Pregnant and Finally Protected: One Year Later, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act Provides a Lifeline to Workers (A Better Balance, 2024) (Part 1 of 2)
Part 1 of 2
Executive Summary
On June 27, 2023, the landmark Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) went into effect, bringing long overdue 2 protections to millions of workers affected by pregnancy, childbirth, and related conditions. No longer can pregnant and postpartum workers be forced off the job and denied the temporary accommodations they need to stay healthy and attached to the workforce. A Better Balance launched and led the ten-year movement for the PWFA because we knew, based on our work with scores of expecting and new mothers over the years, mostly those in low-wage and physically demanding jobs, that the status quo was unacceptable. We relentlessly argued since 2012 3 that federal law was failing pregnant workers and an affirmative right to accommodations—things like light duty, a modified work schedule, and job-protected leave for prenatal visits, bedrest, and recovery from childbirth—was essential to ensuring fairness and equality under the law. Since the law went into effect last year, A Better Balance has not only been rigorously educating, implementing, enforcing, and defending the law, but also reflecting on the progress made since the law’s effective date, lessons learned for other campaigns, and the vast work ahead.
This report illustrates the powerful impact of the PWFA with profiles of workers whom we have assisted over the past year, compared to those who were unable to rely on the law before passage.
First and foremost, it is clear that the PWFA has made an enormous difference for workers. At ABB, we have heard from nearly 500 workers on our free and confidential legal helpline over the last eleven months, including many women in low-wage and physically demanding jobs, with specific questions that related to their rights under the PWFA. Thankfully, the vast majority of these workers had clear law on their side. As a result, with our support, workers have been able to use the law to protect their health during pregnancy and after childbirth, and keep their jobs. For many workers with whom we have spoken, the difference between having and not having the PWFA is like night and day. We also know tens of thousands have relied on our online tools and resources, as well as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC), to self-advocate independently, and countless others are benefitting from the PWFA’s protections in a seamless manner after their employers updated their policies, handbooks, and training materials.
At the same time, without final regulations from the EEOC in effect for nearly this entire period and with many not knowing about the law’s broad scope, the report also highlights common challenges we have seen some workers face accessing accommodations. The report concludes with recommendations for the future to ensure the promise of the PWFA is fully realized.
Roadmap for this Report
This report starts in Section I with background information briefly explaining why the PWFA was introduced and passed after a decade-long movement. Then, we provide information about the recently promulgated regulations, which implement the statute. Section II provides insight into what it was like before the PWFA went into effect for pregnant and postpartum workers who required accommodations by sharing the experiences of A Better Balance Community Advocates who fought for the law.
Section III gives a big-picture view of what we are seeing on our helpline postenactment as well as key statistics. It also profiles the experiences of workers who requested accommodations after the PWFA’s effective date and groups them into the following categories:
- A. The PWFA in Action—helping workers prevent discrimination and keep their jobs: This subsection includes the examples of Victoria, Kirsten, Cristel, Maxine, Louseda, Beca, Katie, and Raquel, all of whom were able to successfully receive accommodations under the
PWFA, ensuring they could take time off for prenatal visits, secure modified work schedules and remote work, get time off to recover from childbirth, have a space to pump breastmilk at work, access light duty work, and much more, without losing their jobs. These powerful examples of successful self-advocacy show that it was not always easy for these women to get accommodations, but thanks to the rights provided by the PWFA and their own tenacity, their stories represent powerful anecdotal evidence that the law is working as intended.
Sections IV and V evaluate health and financial benefits post-PWFA, as well as the role of the regulations in promoting maternal and infant health and family economic security.
Next, we discuss legal challenges to the PWFA and final regulations in section VI.
Finally, Section VII looks at our key recommendations looking forward.
I. History and Purpose of the PWFA
In 2011, ABB Co-Founder & Co-President Dina Bakst recognized a disturbing pattern when speaking with workers and reviewing case law—pregnant workers, especially women in low-wage and physically demanding jobs, were being pushed off the job for needing temporary accommodations to remain healthy and working. A Better Balance’s legal research at the time confirmed that in far too many instances, this practice was upheld by courts as perfectly legal due to significant gaps in our civil rights laws. A few months later, Bakst published an Op-Ed in The New York Times , laying out the problem and calling for a legislative fix. No worker in America “should be forced to choose between her job and a healthy pregnancy,” she wrote. U.S. Representative Jerry Nadler of New York called A Better Balance the day the Op-Ed was published to discuss working together on federal legislation—shortly thereafter named the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act—and introduced it in the House of Representatives for Mother’s Day of that year. It was later introduced by lead sponsor Senator Bob Casey in the Senate that fall.
As illustrated below by the powerful examples from A Better Balance Community Advocates who fought long and hard for passage of the PWFA, the purpose of the PWFA was to close a gap in our existing legal framework to ensure pregnant and postpartum workers were no longer forced off the job for needing temporary accommodations, facing devastating health or economic consequences as a result. The Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978 (PDA) was inadequate to protect workers affected by pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions, primarily because the statute relied on a comparative framework where pregnant workers only had the right to be treated as well as similarly situated co-workers. This problematic framework was left in place even after a landmark 2015 Supreme Court case, Young v. UPS . The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) also was little help to many pregnant workers because the ADA does not cover pregnancy in and of itself, and even in instances of medically serious pregnancy-related disabilities, courts were ruling against workers who sought relief under the law.
A Better Balance also argued, while pushing for its passage, that the PWFA was necessary for workers to have a clear, affirmative right to reasonable accommodations, in order to facilitate the immediate relief they needed, without
having to resort to costly and lengthy administrative agency investigations and filings or litigation. As Bakst told Congress in 2019:
“ [M]ost workers we hear from simply want an accommodation to continue working and comply with their doctor’s orders. They cannot afford to wait weeks, months, or years for a court decision. Once their baby has started elementary school, it is obviously too late to ensure the pregnancy is healthy at the outset and to prevent a downward spiral of financial woes. Workers need an explicit right to accommodations, not a standard that forces them into a years-long spiral of chasing down co-workers to meet a uniquely burdensome standard.
Simultaneous to the push for the federal law, A Better Balance also worked with partners and coalitions to pass equivalent state and local laws. The movement in the states not only provided protections for millions of workers, but also built the case for the federal legislation, by demonstrating the benefits for employers and employees alike of having a clear law on the books. For example, we knew we were on the right path when, with our quick assistance, Floralba Espinal, UFCW union member and thrift store employee, was able to get her job back with a light duty accommodation necessary to help her avoid having another miscarriage by relying on the New York City Pregnant Workers Fairness Act just days after it went into effect in 2014. 9
Finally, after more than ten long years and diligent efforts building a broad and diverse coalition, Congress passed the PWFA in
December 2022. For more information on the history of the law’s passage, read A Better Balance’s report, “Winning the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act: An Inside Story and Lessons Learned from the Decade-Long Fight for Justice, Fairness, and Equality.”
For more about workers’ rights under the law visit, https://www.abetterbalance. org/pregnant-postpartum-workers-know-your-rights/.
EEOC’s Final Regulations
On April 19, 2024 the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) published its final regulations implementing the PWFA. In August 2023, as required by law, the EEOC issued proposed regulations and invited the public to submit comments to provide feedback on the proposal. A Better Balance responded by submitting a nearly 100-page detailed comment, informed by the experiences of hundreds of workers who had contacted our helpline, urging for robust final regulations by the agency. ABB also delivered over 8,000 comments from individuals urging strong regulations, led by ABB Community Advocates Armanda Legros and Natasha Jackson, discussed in more detail below. These final regulations provide clarity to employers and employees to understand how the PWFA works in practice, benefitting all parties involved. As described below, in many instances, it is reasonable to assume that negative experiences might have turned out differently had final regulations been released and in effect at the time the worker was struggling to receive an accommodation.
II. Before the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
As described above, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act was the result of over a decade of tireless advocacy, and an unwavering commitment to improving the status quo for pregnant and postpartum workers. Most importantly, our movement was grounded in the lived experience of workers, many of whom courageously stepped forward over the past decade to speak about their experiences and demand that their elected representatives hear them.
A Better Balance’s Community Advocates fought tirelessly for the PWFA, publishing Op-Eds, talking to the press, appearing on television, signing community letters, speaking at rallies, and even testifying before Congress. By sharing their stories of severe economic hardship and health complications, they forced lawmakers to confront the realities of working while pregnant or after childbirth without the right to accommodations.
Their experiences demonstrate a striking contrast to those who are now able to benefit from the law, as described later in this report. For these mothers, this is what life was like prior to the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
Tasha Murrell shared the devastating aftermath of being forced to choose between the health of her pregnancy and her job. When employers denied employees accommodations, they found themselves in the impossible position of risking their pregnancy, or their job. Tasha found herself in this position after her employer ignored her request to avoid heavy lifting on her doctor’s advice:
- “ I was 12 hours into my shift lifting heavy boxes, when I started experiencing extreme stomach pain. I told my supervisor and requested to leave early. . . . She made clear that if I left early, she would reprimand me. So I stayed and worked an extra hour in terrible pain. I had no choice. I couldn’t afford to lose my job. I left when the pain became too much to bear and my feet began to swell. Despite having worked more
than 13 hours straight, my supervisor still reprimanded me for leaving before my shift was complete.
The next morning, I woke up to find my bed drenched in blood. I went to the hospital and my doctor told me there was nothing they could do—I was having a miscarriage. . . . We need to take a hard look at how our country supports pregnant and postpartum workers, because right now we’re failing.
In the report Pregnant and Jobless , A Better Balance shared the stories of many pregnant workers who were forced off the job when they requested accommodations. In the years that followed, we often heard from pregnant workers who were immediately sent home when they requested accommodations, facing overwhelming stress and economic hardship as a result. Even when pregnant workers told their employer about minor restrictions that didn’t impact their ability to do their job, employers made reactionary employment decisions relying on gender-based stereotypes and beliefs about the commitment that women in particular would have to their jobs once they became mothers.
Armanda Legros testified before Congress to demand an end to forced leave for pregnant workers. Armanda spoke to Congress back in 2014 to urge lawmakers to pass the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
- “ I worked for an armored truck company on Long Island for two years before I was pushed out of my job. I was 6 and 1/2 months pregnant when I pulled a muscle in my stomach doing some heavy lifting at work and had to miss the rest of the week recovering. My doctor told
me to avoid heavy lifting so I wouldn’t hurt myself again, and gave me a note to bring into work. My manager took one look at the note and sent me home without pay, indefinitely. He said I could only work if I had no restrictions—company policy. I knew this wasn’t true: they had accommodated my co-worker who had injured his back on-the-job. 19
Armanda’s experience was distressingly common. Rather than trying to work with pregnant employees to keep them on the job, employers sent them home as soon as they learned about their pregnancy restrictions. Without a federal right to pregnancy accommodations, many workers had no recourse when their employer put them on leave. These workers found themselves without a source of income when they needed it most. Armanda told Congress what happened to her after she lost her job:
- “ I tried to get another job, but I was showing and I could tell from the interviews that no one was going to hire me. I had to go 7 months without pay when I needed that income more than ever. My credit score dropped and I almost lost my apartment when I fell behind on rent payments. Even when I applied for emergency rental assistance, I didn’t qualify because I didn’t have any income coming in. My employer fought my unemployment benefits, and when they did finally arrive, it
was still only a fraction of my original salary. I had no choice but to apply for public assistance. . . .
When I was eight and a half months pregnant, my health insurance was cut off. I couldn’t afford the COBRA payments and had to apply for Medicaid for my prenatal care. Once my baby arrived, just putting food on the table for him and my four-year-old was a challenge. I was forced to use water in his cereal at times because I could not afford milk. I was scared every time I looked in my empty fridge. 20
Denizer Carter spoke out about the cascading consequences of losing one’s job while pregnant. Denizer worked for a large grocery store chain in Louisiana until 2019. When she nearly had a miscarriage, her doctor told her that she needed to take occasional rest breaks and refrain from heavy lifting. Even though there were plenty of tasks Denizer could still do, Denizer’s employer pushed her out of the job instead of accommodating her. In 2022, Denizer wrote an Op-Ed for Ms. magazine that described the impact this had on her growing family:
- “ It was devastating to lose my paycheck with a baby on the way. I also had another child at home to support and the pandemic had just
begun. I used up all of my savings and I eventually had to move in with my mother because we could not afford rent. I was diagnosed with anxiety and suffered multiple panic attacks. I applied for other jobs but no one wanted to hire me while I was visibly pregnant. 21
Denizer later traveled to Washington, D.C. to demand that her elected representatives hear her story. “I am currently pregnant but I made the effort to come all the way from Louisiana to say: I’m disappointed and angry the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act wasn’t passed years ago,” Denizer said at a rally outside the Capitol on December 1, 2022. “Listen to my voice. It has to happen now.” Mere weeks later, the PWFA was signed into law.
Lyndi Trischler had to fight for the same opportunity to work that her fellow officers received. Officer Trischler was a patrol officer in Florence, Kentucky. Five months into her pregnancy, her doctor Lyndi Trischler appears on a put her on light duty. Light WKRCTV television segment about pregnancy discrimination, 2018. duty was available in the police department where Officer Trischler worked, and officers who were injured on the job were given light duty as a matter of policy. However, the City of Florence wouldn’t extend this policy to allow Officer Trischler to continue working through her pregnancy. Officer Trischler wrote about this experience in an Op-Ed in the Cincinnati Enquirer :
“ My pregnancy was complicated and painful physically and emotionally because we had learned that our son had a rare genetic disorder, meaning he would not survive for very long after he was born. No expecting parent should ever have to shoulder devastating news like
that while also fighting an unsupportive workplace and wondering how to pay expensive medical bills. There was financial stress too from being pushed out of my job—my one-year-old daughter and I moved out of our apartment since we could no longer afford rent. 24
A Better Balance represented Officer Trischler and another officer from her department, Samantha Riley, who was also pushed off the job while pregnant because of the same discriminatory policy. On their behalf, we filed a charge of discrimination under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act— at the time, the only law that gave pregnant employees any legal recourse when they were denied accommodations. Officer Trischler and Officer Riley were able to get compensation for the harm they suffered and the City of Florence agreed to change its policy to include accommodations for pregnant workers. However, their victory, which took years to achieve, was the exception to the rule. In a 2019 report, A Better Balance found that two-thirds of employees who tried to bring this kind of legal claim in court lost their cases.
Officer Trischler became an outspoken advocate for the affirmative right to pregnancy accommodations, both at the state and federal level.
Jennifer, a healthcare worker, was denied the accommodations she needed to protect her pregnancy while on the frontlines of the pandemic. Jennifer learned she was pregnant shortly before the pandemic started. “At about seven months pregnant, I asked for some basic safety precautions,” Jennifer told A Better Balance in 2022. “These were the same safety precautions that were given to a male doctor who had an autoimmune condition. My request was denied, and the company I worked for had a meeting with me and told me they had made the decision to replace me with a non-pregnant person who didn’t need any accommodations and that I was no good to them pregnant.”
At a time when the nation desperately needed healthcare workers, Jennifer was treated as disposable because she was pregnant. “I know I speak for moms out there, when I say we are exhausted. A pregnant woman is valuable. We’re valuable to the country, we’re valuable to the workforce, and it’s time that we start getting treated that way.”
Natasha Jackson introducing President Biden at a White House event celebrating passage of the PWFA.
At a Congressional briefing, Natasha Jackson shared what happened after she told her employer about her pregnancy restrictions:
- “ [O]nce the district manager found out that I was pregnant, he told me the schedule change I’d worked out with my store manager could not continue. I reassured him repeatedly that I was fully capable of working and that it posed no risks to my pregnancy. . . . I told them that I only occasionally needed to lift anything on the job. I explained that on the few occasions in the past when my job required me to lift something heavy, my coworkers had always helped me out. 28
Instead of accommodating her, Natasha’s employer made her take unpaid leave, and then terminated her soon after she gave birth. Natasha’s dreams for her family were immediately derailed:
- “ My husband and I had just made a down payment on a house and were about to close the deal. Without my income, we were forced to back out of the contract. I earned more than he did since he worked temporary jobs. So I was out of a job and no longer able to support my family. 29
After the PWFA was passed, Natasha Jackson, Armanda Legros, and Lyndi Trischler joined A Better Balance at a White House event celebrating the law’s passage. “This victory is personal to me,” Natasha shared while speaking at the event. “I have two daughters and nieces. I am so grateful that they—and millions of workers across the country— won’t have to choose between starting a family or keeping their jobs.”
By sharing some of the most difficult moments of their lives on a national stage, A Better Balance Community Advocates became the voice of millions of workers. Passing the PWFA would not undo the harm they had suffered. But they spoke up anyway and fought for the women who would come after them. Their efforts ensured that, as enacted, the PWFA was a comprehensive law with the potential to dramatically change the workplace for pregnant and postpartum workers. Because of their willingness to speak out, these remarkable women made possible the experiences detailed in this report in the next section— stories of success from real workers who benefitted from the law they fought so hard to pass.
III. The View From the Ground: Worker Experiences From A Better Balance’s Legal Helpline
When the PWFA was passed and signed into law in December of 2022, twentytwo states still had no law that gave pregnant workers in the private sector the right to reasonable accommodations. Federal employees also had no legal right to pregnancy accommodations.
Then on June 27, 2023, the PWFA went into effect. Overnight, millions of workers gained the right to accommodations that would allow them to work during and after their pregnancy. The enormous amount of media attention that the new federal law drew meant that many workers heard for the first time that they could have a right to pregnancy accommodations. The state laws, while they had changed the lives of workers and built a groundswell of support for the PWFA, had rarely been the subject of national news. Moreover, the federal
government was now using its significant reach to get the word out, and more workers and employers than ever heard about the PWFA through EEOC trainings and outreach.
The effect of this sudden attention was immediate. Since June 27, 2023, A Better Balance has received tens of thousands of visitors to our online know-your-rights resources about the PWFA, many of whom have accessed the sample letters we created to help workers request accommodations and explain their PWFA rights to their employer. Our resources were also amplified by dozens of influencers, partners, and elected officials on social media after the law took effect, helping information about the new law reach millions more people.
A Better Balance has also been able to speak to hundreds of workers about their PWFA rights over the last year. We have learned about their experiences, and shared in both their challenges and their triumphs. In the first month alone after the law’s effective date, A Better Balance’s helpline received 108 calls or messages from workers about the PWFA. At first, we expected to hear mostly from workers who had no existing right to pregnancy accommodations before June 27th, since they would be most impacted by the PWFA. To our surprise, the majority of these calls were coming from states that already had a pregnancy accommodations law that covered private employees, indicating that the new federal PWFA had done the important work of spreading awareness about the right to accommodations for pregnancy and childbirth. As of June 3, 2024 we had heard from almost 500 workers from 44 states and Washington, D.C., representing a cross-section of the workforce.
A snapshot of helpline callers
Age Data
- The fact that healthcare workers are by far the most common callers to our helpline is especially concerning given that the United States is facing a critical shortage of healthcare workers. The Health Resources & Services Administration predicts that the country will face a deficit of over 400,000 nurses in the coming decade. Health Workforce Projections, Health Resources and Services Administration, https://bhw.hrsa.gov/data-research/projecting-health-workforce-supply-demand (last visited Apr. 9, 2024).
For over a decade, A Better Balance’s helpline has provided workers with free information about their legal rights. Through our helpline, we have seen that information can be an incredibly powerful tool in a worker’s hands. Often, callers to our helpline are able to get pregnancy accommodations by sharing information about the PWFA—such as our sample letters—with their employers. Over the first year of the PWFA, we have heard many stories from workers who used the new law to successfully advocate for themselves.
The workers we spoke to said that knowing the law was on their side made them feel more confident about asserting their legal rights. This is the PWFA working as intended: empowering employees to ask for the accommodations they need, spreading awareness among employers, and shifting the paradigm for pregnant workers in workplaces across the country.
The following profiles are examples of success stories where workers were able to obtain the reasonable accommodations they needed by using the PWFA, with legal information provided by ABB, and in some cases, through ABB’s direct intervention with their employers through legal representation.
Victoria’s Story: Fighting back against forced leave
Victoria, a pregnant custodial worker in South Carolina, called us because her employer was forcing her to take unpaid leave.
Victoria’s doctor issued a note specifying pregnancy-related work limitations, including restrictions on lifting anything over twenty pounds, limitations on climbing, and the need for additional breaks. Victoria handed her doctor’s note to her employer a few days later, expressing her intention to continue working while following her doctor’s advice. However, Victoria was subsequently informed that she couldn’t return to work until her pregnancy-related restrictions were lifted.
After contacting A Better Balance, Victoria used our PWFA resources to
successfully advocate for herself. Her employer agreed that she could continue working while pregnant and that they could accommodate the restrictions set out by her doctor. She returned to her normal shift the following day.
Victoria wants other pregnant employees to know that they have a right to keep working. “It’s important to know that having a baby inside your belly is not a sickness.”
She further added that employers need to be thinking about the lives of their employees outside of work if they want to keep employees who have families (particularly women) working for them long-term. “When for a company is the right time for a woman to have a baby? It would never be the right time if they don’t make accommodations.”
Victoria later told us that after she came back to work, her employer put up posters in the employee break room about the PWFA and the right to pregnancy accommodations. Victoria hopes this means that other workers won’t have to go through what she did, and her employer will work with pregnant employees to find accommodations instead of forcing them on leave.
Victoria’s story shows that by asserting their rights, pregnant employees can bring about significant changes in their workplace and get back to work when they are unjustly pushed out.
Kirsten’s Story: Getting job-protected time off to recover from childbirth
Kirsten is a part-time enrollment specialist at a community college in Arizona. She recently had her first child. While she was pregnant, Kirsten called A Better Balance’s helpline for information about her legal rights. She wasn’t eligible for Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) leave because she hadn’t been with her employer for long enough to qualify. Using information about the PWFA that A Better Balance provided, Kirsten was able to request leave to recover from childbirth as an accommodation under the PWFA.
Being able to get the leave she needed to physically recover from childbirth made all the difference in Kirsten’s peace of mind as she welcomed her new baby. “Although this time off is unpaid, it makes me feel more secure financially and in my career,” Kirsten told us. “I will have a job to return to and know I will be able to pay my bills and care for my child.”
Kirsten said that the right to accommodations has given her peace of mind, since she knows she will be able to continue working through her pregnancy. “Overall, I think knowing that I have the PWFA to support me in my workplace has really allowed me to relieve stress I may have felt otherwise. I believe the PWFA is incredibly important
in supporting new families and those who want to start a family and hopefully in the future the government will implement even more legislation to help families.”
Cristel’s Story: Navigating pregnancy in a male-dominated industry
Cristel, an electrician’s assistant in New York City, was 29 weeks pregnant and needed accommodations to allow her to continue working. Initially, Cristel presented her employer with a doctor’s note outlining several pregnancy-related restrictions, such as limitations on lifting and climbing stairs, common for expecting mothers.
Rather than grant her accommodations or work with her to identify alternate accommodations that could meet her needs, Cristel’s employer tried to push her onto leave. Cristel told our Spanish-language helpline, “[C]uando me quedé embarazada, tenía miedo de sufrir discriminación, y así fue. Como trabajaba en la construcción y sólo había hombres, miraban a las mujeres como si no debieran trabajar sólo porque yo estaba embarazada. Definitivamente hay áreas en las que una podría trabajar que son más fáciles, pero simplemente te mueven y te colocan en áreas difíciles con la esperanza de que renuncies.”
Translated from Spanish: “When I became pregnant, I was afraid I would face discrimination, and I did. Because I work in construction and there were only men, they looked at women as if they shouldn’t be working, just because I was pregnant. There are definitely areas where one could work that are easier, but they just move you around and move you around to hard areas, in the hopes that you quit.”
After Cristel learned about her PWFA rights from A Better Balance and advocated for herself using the law, her employer suddenly exhibited increased flexibility and willingness to accommodate her needs. “They did listen to my doctor and accommodated the restrictions outlinedby my doctor, which was good and helpful,” Cristel told us. She feels relieved that she knows her rights and can ensure that her employer is treating her fairly. “I’m feeling hopeful.”
Maxine is a medical assistant in Washington, D.C. Her partner Andrés reached out to ABB’s helpline on her behalf earlier in the year when Maxine was pregnant with their first child together. They were looking for more information about whether Maxine had the right to keep her job after she gave birth because her employer had advised that she had no options for maternity leave due to her tenure with the company. Specifically, her employer told her that because she would be about one month shy of her one-year anniversary with the company by the time she gave birth, she would not be eligible for leave under the FMLA, and therefore her only option would be to resign from her position.
We spoke with Andrés and explained that even though Maxine would not be eligible for FMLA leave by the time she gave birth, the PWFA still required her employer to provide her with job-protected time off work to recover from childbirth unless they could prove that doing so would create undue hardship for the company.
Using the information and resources about the PWFA we shared, Maxine sent an email to her employer requesting leave to recover from childbirth as an accommodation under the PWFA, and the company immediately changed their tune. They went from advising that she must resign from her position upon giving birth to telling her that they would be happy to have her continue as an employee following the birth of her child. They then requested medical documentation indicating Maxine’s expected return-to-work date
following her delivery, which she submitted, and soon thereafter, she was approved for six weeks of leave.
Maxine later told us that the information she got from A Better Balance about the PWFA made all the difference:
- “ I want to give a very special thank you to [the attorney my partner spoke with at A Better Balance] who is very well informed about the laws. Unfortunately for me I was told to put my two weeks in due to me about to give birth because I didn’t have one year with the company. I had literally written up my [notice] and was about to turn it in the next day. Luckily for me that night I had looked up information and came across A Better Balance’s free and confidential helpline, which saved me from resigning by informing me about the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Wow, this saved me from losing my job, completing now one year with my company and, most importantly, being able to spend that time with my baby. Thank you so much. I really do believe that these services don’t get enough credit. Thank you for your hard work and knowledge!
Andrés also told us that without the information ABB shared about the PWFA, he and Maxine “would have been clueless since we didn’t know the correct laws that protect us. I really appreciate your help.”
Louseda is a registered nurse in Florida. Louseda called our helpline during her recent pregnancy, since she had been experiencing lower abdominal pressure and pain that impacted her ability to work. Many healthcare employers offer light duty to workers injured on or off the job,
in order to keep qualified workers employed. However, when Louseda requested light duty as an accommodation, she was denied.
After researching the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) and seeing A Better Balance’s online resources, Louseda asked her employer to reexamine her request under the law. After a quick conversation with her employer about the PWFA, Louseda was granted several accommodations including a temporary transfer to a position that allowed her greater access to a chair and less walking, as well as a modified schedule. With these accommodations, she was able to keep working without risking her or her baby’s health. Louseda told us that seeing her stick up for her rights had made other pregnant nurses more comfortable asking for accommodations as well.
Louseda’s experience as a healthcare worker was not uncommon. Healthcare workers seem to be struggling more than most to get accommodations, and close to 1 in 3 callers to ABB’s helpline since the PWFA went into effect work in a healthcare setting. However, Louseda was able to not only get accommodations for herself but bring about larger changes in her workplace, letting her coworkers know that healthcare workers can benefit from the protections of this new law.
Beca’s story: Exercising the right to accommodations to prevent pregnancy loss
Beca Macri is a certified nurse assistant in Massachusetts. Beca had previously experienced a pregnancy loss while working for her current employer of ten years. When she became pregnant again, Beca was determined to safeguard her health by seeking accommodations at work to limit the amount of heavy lifting she was doing.
“I feel like a lot of pregnant women across the world don’t realize what their rights are,” Beca told A Better Balance. “It took me having a miscarriage for me to advocate for myself because I realized my job
didn’t care about me. I found the new law that took effect June 27th and did my research. I dug deep, not just to get myself help, but to spread the word to every pregnant person I meet.”
Beca was able to use information about the PWFA that she got from A Better Balance’s website to successfully advocate for pregnancy accommodations. Beca believes that this information made all the difference. “When I went into work, I wasn’t afraid to request reasonable accommodations because I wasn’t alone,” Beca said. “I didn’t have a person with me, but I had a federal law with me to help me. Suddenly they agreed to accommodate me after being completely resistant before.”
Katie’s story: Challenging inflexible return-to-office policies
Katie is a tax specialist in Ohio. Katie has been working remotely since 2020, but in mid-2023 her employer began to require employees to return to the office if they live within a certain distance. Employees who had moved farther away during the pandemic could continue to work remotely. When she called our helpline, Katie was four months pregnant and had gestational hypertension (high blood pressure). Her doctor recommended continued remote work as a pregnancy accommodation, but Katie’s employer denied this request without explaining why they were making exceptions for employees who moved away, but not for pregnant workers.
After her request was denied, Katie spoke to A Better Balance about her legal rights under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act and then used sample letters from A Better Balance’s website to write to her employer. Shortly afterwards, her employer granted the accommodation she requested.
Katie told us: “My employer denied my accommodation. I even had a doctor’s note to back it up.
I called A Better Balance and they helped reassure me that my accommodation was reasonable and provided a letter to give to my employer explaining the new law (PWFA). After reviewing they approved my accommodation! This law is a huge win for women!”
Remote work can make a huge difference for pregnant workers struggling with a variety of conditions. Even the common symptoms associated with pregnancy can make commuting and working in an office environment extremely difficult. Some employees we talked to were experiencing severe nausea that disrupted their workday and left them frequently running for the nearest bathroom or even vomiting at their desk. Others had conditions that required them to manage stress to control their blood pressure, and still others needed to be on bedrest. Postpartum workers who were struggling to produce enough milk by pumping needed to be close to their baby so they could directly breastfeed.
Many workers we spoke to who requested remote work as an accommodation for pregnancy or postpartum conditions were initially denied. Often, these workers weren’t given a reason why their employer couldn’t accommodate them, let alone an explanation of how it would be an undue hardship (especially given that many of them worked remotely for years during the pandemic). Frequently these workers were told that remote work was simply not an option anymore due to the company’s return-to-office policy.
This problem is not isolated to high earners. Many of the workers we spoke to were not highly-paid professionals, but call center or customer service workers trying to support a growing family on less than $40,000 per year. They wanted and needed to continue working throughout their pregnancies, and their employers had the procedures and technology in place to allow them to work remotely. However, their requests for accommodations were still being denied out of hand.
After speaking with our helpline, many workers (such as Katie) were able to return to their employer with information about their legal rights and
successfully advocate for remote work. However, others ran into roadblocks as their employers stuck to their implausible claims that providing temporary remote work would be extremely difficult or expensive for their business.
Raquel works for a major telecommunications company in Ohio. After Raquel gave birth to her daughter, like many new mothers, she developed severe postpartum mental health conditions. At the time she gave birth, pregnant and postpartum workers in Ohio did not have a right to reasonable accommodations. Raquel was able to take some time off to recover, but when she was ready to return to work, her doctor recommended that she temporarily work from home to make the transition more manageable due to her mental health needs.
When Raquel requested remote work as a reasonable accommodation from her employer under the new Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, her employer denied her accommodation on the grounds that she was a unionized employee. Raquel’s union repeatedly advised her employer that it did not object to Raquel’s employer providing remote work as an accommodation to union members and that there was nothing about Raquel’s union contract that conflicted with the employer’s legal obligations under the PWFA. However, Raquel’s employer did not listen to the union, and Raquel was forced to remain on leave, losing vital income for her growing family.
Raquel contacted our helpline and learned more information about her rights under the PWFA. Using information and resources from A Better Balance, Raquel returned to her employer and asserted that she had a legal right to accommodations for medical conditions related to childbirth, even if she was unionized. Thanks to her self-advocacy, Raquel was able to get the accommodation she needed to return to work. Raquel told us that “if it wasn’t for A Better Balance, I couldn’t have gotten this accommodation.”
Still, the months that it took for Raquel to get this accommodation had lasting personal and financial consequences.
“My employer’s delay in responding to my request took a huge toll on me psychologically,” Raquel told us. “It further delayed my recovery as I was depressed and on pins and needles waiting for an answer. I didn’t know how I would survive if they didn’t approve my accommodation because I am not in shape to return to my office. Economically it affected me because they took so long to make a decision that I used up all of my vacation time and went into non-paid time which meant my paycheck was short and I got behind in many of my household bills.”
Raquel was not the only unionized employee that A Better Balance spoke to who faced this problem. In the early months of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, multiple callers told us that employers were using the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) they had with the union as an excuse not to accommodate workers, saying that potential conflicts with the terms of the CBA made accommodating the worker an undue hardship.
However, none of the workers we spoke to on our helpline had received information from their employers explaining how the accommodation they were requesting conflicted with the terms of the CBA. In fact, like Raquel, all of these workers had the support of their union when they requested accommodations.
Ashley, a hospitality worker in Florida, was a star performer who consistently received excellent performance reviews at work. After she became pregnant, she experienced severe nausea and bleeding, causing her to occasionally come to work late or miss work to rush to the hospital to attend to her severe pregnancy symptoms. Rather than support and accommodate her, her employer punished her, deducting “points” for her pregnancy-related absences in accordance with its points-based absence policy and ultimately terminating her employment in violation of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Ashley’s employer never brought up the option of reasonable accommodations, and she doesn’t believe they were aware of her rights under the new law.
“Losing my job put me and my family in immediate danger of being evicted from our home, and loss of medical coverage for not only ourselves but also our unborn child, making an already stressful and high-risk pregnancy even more stressful,” Ashley explained. “On top of that, the pride and inclusiveness I had felt working for my company was tarnished by being singled out and ignored, all because of my pregnancy symptoms.”
Ashley started researching online and learned about her rights under the PWFA. She contacted A Better Balance’s legal helpline and, using ABB’s and the EEOC’s PWFA resources, educated her employer about its legal obligations, and successfully got her job back. She told us, “Thank you so much for all of your guidance and help with everything. You really were the rock I needed and I am so thankful and will forever be grateful for you!”
About the PWFA, she reflected that “knowing that the PWFA had my back meant that my voice and rights had to be acknowledged and not pushed aside. I was able to go to not only my HR division, but also to the directors of my department, to provide educational material about pregnant workers’
rights with confidence, resulting in receiving my full-time status and benefits at work again.”
B. Common challenges workers faced when requesting accommodations
For all of the success stories we heard about on the helpline, as the experiences above show, the process of getting accommodations was not always easy for the workers who called our helpline. Certain patterns began to emerge: many workers were waiting too long for responses to their accommodation requests, struggling with burdensome requests for medical documentation, grappling with their employers who had denied accommodations without explanation, or were even at risk of losing their livelihood because their employer was disciplining them for absences or forcing them onto leave.
The stories below highlight trends that we heard about during the first year— trends that burden the critical rights created by the PWFA and show us that the fight to protect pregnant workers is far from over.
i. Urgent accommodation requests were met with unnecessary delays and obstacles
When a worker lets their employer know about a pregnancy-or childbirthrelated limitation, this is supposed to trigger an “interactive process” under the PWFA between the employee and their employer. Employers can’t require workers to accept any accommodation without first engaging in the interactive process. The interactive process should be a dialogue, allowing the employer to gather the information they need to provide the employee with an effective accommodation. In practice, many callers to our helpline described a process that was excessively burdensome and one-sided.
The interactive process was the most common issue raised by workers who contacted our helpline. Some workers described processes that were prohibitively difficult to navigate, as their employers requested highly detailed medical documentation even for minor accommodations, such as a stool to sit on. Others had to wait for weeks or even months for a decision on their accommodation request, often taking (or being forced to take) leave without pay while they waited—if they heard back at all.
These examples identify common themes of barriers in the interactive process we have heard on our helpline.
Robin’s story: Major hurdles even for minor accommodations
Robin works for a convenience store in Virginia. At thirty-two weeks pregnant, Robin was struggling to stand for long periods of time behind her cash register, and requested a stool to sit on. Robin’s manager said they could not grant her accommodation request, so Robin had to directly reach out to HR. HR then redirected her to a separate company that handles employee benefits. After she submitted her request to that company, she didn’t hear anything for weeks.
It is increasingly common for employers to use third-party administrators to handle accommodation requests, and almost every worker we
spoke to who had to request an accommodation from a third-party administrator dealt with significant communication issues and delays. They told us that the interactive process ground to a halt as soon as their request was handed off to a third-party administrator, or that they were caught in a feedback loop between their employer and the third-party administrator as neither party took responsibility for making a decision. When faced with these disheartening obstacles, rather than giving up, Robin contacted A Better Balance. After we learned about her impossible situation, we offered her legal representation and reached out to her employer on her behalf. A Better Balance was able to successfully negotiate accommodations with her employer. Robin was thankful for our assistance, and has been able to continue working without further issues and support her family.
Rachel’s story: The cost of getting accommodations shouldn’t outweigh the benefits
When Rachel, a nurse in Virginia, requested light duty, she was put on leave for two weeks. She quickly used up all her paid time off, going into unpaid leave. Her employer then agreed to give her accommodations, but when she returned to work, she was still frequently being asked to do tasks outside of her restrictions. She raised the issue with HR, but they were not supportive. The more she fought to have her accommodations respected, the more stressful it became. Rachel told us that the stress of navigating the accommodations process (and the health risks that creates) was enough to dissuade her from getting accommodations. She was worried that if she pushed the issue, she would be put back on unpaid leave and be under even more stress. She eventually decided to give up on getting accommodations and get a note from her doctor
clearing her work restrictions. She was able to continue working without an official accommodation with the support of her coworkers.
Janiyah’s Story: For some workers, it’s too little too late
Janiyah worked for a mid-size retailer in Maryland. During her pregnancy she developed serious back pain, so she asked her employer for a stool behind the cash register so she could sit down as needed during her shift. Her employer denied this request, and when Janiyah found her own stool to use, her employer reprimanded her for sitting down during her shift and eating snacks at her workstation.
They told her she needed a doctor’s note if she wanted to sit down during her shift, but even after she got a doctor’s note, her employer continued to monitor her over the store’s cameras and disciplined her for sitting down. Janiyah told her employer there was a law that required them to accommodate her, but nothing changed.
Janiyah decided to quit her job because of the difficulty she was facing getting accommodations. She spoke to A Better Balance’s helpline shortly after she quit, and our helpline staff discussed her legal right to accommodations with her. However, Janiyah didn’t want to try to get her job back with accommodations—she was too close to her due date, and after struggling with her employer over every minor thing, she was done.
ii. Requests for unnecessary medical documentation delayed the process or even put accommodations out of reach
Before the PWFA was passed, the only law that gave workers the affirmative right to work-related accommodations was the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). As discussed in Section I above, we fought for the PWFA because the ADA was
not enough. Workers who had debilitating yet common pregnancy-or childbirthrelated limitations had no right to accommodations, and had to work through health conditions that risked the safety of themselves and their pregnancy. The PWFA changed the landscape by giving pregnant and postpartum workers broader access to accommodations even when they didn’t have a particular diagnosis or a condition that met the limited definition of “disability.”