Pregnant and Finally Protected: One Year Later, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act Provides a Lifeline to Workers (A Better Balance, 2024) (Part 2 of 2)
Part 2 of 2
And yet, some employers do not seem to have gotten the notice. It was shockingly common for employees to ask for pregnancy accommodations and get handed ADA paperwork that asked them for detailed information about how their condition “limited major life activities” (language that comes directly from the ADA but is not a requirement of the PWFA) or to outright certify that they have a “disability.” Not only does this mislead employees about their rights under the PWFA, it also requires them to provide medical information that their employer doesn’t need to determine the proper accommodation. The limitations associated with pregnancy are not medical mysteries; they are often common sense. Pregnant employees shouldn’t need to turn in detailed information about their diagnoses and medical treatments for their employers to know that they may need additional restroom or snack breaks, the ability to sit down at their workstations, a closer parking spot in their last trimester, or accommodations so they can pump breastmilk at work.
Moreover, by requiring detailed medical documentation for even simple accommodations, employers put accommodations out of reach for many workers. Especially early in their pregnancies, workers may not have found an OB-GYN, and setting up a costly doctor’s visit just to get paperwork filled out is prohibitively expensive for many workers. Even if an employee could get medical paperwork filled out, employers would frequently reject it for not being specific enough even if it described in detail the employee’s limitations and the accommodations they needed.
As the stories below show, requiring extremely detailed medical documentation can be a barrier to getting accommodations, and employers are not working with their employees to get around this barrier.
Christine’s story: When an employer won’t take a doctor’s advice
Christine works in marketing for an employer in South Carolina with over 10,000 employees nationwide. Christine was experiencing severe and sudden nausea in her second trimester of pregnancy, making her commute dangerous and working in an office setting nearly impossible. She also experienced pregnancy-exacerbated migraines that she had home treatments for that she couldn’t bring into the office.
With her supervisor’s support, Christine requested remote work as an accommodation. At first, her employer handed her paperwork for disability accommodations, and her doctor wasn’t sure how to fill it out since Christine did not have a disability. Christine looked up her PWFA rights, and got her employer to modify their paperwork to mention pregnancy-related conditions. She eventually submitted medical paperwork from her doctor describing her severe nausea and why it made remote work the safest option for Christine. However, HR denied her request, saying that extreme nausea— even when it caused her to vomit at her desk, disrupting her work and the work of those around her—wasn’t a sufficient reason to work remotely.
Christine reached out to A Better Balance for help. Once A Better Balance intervened with her employer, Christine was able to get the accommodation she was looking for, but only after she submitted additional medical documentation that contained detailed information about her diagnoses and treatments. This was far more information than her employer needed to understand her limitations and which accommodations she required, but thankfully Christine’s doctor was able to provide it, leaving her employer with no excuse not to accommodate her.
Although it shouldn’t have been this difficult for Christine, she was grateful that the PWFA allowed her to be accommodated in the end. “Before I connected with ABB, I felt alone, not heard nor valued, and was beginning to doubt my rights,” Christine told us. “I am so thankful ABB was able to help my company agree to allow me to work remotely while I experienced these symptoms and navigated this difficult and vulnerable time in my life. Without ABB’s support and advocacy for adequate pregnancy accommodations and rights, I would not have been able to continue working.”
Sasha’s Story: Not all healthcare providers are willing to write documentation
Sasha H. works in a warehouse in Memphis, Tennessee. In the summer of 2023, Sasha sought accommodations for her high-risk pregnancy. However, her employer refused to grant her excused time off to attend prenatal appointments, putting Sasha at risk of being fired.
Sasha also struggled to get her doctor to support her accommodation needs. When she asked for a doctor’s note recommending a reserved parking spot closer to the entrance to her worksite to minimize walking,
her doctor declined to write her a note because she “didn’t qualify for a handicap placard.”
Employers can’t assume that getting medical documentation will be straightforward, even for basic or obvious accommodations. Some doctors aren’t even aware that their patients have the right to accommodations and can be an obstacle in themselves.
iii. Employers denied accommodations for reasons that had no basis in the law
Under the PWFA, covered employers are required to accommodate pregnant and postpartum workers and may only deny accommodations if it would be an “undue hardship” (extremely difficult or expensive) to do so. The undue hardship standard allows businesses to refuse accommodation requests that would be highly burdensome to their operations, taking into account factors such as their size, resources, and the nature of their business. However, it does not allow employers to refuse employees the accommodations they need to keep working if they would only be a moderate difficulty or inconvenience to the employer.
In spite of this, we heard from multiple employees who had their request for accommodations denied for reasons that weren’t an undue hardship. Several employees said that their employer was worried that accommodating pregnant workers was unfair to other employees, and would impact “morale.” Some employers said that providing the requested accommodation violated their policies. Other employers would invoke the terms “hardship” or “undue hardship” when they denied the accommodation, without further explanation or engaging in a dialogue with the employee about alternative accommodations.
Equipped with information about their legal rights and what “undue hardship” actually means, some workers we spoke to were able to get their employer to change their accommodation decision. Others, however, found themselves at an impasse.
Rebecca’s Story: Employees deserve more than a generic answer to their accommodation requests
Rebecca is a nurse in New York. She is breastfeeding and requested for her employer to limit her exposure to patients with COVID-19, since getting COVID could impact her milk supply. She felt this would be a reasonable request, as her employer has total discretion over which patients are assigned to her. She requested this accommodation and shared information with her employer about their obligations under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
However, her employer denied her request and gave her a vague letter saying this request would remove an essential function of her job “and/ or” is an undue hardship, without any explanation about which essential functions would be impacted or why it was an undue hardship. She is in the process of appealing her employer’s accommodation decision using information provided by A Better Balance.
One of the major ways that the PWFA differs from previous laws, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act, is that workers are still qualified for accommodations under the PWFA even if they temporarily can’t perform one or more essential job functions. Excusing an essential function can be a reasonable accommodation under the PWFA, but many employers (like Rebecca’s) haven’t updated their processes to reflect this significant change in the law. As far as Rebecca knows, her employer didn’t ever take this possibility into account.
iv. Employers were still enforcing punitive absence control policies against pregnant workers in violation of the PWFA
Workers who called our helpline were seriously struggling to balance their jobs with the challenges of pregnancy. With access to little or no sick time, workers were unable to take time off work to attend critical prenatal appointments, or to deal with severe morning sickness and other pregnancy-related illnesses. If they took time off anyway, they received “absence points,” a common strategy used
(and abused) by employers to control employee absences. Accruing enough absence points can lead to automatic termination, and we heard from multiple workers who were one absence away from losing their job.
The PWFA can provide these workers with the time off they so desperately need. Workers can request time off work for pregnancy‑related illness or prenatal care as a reasonable accommodation, and employers must give them time off unless it would be extremely difficult or expensive to do so. However, many workers we spoke to were not aware that they could request time off as an accommodation, in large part because their employers’ absence control policies hadn’t been updated to mention the new law. Using the PWFA, workers were able to push back against abusive absence control policies, and get the time off work they needed to manage their pregnancies. But as the story below shows, getting employers to change their overall policies could be a bigger fight.
Hayley’s Story: Employers need to update punitive absence control policies
Hayley is a police officer in Texas who just had her first child. Hayley’s employer has an absence control policy that gives workers “points” for unplanned time off, even if the worker has PTO available to cover this
absence. This policy contains exceptions for employees with disabilities who need accommodations under the Americans with Disabilities Act, but doesn’t mention anything about pregnancy accommodations or the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
During her pregnancy, Hayley accumulated points for two unplanned absences due to pregnancy‑related illness and received a warning that if she got another point she could be terminated. The resulting stress led to health consequences for Hayley, and she learned that she was too high‑risk to give birth at a birth center as she originally planned. “For me the experience was frustrating and ultimately my blood pressure continued to elevate only while at work to the point I risked out of being able to use the birth center I paid $7500 for,” Hayley shared. “It was a huge financial loss and an even bigger emotional loss.”
Using information from A Better Balance, Hayley advocated for her employer to change their absence control policy to account for workers who have unplanned absences due to pregnancy. She was able to get her own absence points removed, but by the time she gave birth, her employer had not updated their policies and other pregnant officers were still struggling to get points excused.
v. Forced out on leave by their employers, workers suffered serious consequences
As the stories of A Better Balance’s Community Advocates who were forced on leave after requesting accommodations show, forced leave can have catastrophic consequences for pregnant and postpartum workers. A Better Balance fought to ensure that the PWFA addressed this problem and, as enacted, the new law contains language to specifically prohibit this practice. It is now illegal to put an employee on paid or unpaid leave if any other reasonable accommodation can be provided.
Workers are undoubtedly better off with the law on their side in avoiding being pushed onto leaves of absence. Yet, employers are still using leave as a way to
avoid accommodating employees. In the first year of the PWFA, almost one out of every seven callers who contacted the helpline told us that they were being threatened with or were already on forced leave even when there were other accommodations available—far too many, given that this is now illegal under the PWFA. Thankfully, and unlike prior to the PWFA’s enactment, many were able to end their leave by advocating for themselves using the law and A Better Balance’s resources, but as the experience below describes, they still suffered financial and personal setbacks as they waited for their employer to correct this violation of their rights.
Abby’s Story: Out of sight, out of mind, and out of work
Abby is a hospital technologist at a hospital in Florida. She has been working for her current employer for ten years. When Abby had her first child, she was able to work for the duration of her pregnancy. However, when she was expecting her second child, it was a very different story.
During Abby’s second trimester, her doctor put her on light duty due to tachycardia. The hospital she works at had a light duty program, but when Abby requested light duty, her supervisor sent her home because they were worried that her restrictions made her a “liability.” This was only days after the PWFA went into effect. “Getting sent home early from work in front of all my colleagues felt so demeaning,” Abby told us. “It made me feel inadequate to do a job that I had worked hard to master all those years.”
Abby was placed on leave, without pay, despite the availability of alternate work for her to do, and then forced her to endure months of silence as she waited to learn when and how she could return to her job. Abby called and emailed her employer about getting back to work with accommodations, but they didn’t respond.
The financial consequences for Abby’s family were immediate and severe. “Since I was no longer able to contribute to my financial household responsibilities, my husband had to take the burden on all
by himself. He had to pick up overtime shifts at work, which meant less time with our family. This placed a strain on my marriage and mental health. I was in a constant state of anguish. After getting silence from my employer, I started to regret my pregnancy, one that I had wholeheartedly prayed for. I felt this wasn’t fair to myself or my baby.”
After Abby contacted A Better Balance, we directly intervened with her employer. Abby got her requested accommodations and was able, after months of unpaid leave, to return to work. “When I received the call that my accommodation was approved I burst into tears,” she shared with A Better Balance. “It felt like a load of bricks had been lifted off my chest. When I returned to work, I walked around with such pride and a high sense of dignity. I was finally able to enjoy my pregnancy and relax. I am able to contribute financially again, giving me my sense of self-worth back. I no longer felt ostracized or incapable because I was pregnant.”
Abby requested and received back pay for the period of time that she was on forced leave.
IV. Accommodations Protect the Health of Workers
A. The PWFA was passed to improve the United States’s poor record on maternal and infant health
In 2023, only months before the PWFA went into effect, the CDC released statistics showing that maternal mortality in the U.S. increased between 2018 and 2021, with the most significant increases happening during the COVID-19 pandemic. Provisional data through June 2023 shows a concerning spike in maternal deaths between September 2021 and January 2023, with hundreds more maternal deaths counted in that time period compared to previous years. Although maternal deaths have decreased since they peaked in early 2022, time will only tell if maternal mortality will return to pre-pandemic levels, let alone show signs of decreasing.
For pregnant workers of color, these numbers are even more concerning. Maternal mortality rates for Black expectant mothers in 2021 were 2.6 times the maternal mortality rate for white expectant mothers. Black mothers are also twice as likely to experience stillbirth.
At the same time, infant mortality has also been increasing, particularly for preterm infants. Preterm birth rates have also been on the rise since 2014, and the preterm birth rate among babies born to Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous mothers is up to 1.5 times higher than the rate among other babies.
The PWFA is the result of a decade-long coordinated effort among many advocates, from workers’ rights and social justice organizations to healthcare providers, to address the underlying cause of these deeply concerning statistics. In 2022, A Better Balance released a report in partnership with the Black Mamas Matter Alliance that documented how the United States devalues the lives of Black women who work during their pregnancies and the devastating health consequences this can have. In this report, we urged Congress to pass the PWFA to make working during pregnancy safer for Black women. In the lead-up to passing the PWFA, ABB and PWFA coalition partners
also organized multiple open letters to Congress that were signed by major healthcare professional organizations, including the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), American Nurses Association, American College of Nurse-Midwives (ACNM), and the American Academy of Pediatrics. The consensus was clear: Congress needed to pass the PWFA to protect the health of pregnant workers.
B. Accommodations provide demonstrated health benefits for workers
Although data on the long-term impact of the PWFA on maternal and infant health outcomes nationwide is several years away, the data we do have indicates that the right to pregnancy accommodations could achieve the goal of improving the unacceptable statistics recently seen in the United States. Working while pregnant is generally safe. However, physically demanding work— work that involves extensive standing, hazard exposure, frequent heavy lifting, and working long/overnight shifts—can increase the risk of preterm delivery and low birth weight. There are also limitations that pregnant workers in any line of work commonly struggle with, such as the need to increase food/water intake, or take more frequent restroom breaks.
Before the passage of the PWFA, many workers had to decide between risking the health of their pregnancies or risking their jobs (and often their health insurance as well). No matter their choice, the stress created by this forced decision alone can compound adverse health outcomes for employees and their pregnancies. The very fact that workers no longer are faced with the choice between their health and their livelihoods has the potential to improve maternal and infant health outcomes.
Work modifications for pregnant and postpartum workers have been shown to have numerous health benefits. According to a 2019 Health Impact Assessment conducted by the Louisville, Kentucky Department of Public Health and Wellness, granting employees even minor accommodations can reduce poor health outcomes, including:
- low birth weight
- birth defects
- dehydration
- insufficient amniotic fluid and related birth outcomes
- unnecessary pain resulting from excessive standing, bending, or lifting
- urinary tract infections and related risk of preeclampsia (dangerous high blood pressure); and
- mastitis (an infection) due to insufficient, safe locations for pumping breastmilk.
The unavailability of pregnancy accommodations up until now is only one of many factors contributing to poor maternal and infant health outcomes, among others such as systemic racism and lack of access to reproductive healthcare. However, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act has the potential to make a noticeable and important positive impact on the health of pregnant workers and their babies. In the lives of the workers who call our helpline at least, accommodations have made all the difference.
C. Anecdotal evidence shows that accommodations improve health outcomes for pregnant workers, but procedural hurdles could undermine these positive effects
As the experiences of people who have called our helpline show, by asserting their rights under the PWFA, workers have been able to get accommodations that are critical to their health and safety. Cristel, Katie, and Victoria were able to continue working safely because of the accommodations their employer agreed to. Maxine was able to recover from childbirth, instead of being forced to return to work immediately after giving birth. Raquel’s request to work-from-home allowed her the time she so desperately needed to recover from postpartum mental health complications. Kirsten and Abby both spoke about the relief they felt when they learned they were going to get accommodations, and how their stress lifted almost instantaneously.
However, their employers did not always make it easy, even when workers were asking for simple accommodations that would be minimally difficult to provide (like Robin’s request for a stool, or Janiyah’s request to eat snacks during her shift). By communicating poorly with employees about their rights, making the interactive process needlessly complicated, and requiring burdensome medical
documentation, some employers are counteracting the health benefits of a nationwide right to pregnancy accommodations by making them prohibitively difficult to obtain.
Employers are still learning what the PWFA requires of them, and many workers we spoke to were not granted accommodations the first time they asked for them. Some had to wait weeks or even months (like Victoria, Raquel, and Abby) to get an accommodation. When faced with these extensive delays, workers found themselves in the predicament the PWFA was passed to eliminate, required to either work without an accommodation or go on leave (possibly even losing their job).
Multiple callers to the helpline told us what Hayley described: the stress of fighting for the accommodations they were legally entitled to became a medical problem in and of itself, raising their blood pressure more creating other adverse health outcomes. For some employees, like Rachel, the cost to their health was too much, leading them to give up on getting accommodations and try to do without or begin parental leave early.
D. The new EEOC regulations directly address many barriers preventing workers from receiving the full health benefits of the PWFA
In our comment to the EEOC on their proposed regulations, we described how procedural hurdles were burdening the right of pregnant and postpartum workers to medically necessary accommodations. The final regulations included important provisions that have the potential to dramatically lower barriers to getting accommodations, including:
- Making unnecessary delay of accommodations an independent violation of the PWFA, even if the accommodation is ultimately granted.
- Prohibiting employers from seeking unnecessary medical documentation when the pregnancy-related limitation is obvious (for example, when an employee is obviously pregnant and requests a maternity uniform).
- Prohibiting employers from making employees provide medical information on a specific form, especially if they have already provided
a sufficient doctor’s note. The new regulations also make it clear that employers can’t require employees to certify that they have a “disability.”
- Reiterating that employers can’t assert undue hardship “based on employees’ fears or prejudices toward the individual’s pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical condition,” or concerns that accommodating a pregnant/postpartum employee “would negatively impact the morale of other employees.”
- Identifying several accommodations (called “predictable assessments”) that are so common and straightforward to provide, they are virtually never an undue hardship including: allowing an employee to keep water at their workstation, take additional restroom/food/drink breaks as necessary, and sit or stand at their workstation as necessary.
By emphasizing the informal, flexible nature of the interactive process and limiting employers’ ability to seek unnecessary documentation, the new regulations directly address many of the obstacles callers to our helpline faced when they requested accommodations.
Compliance with the new regulations may be a different story. The experiences described by callers to our helpline show that many employers need to significantly overhaul their accommodations policies to provide the straightforward, streamlined process that is required by law. But the mandate is clear. Removing barriers for workers seeking accommodations will be critical to achieving the goal of improving health outcomes for pregnant workers.
V. Accommodations Support the Livelihood of Workers
A. The problems the PWFA solves sit at the intersection of racial, gender, reproductive, and economic justice
Pregnant and postpartum workers seek accommodations because they need to keep working in order to support their families. Ninety percent of the workers who called our helpline in the first year of the PWFA were working full time. Seventy-two percent of callers were currently pregnant, and over half of those callers already had one or more children. Eight percent of callers provided care for a family member other than a child, such as a parent, a grandparent, or another relative with a disability.
These trends reflect the larger economic reality that pregnant and postpartum workers provide a significant portion of their household income. Recent data shows that mothers are the primary breadwinners for 40% of households with children under the age of 18, and 70% of working mothers will be the primary
earner at some point during the first eighteen years of motherhood. But in spite of the important economic contributions working mothers make, the pay gap for mothers is even larger than the pay gap for women as a whole. The “motherhood penalty” means that mothers are paid sixty-two cents for every dollar paid to fathers.
This disparity falls hardest on women of color. Four out of five Black mothers are breadwinners for their families, and two out of three Native American mothers are breadwinners for their families. The exacerbated pay differential for women of color means that even though their households are more reliant on their income, mothers of color are taking home less on the dollar than any other group.
Before the PWFA was passed, Takirah Woods, ABB Community Advocate, shined a light on these inequities to implore Congress to pass the bill. Takirah was a family services worker for the state of New Jersey, who was also forced out on leave after her employer refused to accommodate her with light duty. “80 percent of Black women are family breadwinners,” Takirah wrote in Ms. magazine in 2020. “Black women are the backbone of the American economy, we are rising to the highest ranks of government and making huge economic and educational strides, and yet we are still too often held back at work especially when it comes to pregnancy. It’s still the case that too many women of color are fired or forced out when they request a modest workplace accommodation to protect their health. Longer term, pregnancy discrimination pushes women deeper into poverty, jeopardizing the health and economic wellbeing of our families.”
B. Access to pregnancy accommodations will have an enormous positive impact on a large swath of American workers and their families
The fact is that many pregnant workers can’t afford to stop working, and threequarters of working women will be pregnant at least once while employed. As part of our advocacy for the PWFA, A Better Balance shared the stories of pregnant workers who were faced with the impossible choice between protecting the health of their pregnancies, and bringing home a paycheck that their families relied on. As discussed in Section II, many of these workers bravely spoke out on behalf of the law to force Congress to confront the lifealtering consequences of being forced to make that choice (or having their employer make it for them).
We fought to pass the PWFA so no worker would find themselves in this position again, and we know from our helpline that it is making a difference. Workers like Victoria, Cristel, and Abby were able to use the PWFA to get back to work when their employers forced them out on leave. Ashley was able to get her job restored, and Katie got the accommodations she needed to continue feeding her child even as she returned to work.
What we heard from the helpline aligns with early data about the economic impact of pregnancy accommodations on a broader scale. A recent study of states that passed a pregnancy accommodations law prior to the passage of the federal PWFA shows that the right to pregnancy accommodations had a positive impact on pregnant workers’ labor force participation, employment, and earnings during pregnancy. This paper estimates that for women without a college education, pregnancy accommodations could result in a 17-20% increase in all of these factors, and a 9-11% increase for women with some college education.
But for some workers, accommodations have still come at a price. Workers who were put on forced leave after requesting accommodations or had to take leave because their employers wouldn’t accommodate them told us about the significant financial struggles they faced. Although a handful of workers we spoke to (like Abby) were able to get back pay after their employers accommodated them, most of the workers we spoke to went without pay while their employers considered their accommodation requests for weeks or even months. Others experienced a lapse in health insurance that impacted both their physical and financial well-being. As Hayley, the police officer who was so stressed her blood pressure spiked and she became too high-risk to pursue her plans of giving birth at a birth center, powerfully put it, “all of this places even more of a burden on working pregnant women who are already juggling a lot with pregnancy. It’s not a surprise to me that women quit the workforce while pregnant. It’s too expensive to stay employed.”
C. Enforcing the new EEOC regulations will be crucial to making the promise of the PWFA a reality
The new regulations from the EEOC take necessary steps to protect the economic well-being of pregnant workers, both by lowering the barriers to getting accommodations in the first instance, but also by clarifying employers’ obligations to workers while the interactive process is ongoing. The regulations discuss how employers can mitigate damages and protect themselves from claims that they unnecessarily delayed accommodations by offering interim accommodations as a “best practice.”
The regulations also clarify that leave is not an appropriate interim accommodation unless requested by the employee. Requiring an employee to take leave while they are waiting for a response to their accommodation request or while the interactive process is ongoing could actually be considered illegal retaliation, as it would discourage employees from exercising their legal rights. In this situation, the employer wouldn’t be able to claim that allowing the employee to continue working would be an “undue hardship,” as there is no undue hardship defense for claims of retaliation.
Widespread adoption of interim accommodation policies would go far in addressing the economic consequences pregnant workers are still facing as a result of requesting accommodations. Interim accommodations would allow employees to continue working while the employee gathers any necessary medical information and while the employer explores long-term accommodation options. Enforcement of the PWFA against employers who compel an employee to take leave instead of exploring interim accommodations will be critical to encourage wide-spread adoption of these policies.
VI. The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act Under Attack
At the time of publication of this report, several attacks in the courts against the PWFA are well underway. A Better Balance remains committed to defending the PWFA and ensuring there is no confusion among workers about their rights under the law and the important regulations published by the EEOC.
Texas v. Garland:
In February 2023, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed a lawsuit against the Department of Justice and EEOC, among other defendants, challenging the constitutionality of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, an omnibus spending bill that included many pieces of legislation, including the PWFA. One year later, Judge Hendrix ruled in Texas’s favor, barring the EEOC from accepting any charges of PWFA violations by Texas state employees. The decision is currently on appeal to the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Although the legal arguments in the case are unrelated to the merits of the PWFA itself, the underlying reasoning has the potential to undermine the ability of workers in every state, including private sector employees, to exercise their rights under the PWFA.
Dina Bakst, A Better Balance Co-Founder & Co-President immediately released the following statement following the judge’s ruling:
The following is a statement from A Better Balance Co-President Dina Bakst:
“This ruling, which eliminates the ability of Texas state employees to exercise their rights under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA), is an outrage. It makes a mockery of our court system and represents an attack on pregnant workers and their families.
“As we at A Better Balance see firsthand everyday through our free legal helpline, the PWFA is a lifeline for pregnant and postpartum workers
in Texas and nationwide, particularly for Black and Latina women in low-wage, physically-demanding jobs. Pregnancy accommodations are critical to reduce preterm birth, low birth weight, and maternal and infant mortality and morbidity. By gutting protections for pregnant state workers, the opinion treats those working for the state of Texas like second-class citizens, unfairly denying them the legal rights they need to safeguard their health and that of their pregnancy—and to remain attached to the workforce when they need their income the most.
“In addition, the opinion purports that the law would cost employers money. But in reality, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which was passed with bipartisan support and the support of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, saves employers, including the State of Texas, time and money by providing vital clarity about their obligations under the law, boosting employee morale, and reducing costly turnover and litigation.
“We fiercely disagree with this blatant attempt to roll back the rights of pregnant workers, and we fully expect to see this ruling appealed.”
Bakst also penned an Op-Ed in The Texas Tribune, “Pregnant Workers’ Health and Livelihoods Face A New Threat,” stating:
“This recent Texas decision really isn’t about the pennies it would cost the state to comply or any potential administrative burden. By gutting protections for pregnant state workers, the opinion attempts to cement pregnant workers’ status as second-class citizens under the law and, yet again, deprive women of the right to control their reproductive lives.”
Tennessee v. EEOC:
Shortly after the EEOC issued its final regulations in April 2024, a coalition of conservative state Attorneys General, led by Tennessee Attorney General Skrmetti, filed a lawsuit in an Arkansas district court challenging the legality of the regulations. Although public statements focus on the portion of the final regulations that relates to abortion, the states sought for the entire regulations to be set aside. Again, ABB condemned the lawsuit:
The following is a statement from A Better Balance Co-President Dina Bakst:
“We condemn this lawsuit, brought by the Arkansas Attorney General and Tennessee Attorney General, among others, which baselessly attacks the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act and its vital protections for pregnant and postpartum workers and workers with pregnancy-related conditions. The inclusion of time off for abortion as a reasonable accommodation by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission appropriately reflects
decades of legal precedent that define the parameters of a ‘pregnancyrelated condition.’
“This lawsuit represents a bad faith effort to politicize what is a vital protection for the health and economic security of millions of families, and a continuation of the alarming attacks on women’s health and reproductive choice. We are committed to fighting to defend workers’ rights under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.”
A Better Balance also joined an amicus brief (a “friend of the court” brief) highlighting the critical need for the regulations grounded in the experiences of workers who have contacted our helpline. As is clear from this report as well as illustrated in that brief, workers’ health and economic security often depends on the clarity provided by the regulations.
On June 14th, 2024, in a significant victory for millions of pregnant and postpartum workers, the judge ruled in favor of allowing the PWFA regulations to go into effect because the coalition of conservative Attorneys General lacked standing to bring the lawsuit.
However, in May 2024, the Louisiana and Mississippi Attorneys General filed a lawsuit similar to Tennessee v. EEOC challenging the PWFA regulations. Separately, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, et al., filed a lawsuit challenging the regulations as well. The two cases were consolidated and on June 17th, 2024, the judge preliminarily enjoined one discrete portion of the EEOC’s regulations implementing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. The enjoined section relates to some employers’ obligations to provide accommodations to workers who need time off for abortions in certain circumstances. The ruling is limited to workers who are employed by Mississippi or Louisiana, primarily report to worksites in Mississippi or Louisiana, or who work for a specific list of religious employers. A Better Balance condemned the ruling as being out of step with decades of legal precedent.
VII. What’s Next?
In this section, we explore what must happen next in order to fully realize the PWFA’s potential, recognizing the above identified barriers to access to justice.
A. Courts must uphold the statute and regulations
As discussed above, the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit will consider whether the specious attacks on the PWFA’s constitutionality will be allowed to prevail. Other courts have heard challenges to the PWFA’s regulations. In each instance, the challengers are attempting to score political points by ripping the rug out from under pregnant workers and others in need of protections for pregnancy, childbirth, and related conditions, causing confusion for workers and employers alike. But the law is clear, and courts should stay above the fray and rule in support of the statute and regulations. ABB will continue to work with partners to vigorously defend the law and regulations to ensure workers in every corner of the country benefit from the law’s protections.
B. Expand outreach, education, and enforcement
Far too many employers, employees, healthcare providers, social service providers, and others do not know about the PWFA or its broad scope. Greater investment in resources is necessary to properly effectuate the purpose of the PWFA and ensure that millions of people know and are able to assert their rights under the law. Federal agencies can play an especially helpful role in educating employers, who will listen to an enforcing agency and have an incentive to follow their guidance in order to come into compliance. A Better Balance will also continue to prioritize free information and legal support to workers to help them assert their rights under the law, as well as, where appropriate, take employers to task when they flout the law.
C. Further research and evaluation is needed
Because the PWFA is such a new law, there is not yet scientific research analyzing the economic and health effects of the law (and regulations).
Investment in such research is necessary to demonstrate any quantitative differences that can be attributed to the law, in addition to qualitative and anecdotal evidence cited above. Although research will likely take years, investment is needed now to begin multi-year projects.
Conclusion
In conclusion, in the past eleven months when the PWFA has been in effect, A Better Balance has seen the benefits of the law’s protections for many workers who have called our helpline, as profiled above. For so many workers, it has been a lifeline to protecting their health or their paychecks. For others, the law empowered them and made them feel like they deserved accommodations to protect their health or economic security—showcasing the beginnings of a cultural shift, where pregnancy discrimination in all its forms will no longer be tolerated in American workplaces. However, there remains much work to do to overcome identified barriers. The clarity provided by the regulations will go a long way in addressing many of the challenges identified in this report. At the same time, we must also work to ensure employees know about and can access their rights under the law, and diligently pursue employers who think they are above the law. By pursuing multifaceted strategies, we are confident that the PWFA will continue to be an essential tool for economic security and public health for generations to come.