Under New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (NY), Practical Law Practice Note w-018-0164
Employers must be ready for a qualifying employee to request safe or sick leave at any time by:
- Distributing the required ESSTA Notice of Employee Rights (see Required Notice of Employee Rights).
- Maintaining and distributing a written sick and safe leave policy (see Written Safe and Sick Leave Policy Requirements).
- Training supervisors.
- Properly recording leave accrual and use (Payday Notice of Safe and Sick Leave Amount Available and Recordkeeping Requirements).
Required Notice of Employee Rights
The ESSTA requires employers to provide a Notice of Employee Rights to all covered employees at the time of hire (and when their rights change) and to post this notice in a conspicuous location accessible to employees (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a)). Employers may also provide employees with a copy of their own paid sick leave policies but cannot change the required notice beyond filling in the employer's calendar year where indicated. (For more information, see DCWPA: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions V(1)-(3)).
Under the ESSTA, the written notice must include:
- The employee's right to safe and sick time.
- The employer's calendar year.
- The right to be free from retaliation .
- The right to file a complaint to the DCWP.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a)(a).)
The notice also informs employees of:
- The accrual and use safe and sick leave.
- The employer's calendar year.
- The employer's right to require employees to:
- request use of safe and sick leave in advance; and
- provide documents to justify being absent for more than three consecutive workdays of safe or sick leave.
- The right to be free from retaliation.
- The right to file a complaint.
(See DCWP: Notice of Employee Rights.)
The DCWP has posted multiple language versions of the notice template on their website (DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave: Notice of Employee Rights). For each employee, the Notice of Employee Rights must be distributed in:
- English
- Any language that the employer customarily uses to communicate with that employee.
- If available on the DCA website:
- the employee's primary language; and
- the primary language spoken by at least five percent of the workers.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-107(a)-(c).)
Employers are also required to post the notice in the workplace. However, the employer cannot post the notice instead of delivering it to employees. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a)(a)(1); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-107(d); see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question V(1).)
The ESSTA requires employers to retain records showing the date the notice was provided to an employee and proof that the notice was received by the employee (see Recordkeeping Requirements). Therefore, employers should save signed copies of the notice or email receipts as evidence of compliance (DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question V(2)).
Employers should check the DCWP website to ensure they distribute the most current Notice of Employee Rights to covered employees. Whenever there is an amendment made to the ESSTA, employers should have employees acknowledge receipt of any re-issued notices and collect their signed version for their personnel files.
Written Safe and Sick Leave Policy Requirements
In addition to the notice requirement, employers must have a written safe and sick leave policy and to distribute it:
- Personally at the time of hire.
- Within 14 days of the effective date of any policy change.
- On employee request.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-211(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(37).)
An employer's written safe and sick leave policy must be contained in a single document, whether it is a stand-alone writing policy or a section of a policy manual, such as an employee handbook, and must meet or exceed all the ESSTA's requirements. At a minimum, the policy must include:
- For employers choosing to front-load safe and sick leave, the amount of safe and sick leave.
- For employers that use the accrual method:
- when accrual of safe and leave starts;
- the rate at which an employee accrues leave; and
- the maximum number of hours an employee may accrue in a calendar year.
- The availability of a separate bank of prenatal leave.
- Any procedure employees must follow to provide notice of a need to use leave to the employer.
- Requirements for written documents or verification of the use of safe and sick leave.
- The consequences of employee failure or delay to provide required documentation.
- Any reasonable minimum increment and fixed interval to use safe and sick leave (see Setting the Minimum Use Amount of Safe and Sick Leave).
- Policy on employee discipline for misuse of leave.
- A description of the confidentiality requirements under the ESSTA (see Employee Privacy and Training Supervisors).
- Policy on carryover of unused safe and sick leave at the end of the employer's calendar year.
- If the employer uses a term other than "safe/sick time" or "safe and sick time" to describe ESSTA-required leave, a statement that employees may use the leave for safe and sick purposes in full compliance with the ESSTA.
- A statement that the employer will not ask the employee to provide the details of any medical condition or situation that caused the employee to use leave.
- A statement that any information the employer receives about the use of safe and sick leave or prenatal leave will remain confidential.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §§ 7-107(c), 7-211(c); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(35); DCWP, Rules for Safe and Sick Leave Policies.)
This policy requirement is in addition and separate to an employer's obligation to distribute the Notice of Employee Rights (see Required Notice of Employee Rights). Therefore, an employer may not distribute the Notice of Employee Rights as required by the law instead of distributing a written safe and sick leave policy. Employers must provide the safe and sick leave policy by a method that reasonably ensures that employees receive the policy, such as by email or by including it in new hire materials given directly to the employee. Employers cannot post the policy at the workplace in lieu of individually providing the policy to all covered employees. (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-211(b), (e); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(37)).
Payday Notice of Safe and Sick Leave Amount Available
The ESSTA requires employers to provide safe and sick leave information on pay stubs or other documentation provided to employees each pay period. Employers must provide information about how much sick leave the employee has:
- Accrued.
- Used.
- Available for use.
This information should include both the baseline unpaid leave hours, and any additional leave hours that are accrued or frontloaded based on the employer's policy. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-919(a)(c); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question V(4).)
Employers who use an electronic system to deliver pay stubs or other documentation must allow employees to retain access to the system for six months following the employee's separation from employment (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-207(b)).
Payday Notice of Paid Prenatal Leave
During any pay period in which an employee uses paid prenatal leave, the employer must also provide in writing:
- The amount of paid prenatal leave used during the pay period.
- The total amount of paid prenatal leave still available for use in the 52-week period.
This information may be provided on pay stubs or other pay period documentation, or in a separate written document.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-207(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question V(5).)
Recordkeeping Requirements
Employers must keep records documenting their compliance with the ESSTA's requirements, including the following:
- Each employee's:
- name;
- address;
- phone number;
- employment start and end date (if applicable);
- rate of pay; and
- exempt or nonexempt classification from overtime requirements under the New York state labor laws and regulations.
- Hours worked each week for nonexempt employees and employees working regularly less than 40 hours per week.
- Date and time of each instance of safe and sick leave or prenatal leave used by the employee and the amount paid for each instance.
- For each pay period, the amount of safe and sick time accrued and used during the pay period, the employee's total balance of accrued safe and sick time, differentiating between paid and unpaid time off, and the amount of accrued safe and sick time available for use by the employee.
- The amount of paid prenatal leave used during the pay period and the employee's total balance of paid prenatal leave.
- Any change in the material terms of employment specific to the employee.
- Date that the Notice of Employee Rights was provided to the employee and proof that it was received by the employee.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-920; R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-212(a)-(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions IX(1) and (2).)
Employers must retain these records, including employment, payroll, and timekeeping records, for a minimum of three years. They must be made available for inspection by the DCWP on notice or at an agreed-on time of day. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-920.)
When an Employee Takes Safe and Sick Leave and Prenatal Leave
Employee Notification ObligationsManaging Leave Under New York City's Earned Safe and Sick Time Act (NY), Practical Law Practice Note w-018-0164
An employer can require an employee to provide advance notice of the need to use safe and sick leave or prenatal leave. The employer must explain the procedures for giving notice in its written safe and sick leave policy. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a) (c); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §§ 7-205(a)-(d), 7-211; see Written Safe and Sick Leave Policy Requirements.)
The notice policy must be reasonable and consider whether the need for safe or sick leave or prenatal is foreseeable or unforeseeable (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(c)). An employer that has not provided an employee with a written policy of its notice procedures cannot deny leave to an employee failing to give reasonable notice (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §7-211(f); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions VI(33)-(35)).
If the need for leave is foreseeable, an employer can require up to seven days' advance notice, in writing, of the employee's intention to use leave. If the need for leave is unforeseeable, an employer can require an employee to provide notice as soon as practicable. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(c).)
An employer must have reasonable procedures for providing notice if an employee has an unforeseeable need to use leave. Reasonable procedures include:
- Instructing the employee to call a designated phone number where the employee can leave a message or following another uniform call-in procedure.
- Using another reasonable and accessible means of communication identified by the employer.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-205(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(33).)
When the employee's need to use leave is unforeseeable, the employer cannot require the employee, before using leave, to:
- Appear in person at a worksite.
- Deliver any document to the employer.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-205(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(33).)
Setting the Minimum Use Amount of Safe and Sick Leave and Prenatal Leave
Employees are free to determine when and how much safe and sick leave they need to use. However, employers may set a "reasonable minimum increment" of up to:
- Four hours per day for safe and sick leave.
- One hour per day for prenatal leave.
Any minimum increment must also be reasonable under the circumstances, and explained in the employer's written leave policy. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(g); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-204(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions IV(8) and V(26) and (27).)
Under these guidelines, an employee wanting to take only one hour of paid sick leave must take a full four hours if employers choose to set four hours as the minimum increment. However, the requirement that the minimum increment be reasonable under the circumstances means an employee who does not have four hours of leave available must be permitted to take any time they have available if needed. An employer can also:
- Set fixed periods of 30 minutes or a lesser amount of time for the use of accrued safe and sick leave beyond the fourhour minimum daily increment.
- Require fixed start times for these intervals.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §§ 7-204(b) and 7-207(a); DCA: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(27).)
Requesting Reasonable Documentation Under the ESSTA
For an absence of more than three consecutive workdays, the ESSTA permits employers to require that employees provide reasonable documentation of their need for safe or sick leave or paid prenatal leave (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(a) (2), (b)(2); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-206(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leve Law FAQs, Question IV(9)). Employers must reimburse employees for any reasonable costs and expenses associated with obtaining this documentation (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(a)(2), (b)(2); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions VI(40) and (43).)
If the employee uses sick time or prenatal leave, the employee may provide documents signed by a licensed health care provider indicating the need for sick leave and the amount of work hours or days used as sick leave. The employer must allow the employee a minimum of seven days after returning to work to obtain the documentation. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(a)(2); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §§ 7-205(a)-(b) and 7-206(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions IV(9) and VI(42) and (43).)
If the employee uses safe time, the employee may provide any of the following as reasonable documentation:
- Documentation signed by an employee, agent, or volunteer of a:
- legal or social services provider;
- court or government agency;
- school or care provider;
- an attorney;
- a member of the clergy; or
- a medical or other professional service provider.
- A police, agency, or court record.
- A notarized letter from the employee explaining the need for leave.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(b)(2); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VI(42)).
For use of either sick or safe leave or prenatal leave of any length, the employer can ask the employee for written verification that the employee used leave for purposes authorized under the ESSTA. For a model form provided by the DCWP, see the Employee Verification Form Regarding Authorized Use of Earned Safe and Sick Leave.
An employer cannot require:
- That the documents specify the reason for safe or sick leave.
- That an employee provide documents from a second licensed health care provider after the employee has already provided the requested written documents from a licensed health care provider.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-914(a)(a)(2); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-206(a) and (d).)
Review Absence Control Policies to Assure Legal Compliance
Employers should review and update any safe and sick leave or absence control policies that require a doctor's note when employees are absent for a specified number of days. Policies that discipline employees based on a specific number of absences should not count leave that is protected by the ESSTA or any other protected leave laws (see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VIII(2)).
Employee Privacy and Training Supervisors
Employers cannot require an employee to disclose details relating to:
- Their own or their family member's medical condition.
- Their own or their family member's status as a victim of domestic violence, family offenses, sexual offenses, stalking, or human trafficking.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code §20-921(a).)
While processing safe or sick leave requests, information that is medical and health-related or concerns any reason an employee may have taken safe time must be kept confidential unless the employee has provided written consent for release or release is required by law (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-921(a)).
Access to the medical file should be restricted to the employer's:
- Health care provider.
- Human resource professional.
- Leave administrator.
Supervisors and managers should not be given unrestricted access to an employee's medical file. An employee's supervisor or manager should only be given information that is limited to an employee's:
- Necessary work restrictions.
- Reasonable accommodations .
If an employee has accrued safe and sick leave available, supervisors may not deny the employee the right to use it and may not discipline an employee for requesting or using the leave. Supervisors need to be aware of the employer's obligations and the relatively limited employee obligations under the ESSTA.
Employers should consider having a process where a supervisor can easily grant approval to an employee's oral or written request for safe or sick leave and provide written confirmation to human resources or payroll personnel so safe and sick leave usage is tracked accurately.
Employees may voluntarily disclose to their supervisors the underlying medical or health reasons why they are taking sick leave for themselves or another covered family member. However, supervisors must keep this information private, because discussing an employee's private medical information with other employees without a need to know the information can lead to claims of invasion of privacy. Supervisors must understand their obligation to maintain privacy of medical information.
Employers should ensure that supervisors are not asking for a doctor's note from employees to use sick leave protected under the ESSTA for absences of three or less consecutive workdays (see Requesting Reasonable Documentation Under the ESSTA). If an employer provides additional sick leave or PTO that is not protected by the ESSTA and wishes to seek a doctor's note for use of unprotected leave, Human Resources should work with supervisors to manage doctor's note requests so the policy is applied in a nondiscriminatory fashion.
Termination of Employment
If an employee terminates employment either voluntarily or involuntarily, the employer is not required to pay the employee for unused accrued safe or sick leave (see N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(i)). Most employers choose not to pay out unused sick leave on termination.
Employees that are rehired within six months of termination by the same employer are entitled to reinstatement of accrued unused safe and sick leave that was not paid out on termination (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(j)). Employees rehired any time within the same calendar year are entitled to reinstatement of any unused unpaid safe and sick leave hours, in addition to any paid leave reinstatement they may be entitled to (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-217(c)).
As with terminations occurring during other types of protected leave, terminating an employee during or on return from ESSTA leave may raise claims of retaliation or interference with exercising ESSTA rights and employers should proceed cautiously in this area.
Interaction with Other Protected Leaves
Many laws and regulations are implicated when an employee needs time off for their own or a family member's illness. Federal and state laws, such as the FMLA, Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), or the New York State Human Rights Law (NYSHRL) and New York State Paid Sick Leave Law (PSLL), take precedence when they offer greater rights and protections to employees than the city's ESSTA (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-923(a)).
New York State's PSLL requires all employers to provide paid leave to employees. The PSLL specifically provides that municipal paid safe and sick leave programs in effect as of the effective date of the PSLL will not be diminished or limited by the PSLL and cities with populations of one million or more are entitled to maintain their own paid safe and sick leave laws which meet or exceed the standards of the PSLL (N.Y. Lab. Law §196-b(12)). The ESSTA was amended in 2020 to comply with all components of the PSLL that are more beneficial to employees. Therefore, New York City employers that comply with ESSTA will also be in compliance with the PSLL.
However, on January 1, 2025, amendments to the PSLL went into effect providing employees with additional, separate, paid prenatal leave (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-913(a)(l); N.Y. Lab. Law §196-b(4-a)). Under this law, all New York employees receive 20 hours of paid leave to be used for prenatal healthcare service appointments, including fertility treatments, during or related to the employee's pregnancy. This leave is a stand-alone benefit, so employers cannot require this leave to be used concurrently or instead of leave under ESSTA or any other applicable leave law or policy (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-216(a); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question IV(6) and (7)). Where prenatal healthcare appointments could fall under multiple available leave entitlements or policies, the employer cannot require an employee to choose to use one type of leave over another, or to exhaust one type of leave before using another. For more information on paid prenatal leave and ESSTA, see DCWP, Notice of Adoption to Add Rules Related to the ESSTA. For more information on paid prenatal leave under the PSLL, see New York State, Paid Prenatal Leave: Frequently Asked Questions.
If an employee's own illness or injury continues past the time period of accrued sick leave under the ESSTA, the employer must consider whether the employee qualifies for leave or accommodation under:
- The FMLA.
- The ADA.
- The NYSHRL.
- The New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL).
Similarly, if an employee takes sick leave to care for their covered family member, employers need to be aware that if the family member has a serious health condition, the employee may be entitled to further leave under the FMLA or NYPFL.
When the leave of absence is requested due to a work-related illness or injury, employers must consider the New York State Workers' Compensation Law. Although workers' compensation law is beyond the scope of this Note, more information is available at State Q&A, Workers' Compensation Laws: New York.
If an employee is taking safe leave for a permitted purpose due to being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, employers must be aware of and in compliance with New York Penal Law § 215.14 and the NYSHRL relating to applicable prohibitions on discrimination and requirements for reasonable accommodations for victims of domestic violence, sexual abuse, or stalking (see Standard Clause, Witness and Victims of Crime Leave Policy Clause (NY)).
When employees are using safe or sick leave governed by the ESSTA, employers should track the time correctly. Employers should also track whether any other leave law applies, such as family and medical leave.
This section provides an overview on how certain federal and state laws interact with the ESSTA.
Family and Medical Leave
The FMLA entitles eligible employees of covered employers to take up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave from work for certain medical and family reasons, including the employee's own serious health condition or the serious health condition of a spouse, parent, or child. The FMLA also offers up to 26 weeks of leave to care for a military family member. (29 U.S.C. § 2612.)
Unlike the ESSTA, FMLA leaves are generally unpaid, unless an employee uses some accrued time off to cover some or all the leave (29 U.S.C. § 2612(c), (d)(2)(A)).
While the ESSTA applies to all New York City employers, the FMLA only applies to private sector employers if they have 50 or more employees for than 20 or more calendar workweeks (29 U.S.C. § 2611(4)(A)(i); 29 C.F.R. § 825.104).
For FMLA leaves relating to the employee's own serious health condition, an employer can require the employee to substitute all accrued paid time off (vacation, sick, or personal leave) during an FMLA leave (29 U.S.C. § 2612(d)(2)(A); 29 C.F.R. § 825.207(a)). Leave taken under the ESSTA runs concurrently with leave taken under the FMLA (see DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question XI(3)).
The definition of family member under the ESSTA is broader than that under the FMLA because the ESSTA covers grandchildren, grandparents, siblings, and parents-in-law while the FMLA does not. The FMLA covers leave to care for the serious illness or injury of an employee's children, parents, and spouses. For example, when employees are caring for a serious health condition of a grandparent for two days, they may take two days of paid sick leave under the ESSTA, but those two days are not covered by the FMLA and therefore cannot be charged against their FMLA entitlements.
For more information on the FMLA, see Practice Note, Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) Basics.
New York State Paid Family Leave
Under the NYPFL, eligible employees may take up to twelve weeks of partially paid leave:
- To participate in providing care, including physical or psychological care, for a family member with a serious health condition. In 2019, the definition of serious health condition was expanded to include preparation for and recovery from surgery related to organ or tissue donation.
- To bond with the employee's child during the first 12 months after the child's birth or the first 12 months after the placement of the child for adoption or foster care with the employee.
- For any qualifying reason provided for under the FMLA when the employee's spouse, domestic partner, child, or parent is deployed on active military duty or has been given notification of an impending call or order to active military duty.
(N.Y. Workers' Comp. Law § 201(15).)
The length of available leave benefits and the amount of the weekly benefits increased over the years until January 2021 (N.Y. Workers Comp. Law § 204(2)(a)). Unlike the ESSTA, the NYPFL does not apply to leave due to an employee's own health condition.
The NYPFL covers all private employers that employ one or more employees for at least 30 days during any calendar year (N.Y. Workers' Comp Law § 202(1)).
An employer may allow an employee to use any earned paid vacation, PTO, or sick time during their NYPFL leave. This allows the employee to receive their full salary for all or part of the leave and is covered by the same rights and protections afforded to employees under the NYPFL leave (N.Y. Workers' Comp. Law § 205(2)(c); see New York State Paid Family Leave: Sick and or Vacation Time). Like the ESSTA, employers must reinstate employees returning from leave.
For more information, see State Q&A, Leave Laws: New York.
Short-Term Disability Benefits
When employees cannot work due to their own non-work-related illness or injury or pregnancy, they may be able to substitute in benefits offered by State Disability Insurance (SDI) or their employers' applicable short-or long-term disability leave plans.
In addition to Paid Family Leave benefits, New York's Disability Benefits Law provides short-term benefits to employees needing time off for off-the-job injuries and illnesses. Benefits are paid for a maximum of 26 weeks of disability during any 52 consecutiveweek period (N.Y. Workers' Comp. Law § 205(a)). This benefit is only a pay concept and does not provide any protected leave, such as under the ESSTA or FMLA.
Short-term disability benefits do not increase the amount of leave for the employee. They are administered by the Workers' Compensation Board and are separate from any other benefits offered by the employer.
As of January 1, 2018, employees cannot receive short-term disability and NYPFL benefits for the same time period (N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 12, § 380-2.5(e); N.Y. Workers' Comp. Law § 205(4)). (For more information, see NYS Workers Compensation Board: Disability Benefits.)
Extended Leave and Other Temporary Disabilities
A sick employee may qualify for leave from an employer that provides leave for employees with temporary disabilities or as a reasonable accommodation under the ADA, NYSHRL, or NYCHRL.
For more information on federal and state disability laws, see:
- ADA, NYSHRL, and NYCHRL Disability Comparison Chart (NY).
- State Q&A, Anti-Discrimination Laws: New York: Question 2.
- Practice Note, Disability Accommodation Under the ADA.
Discrimination and Retaliation
Employers cannot take adverse actions against employees for exercising, or attempting to exercise, their rights under the ESSTA, including:
- Requesting and using accrued safe and sick leave or prenatal leave.
- Filing a complaint with the DCA or alleging a violation of the law.
- Cooperating in an investigation or prosecuting an alleged violation of the law.
- Informing other individuals of their potential rights under the ESSTA.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-918; DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VIII(1).)
Adverse actions include:
- Threats
- Intimidation and harassment.
- Discipline.
- Termination of employment.
- Demotion.
- Suspension.
- Harassment.
- Reduction in work hours or pay.
- Discrimination.
- Informing another employer than an employee has engaged in ESSTA-protected activities.
- Blacklisting.
- Maintaining or applying an absence control policy that counts leave under ESSTA as an absence that may lead to an adverse action.
- Penalizing employees for not meeting a quota due to the use of safe and sick leave or prenatal leave.
(R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §7-108(b); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Question VIII(2).)
Employers need to review their attendance or absence control policies to assure they do not violate the ESSTA.
Enforcement and Penalties for Non-Compliance
The ESSTA is enforced by the DCWP and contains various fines and penalties. Additionally, effective March 20, 2024, individuals alleging a violation of the ESSTA may file a civil action in court.
Under available administrative remedies, the DCWP can:
- Initiate investigation into compliance with the ESSTA on its own initiative or following a complaint.
- Conduct on-site inspections or issue subpoenas to an employer on 30 days' notice, or less with employer consent. However, the DCWP can conduct on-site inspections without 30-days' notice if it reasonably believes an employer:
- is likely to destroy or falsify records;
- is closing, selling, or transferring its business, intends to declare bankruptcy, or is otherwise disposing of its assets;
- is the subject of a labor-related government investigation or enforcement action; or
- is engaging in retaliation.
- Issue a Notice of Hearing to the employer if, following an investigation, the DCWP believes a violation has occurred.
- Attempt to resolve an employer's noncompliance without a hearing, by settlement, where possible.
- Impose penalties to employers for violations of the ESSTA and grant appropriate relief to aggrieved employees or former employees.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-924; R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, §§ 7-109, 7-212(c)-(e).)
Employees have two years from the date the individual knew or should have known of the alleged violation to file a complaint with the DCWP. The complainant's identity is kept confidential unless their identity is necessary to the investigation or is required by law. The DCWP must notify the complainant that it intends to disclose their identity before the disclosure. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-924(b).)
Administrative penalties and other relief include:
- Civil penalties, of:
- up to $50 per employee that was not given the required Notice of Employee Rights;
- up to $500, for failing to fully respond to the DCWP's Request for Information before the first scheduled appearance date, in addition to any other penalties and remedies imposed resulting from the DCWP's investigation;
- up to $500 per employee for each first-time violation of the ESSTA;
- up to $750 per employee for each second violation within two years of a prior violation; and
- up to $1,000 per employee for each later violation within two years of any previous violation.
- The greater of $250 or three times unpaid wages for each instance an employee took safe or sick leave but was not paid by the employer.
- $500 for each instance an employer:
- unlawfully denied an employee sick time that was requested but not taken by the employee;
- unlawfully conditioned the use of safe and sick leave on the employee finding a replacement worker; and
- required the employee to work additional hours to make up for the work hours they missed while on safe and sick leave.
- $500, backpay and lost benefits, and appropriate equitable relief for each instance of unlawful retaliation that does not include termination of employment.
- $2,500, backpay and lost benefits, and appropriate equitable relief, including reinstatement, for each instance of unlawful termination of employment.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§ 20-919(a)(c), 20-924(d)-(e); R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-109(f).) Penalties are imposed on a per employee basis (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-213(a) and (b)).
When an employer fails to maintain or produce a record that must be both maintained under the ESSTA and relevant to a material fact alleged by the DCWP in a notice of violation, this creates a reasonable inference that the material fact is true, unless a rebuttable presumption or other adverse inference is provided by applicable law (R.C.N.Y. tit. 6, ch. 7, § 7-111(a)).
Effective March 20, 2024, New York City established a private right of action for individuals alleging a violation of the ESSTA (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-924(f)). Following this amendment to the law, individuals can file a civil action for compensatory damages within two years of the time the individual knew or should have known of an alleged violation. Damages in a civil action may include:
- The greater of $250 or three times unpaid wages for each instance an employee took safe or sick leave but was not paid by the employer.
- $500 for each instance an employer:
- unlawfully denied an employee sick time that was requested but not taken by the employee;
- unlawfully conditioned the use of safe and sick leave on the employee finding a replacement worker; and
- required the employee to work additional hours to make up for the work hours they missed while on safe and sick leave.
- $500, backpay and lost benefits, and appropriate equitable relief for each instance of unlawful retaliation that does not include termination of employment.
- $2,500, backpay and lost benefits, and appropriate equitable relief, including reinstatement, for each instance of unlawful termination of employment.
- Injunctive and declaratory relief.
- Attorney's fees and costs.
(N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-924(d) and (f).)
Individuals may file a civil action independent of any requirement to file a complaint with the DCWP. Under the law, employees or other individuals alleging a violation of the ESSTA may choose to file an administrative complaint, a civil action, or both at their own discretion and at any time within the statute of limitations. (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 20-924(g); DCWP: Paid Safe and Sick Leave Law FAQs, Questions X(1) and (2).)