Skip to main content

The Ragged Edge of Rugged Individualism: Wage Theft and the Personalization of Social Harm (University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 2021) (Part 1 of 3)

Part 1 of 3

INTRODUCTION

For eighteen months, Cora did all the grunt work at Eclectic Coif,1 an upscale men’s salon in Washington, D.C. that charges $70 a haircut.2 She cleaned the bathrooms, washed and folded the laundry, swept the floors, made coffee, and shampooed up to 80 clients a day. It was not glamorous work. Sometimes it was downright disgusting, actually, like when the basement flooded from a backed-up sewage line and she had to clean it up. But Cora was a Marine. She had gone through boot camp. She prides herself on her toughness, her willingness to go the extra mile to accomplish the mission. The work might have been undignified, but Cora was not a quitter. Besides, she needed the money.

It was not much money. Ten dollars an hour, plus tips. A far cry from where Cora had been a few years earlier, working at a large law firm and making $56,000 a year plus benefits. Not bad for a single mom without a college degree. Not bad for a woman who, when we met, was $10,000 behind on her rent and struggling to find a job.

What happened to Cora during the Great Recession of 2008 is what happened to a lot of people: her employer downsized. Her entire department moved to another state, and she was not invited along. Things took a turn after that. Cora’s lifestyle and friends changed over time, and her old career was not calling her back. So, she moved away from the corporate legal world and into the jobs she could find, which is how she wound up working for $10 an hour plus tips.

There was a problem, though: hardly anybody tipped her. In a given ten-hour shift, Cora washed 50 to 80 heads of hair. A few clients might tip, but sometimes an entire workday would go by without anything. Most of the time, Cora earned less than the mini3 mum wage.

Cora tried talking to Charlotte, the salon’s business manager, but it was a dead end. “The tips will come,” Charlotte assured her. “Just keep doing the job.” This was no solace, to say the least, and it did not pay the bills. The minimum wage violations were constant, but there were other violations, too. Cora never got paid overtime, and she sometimes got paid late. One time when her wages were late, she asked Charlotte where her money was. Charlotte threatened to fire her.

This wage theft took a toll on the former Marine. “It was just so frustrating,” says Cora. Charlotte’s response made her feel worthless, and dismissed.

I couldn’t pay my rent. . . . [E]very two weeks I’d get paid, that check would go right to my landlord. So then my tips, my little bitty tips, were what I needed to eat, to literally go into the grocery store. . . . I would have to get on the train and go out to Maryland and shop because the prices were lower.

But transportation costs money. Everything costs money. Cora was working full time, supporting only herself, and every week she struggled to put food on the table.

At 45, Cora had had a career, she had raised a child, and she couldn’t even make minimum wage. But what could she do? “I knew that I wasn’t making enough and it wasn’t fair,” she says, “but I didn’t have the knowledge or the strength to go after [my wages], to fight for myself.” Depression settled in and got worse over time. “One day it was really bad. It was like suicidal thoughts, you know? And when I felt that, that cold from the knife on my wrist, I was like, ‘Whoa! That’s a little too far . . . you gotta, really gotta get some help.’ ” Finally, she began to see a therapist.

But after a year and a half of wage theft, Cora’s work ethic finally cracked. “I think I basically just got myself fired because I had given up, you know? They weren’t tipping me and they weren’t paying me.” Her work slipped. She stopped putting forth her Marine-best. When Charlotte terminated her, Cora felt relief. Seeing no other options, she just tried to move on.

As a journeyman plumber with 21 years of experience, Earl has real expertise.4 His skills are sought after in a constantly-growing

city, and he is capable of earning a high hourly rate. In fact, he has at times brought home $40 an hour, enough to provide a decent living.

Earl’s ability to make middle-class wages is, unfortunately, often just theoretical. In Earl’s experience, construction contractors undercut even their skilled workers. Throughout his career, employers have denied him overtime, misclassified him as an independent contractor, refused to pay him what they promised, and even refused to pay him anything at all. Once, for example, an employer told him he would be making $40 an hour. That all changed when he started work. “I ended up getting somewhere around $18,” he explains, “[s]o it was either [a] take it or leave it thing.” He took it. It was better than sitting at home collecting unemployment, and Earl is a man who takes pride in working.

In the grand scheme of things, these offenses are relatively rare. Most jobs pass without any drama. But because he can earn a high hourly rate, this wage theft costs Earl a lot of money. When his employers cut his hourly rate in half or refuse to pay overtime, he experiences a double-digit-per-hour dollar reduction. Beyond that, the principle bothers him. Earl knows his rights and he knows what is fair, and his employers’ casual disregard of both is extremely frustrating.

When employers cheat him, though, Earl’s only response is to argue and then, if he can, avoid working for them in the future. Only once has he tried to pursue legal action, and that was because a contractor refused to pay him anything. He cannot afford a lawyer, does not have any legal training, and does not know how to bring a wage claim. “Where do you take your complaint?” he asks. “Do you take it to the city? . . . Where do I go? Who do I complain to?”

But the lack of information isn’t the real barrier. Earl is more than capable of figuring out where to go. In his view, the government is not interested in taking action unless somebody makes a report. When I ask whether he has ever considered doing that, he laughs. “Okay,” he says patiently, “if you step forward, what are the odds? You’re outnumbered with all the contractors here, and then you’ll be scapegoated. You won’t be able to get no work. You won’t be able to find a job. You won’t be able to get nothing. So how do you step forward?”

In early 2018, Arbalis offered Olivia a job in charge of the organization’s programming.5 The salary was not great—$35,000 a year, no benefits—but she believed in the non-profit’s mission.

Though only 28, Olivia’s resume is impressive. She speaks four languages (English, Bengali, Hindi, and some German), has two master’s degrees, and carries herself with an air of professional competence. At first it seemed like the Arbalis Founder and President, Steven, recognized her value. He praised her effusively in the offer letter and spoke in idealistic, inspiring ways about the job.

Olivia’s opinion of the job quickly soured. The days were longer than promised, and the low pay began to grate after 50 hours a week. Worse, though, Steven was hard to work for. He nitpicked her work, made condescending and racist comments, and blamed Olivia for things that she felt were not her fault. Olivia began to look for other jobs, but things came to a head when she took a sick day.

Steven responded badly. He insisted she was violating workplace rules and unlawfully demanded a doctor’s note. Olivia refused, explaining that she could not afford to see a doctor. Steven fired her, refused to pay Olivia her final wages, and, when she demanded them, escalated his threats. He accused her of a litany of imagined offenses and threatened legal action. If Steven sued Olivia, he promised she would be liable for more than $150,000 in damages. Worst of all, he told her she had committed an unnamed felony that, he claimed, carried a five-year prison term and $250,000 fine.

These were stunning threats, especially for a recent immigrant with little savings and no knowledge of the American legal system. The experience was deeply upsetting and strained her relationship with her husband. “I’m depressed and unhappy because of this whole situation,” Olivia says. “I don’t really feel like going anywhere or doing anything.”

Olivia found a new and better job, but Steven continued to refuse to pay her. She contacted several attorneys, but none would take her case. Her claim, worth about $2,400 in unpaid wages, was just too small.

With nowhere else to turn, Olivia filed a wage claim with the District of Columbia Department of Employment Services (DOES). The experience was an exercise in frustration. She learned that the

agency is disorganized, slow, and uncommunicative. DOES repeatedly lost evidence, like Olivia’s paystubs and offer letter, forcing her to re-submit information. Her claims examiner often ignored her emails and phone calls, confused the details of her claim, and refused to provide her with a copy of her own complaint. It took two and a half months for DOES to even send notice of Olivia’s wage claim to Arbalis and another month before the agency informed Olivia that it would be holding a factfinding and mediation conference. That conference, however, never got scheduled.

“It is getting ridiculous,” Olivia said after several months. “[I am] really confused about why it is taking [DOES] so long to take every small step.”7 After nine months, there had been no substantive movement on her claim. As far as she could tell, the agency had not collected any additional evidence, made any findings, or taken any meaningful action.8 Olivia gave up on the government. With the help of a pro bono attorney, she settled her claim with Arbalis. Although she did not recover the damages and penalties she was entitled to, she was happy to just have the experience behind her.9

Cora, Earl, and Olivia work in vastly different industries, have divergent skillsets, and run the gamut in age, background, and education. But, as with so many working people, the common thread that ties together the tapestry of their experiences is wage theft.

Wage theft occurs when an employer denies a worker the wages or benefits to which they are entitled.10 While wage theft affects workers of all backgrounds and in every industry, low-wage workers—and especially women, people of color, immigrants, and those with little formal education—are more susceptible to abuse than others.11 Common forms of wage theft include not paying the minimum wage, denying overtime, misclassifying employees as independent contractors, and paying workers less than promised.12 At best, wage theft reflects a lack of knowledge about the basic mandates of employment law; at worst, it is a casual and callous repudiation of the minimum workplace standards that society has

deemed necessary. In every instance, it is an unlawful and unacceptable denial of civil rights.

Over the past fifteen years, researchers, activists, commentators, and politicians have paid a significant amount of attention to this problem. The picture that emerges is stark. Wage theft is pervasive and highly impactful. Its most frequent victims are the working poor,13 who simultaneously need the money the most and are the least able to enforce their rights.14 It reduces personal incomes by thousands of dollars per year and collectively costs low-wage workers billions in unpaid earnings.15

Wage theft’s harms reverberate beyond the individuals who experience it, depriving families, neighborhoods, and entire communities of a shocking amount of money. In doing so, it perpetuates the vicious cycle of poverty, dragging hundreds of thousands of families below the poverty line despite their hard work.16 The consequences are significant. Wage theft inflames a range of social problems, as poverty is linked with shorter lifespans,17 poor health,18 eviction,19 and unsafe neighborhoods.20 Over time, wage theft creates a direct barrier to generational economic advancement.

But the harms of wage theft are far more than economic. For people living on the economic margins of society, who depend on every dollar in every paycheck just to make ends meet, wage theft presents a distinct threat to their way of being. Even being denied a hundred dollars can put a person on the wrong side of hunger, homelessness, and despair. Beyond that, low-wage workers are largely aware of their own mistreatment and frequently experience anger, frustration, and depression because of wage theft. In other words, Cora, Earl, and Olivia’s stories are not especially egregious, offensive, or uncommon examples of what America’s low-wage

Crime: A Meta-Analysis , CRIME & JUST. 373, (2005).

workers experience, but the opposite : Their stories are all too typical.

This increased attention to wage theft has not fallen on deaf ears. Recently, states and cities have broadly reformed their laws in response to emerging research and social pressure.21 These legal reforms commonly enhance civil and criminal penalties for wage theft, incentivize action by the private bar, expand the enforcement capabilities of government agencies, impose reporting requirements on employers, and provide new avenues for relief.22 These changes have been inspiring, timely, and important.

But the central thesis of this Article is that responses to wage theft, including the actions taken by some of the most progressive jurisdictions, are fundamentally inadequate. In both passage and implementation, anti-wage theft policies are broadly predicated on a misunderstanding of what wage theft is and how it works. The remedies we create and the ways we administer them are centered on the idea that wage theft is a personal problem that can be adequately addressed through laws and processes that encourage individuals to take action. It is not, and it cannot be.

This Article argues that wage theft is a social problem that cannot be meaningfully remedied through an enforcement scheme that emphasizes private causes of action and passive, complaint-based administrative processes. Until policymakers understand that wage theft is a widespread public problem that not only deserves but requires a broad, proactive social response, low-wage workers will continue to have their most basic rights violated—frequently, flagrantly, and to great harm.

This Article explores the problem of wage theft by tracing its contours, discussing existing solutions, and explaining the failures of these approaches. Part I defines wage theft and summarizes its scope and severity. In doing so, I rely on both existing quantitative research and my own in-depth analysis of wage theft among lowwage workers in the District of Columbia (D.C.). In the wake of D.C.’s own sweeping statutory reforms, I conducted approximately 60 semi-structured interviews with low-wage workers, workers’ rights activists, employment lawyers, and a small number of employers and government actors. This research provides texture to the economic realities of wage theft and, for the first time, explores

the personal and social consequences of basic workplace rights violations.

Part II summarizes how we think about and have responded to this social problem. We conceive of wage theft as a civil offense, a personal issue that should be dealt with on an individual, case-bycase basis, much like a dispute over a car accident or a contract. Both the laws designed to combat wage theft and the actual approach of government actors reflect this thinking. Legal reforms emphasize private action and individual empowerment, while government agencies have overwhelmingly adopted a passive, lenient, complaint-based approach to workplace standards enforcement.

Part III explores why current legal reforms and enforcement strategies are failing. Statutory changes are crucially important. Standing alone, however, existing countermeasures are inadequate. They are premised on the idea that individual empowerment can present a meaningful response to this social problem, but this misses the key fact: the vast majority of low-wage workers who suffer wage theft will never take formal action, so a plan that overwhelmingly relies on expanding private causes of action is destined to fail. As my research from D.C. shows, even with robust laws, wage theft still plagues working people.

Finally, Part IV provides a summary of best practices regarding wage theft. Because this issue is a complex and widespread public problem, it requires a strategic, thoughtful, and multifaceted social response. The final section details the requirements of an effective enforcement scheme, explaining why this approach is necessary.

I. THE SOCIAL HARM OF WAGE THEFT

We typically think about wage theft as a problem that is properly addressed on an individual basis. To that end, reforms—both as written and applied—largely focus on empowering aggrieved workers to bring legal claims and collect unpaid wages and penalties.23

This section directly challenges this underlying premise through a review of the practical realities of wage theft. It is not a personal issue. It is—and must be treated as—a social problem because wage theft is pervasive and highly impactful. It costs affected workers thousands of dollars per year,24 undermining society’s most basic workplace protections. Its harms are not purely economic, howev-

er. Frequently, its victims experience devastating cascading harms, including hunger, homelessness, lasting anger, and deep depression. Even beyond these personal impacts, wage theft broadly hurts society, siphoning billions from low-income communities and trapping families in the vicious cycle of poverty.25 It also denies billions in revenue to the government.26 Finally, wage theft harms employers, distorting the labor market and depriving honest businesses of the opportunity to fairly compete.

A . The Economic Costs of Wage Theft

A wealth of quantitative research paints a clear picture: violations of bedrock employment laws are part and parcel of America’s capitalist economic landscape and cost people and society an extraordinary amount of money.

1. Minimum Wage Violations

Minimum wage violations are significant in both size and scope. Utilizing broad surveys and large-scale data sets from the Census Bureau, researchers estimate that roughly seventeen to 26% of lowwage workers experience minimum wage violations each year.27 These abuses are generally significant to individuals and low-wage workers. A 2009 survey of almost 4,400 low-income people in Los Angeles, Chicago, and New York City found that almost 60% of those who experienced minimum wage violations were underpaid by more than $1 per hour.28 Analyses of Census Bureau data estimate that minimum wage violations cost affected workers about one-quarter of their earnings.29 In real dollars-and-cents terms, the average affected low-income person who works year round has about $3,300 stolen per year, reducing their take-home earnings to only about $10,500.30 These costs add up; collectively, low-wage

workers are estimated to lose $15 billion per year to minimum wage violations alone, artificially placing hundreds of thousands of families below the federal poverty line.31

2. Independent Contractor Misclassification

Independent contractor misclassification is one of the most common and damaging kinds of wage theft. Misclassification occurs in every sector, but it is particularly flagrant where it will be most profitable, like the construction industry,32 and where the work is relatively isolated, like the cleaning and trucking industries.33

Nearly all workers in the United States fall into two categories: employees and independent contractors. Generally speaking, employees labor for a single employer who exercises control over them.34 The true independent contractor, on the other hand, is someone with a particular skill who runs their own business, enjoys considerable autonomy, and has a number of clients.35 Independent contractors, then, do not depend on one particular entity for their wages, nor are they closely directed and controlled by their employers. Here is a classic example: servers at a restaurant are employees, but a plumber who fixes a leaky pipe at the restaurant is an independent contractor. There is no ongoing relationship, the restaurant does not control the plumber’s work, and the plumber has expertise.36

It is almost always more beneficial to be classified as an employee. Employees are protected by wage and hour laws, have the right to form unions, enjoy access to workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance, and pay fewer taxes on their earnings.37 Businesses, in turn, are required to pay a variety of taxes for each of their employees, including Social Security, Medicare, and unem-

ployment insurance.38 Additionally, anti-discrimination laws only cover employees.39

Businesses often wrongly label their employees as independent contractors to save money on labor costs. Studies repeatedly find that at least eleven to 30% of businesses misclassify at least one worker.40 Overall, there may be several million misclassified workers nationally.41

Misclassification is also called payroll fraud because, often, the point is to lie to the government to avoid taxes.42 These taxes include contributions to the crucial programs that form the social safety net. Every year, as workers are paid off the books or misclassified, billions of dollars of payroll are never reported to the government.43 The cost to society is enormous, “robbing unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation funds of billions.”44 And when wrongly-classified workers do attempt to take advantage of these entitlements—as many eventually do—they are either denied the benefits or else society is forced to absorb the costs.

3. Overtime, Time Shaving, Illegal Deductions, and Tip Stealing

Research on other kinds of wage theft has been much more limited. There are no studies evaluating the rates at which employers unlawfully deny their employees access to workers’ compensation, unemployment, and guaranteed sick leave. Nor have there been studies examining how often employers misclassify their workers as exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections. For many kinds of wage theft, the landmark survey of 4,400 low-wage workers discussed above provides the best—and only—information we have on violation rates. Those findings are summarized in Table 1.1.45

TABLE 1.1: FINDINGS ON OTHER FORMS OF WAGE THEFT

Form of Wage Theft | Violation Rate Failure to pay overtime | 76% Unpaid off-the clock work | 70% Illegaldeductions | 41% Tip stealing | 12%

B. The Personal Costs of Wage Theft

The overwhelming majority of wage theft research has been quantitative. As discussed, researchers tend to use large data sets to analyze and estimate the trends and economic consequences of various types of wage theft. Although incredibly useful, this body of research is missing a strong representation of the viewpoints and experiences of low-wage workers themselves. While the raw statistics are damning, they do not fully describe the texture of the economic and social hardships caused by wage theft.

Over the course of eighteen months, I conducted an in-depth, qualitative study on wage theft. I focused on wage theft among lowwage workers in the District in the wake of the city passing one of the most robust and progressive anti-wage theft laws in the country.46 One key finding is that wage theft imposes significant personal costs on those who experience it, and these costs are of great concern. To reiterate, I interviewed approximately 60 people. Most were low-wage workers (n=33), but I also spoke with policy stakeholders, including workers’ rights activists (n=12), employment lawyers (n=10), and a small number of employers and government actors. The takeaway is this: wage theft causes significant harm that goes beyond the dollars-and-cents of it all and is rarely something that can simply be absorbed or ignored.

To grasp the full range of economic harm caused by wage theft, it is necessary to understand the crime in context. For the low-wage workers who experience it, wage theft is about more than just an immediate loss of money. Low-wage workers do not have signifi-

cant savings to fall back on.47 Most live paycheck to paycheck, making for a tenuous existence, and there is a thin, blurry line between survival and tragedy.

Being denied payment often cascades into other escalating harms. If wages are late, short, or entirely unpaid, the whole fragile scheme holding together a person’s life can be put in jeopardy. This is because the real experience of being poor does not come from just one aspect of poverty, like bad housing, food insecurity, or a lack of healthcare. The essence of poverty lies in how a person’s hardships coalesce, interact, and build upon one another.48 It is this interaction that defines the lives of the working poor, and the danger of wage theft’s overflowing harms is what threatens the delicate balance of a person’s existence. When the money workers expect and need suddenly is not there, they are forced to navigate a maze of hard choices. Making it through becomes a question of strategy. Who to call? Who to borrow money from? What is the best approach to take with utility companies, the phone company, and the landlord? Does rent get prioritized? Heat? Food?

Jonathan Tucker, a DC-area employment lawyer who primarily represents underpaid immigrants, knows well the problems that his clients suffer:

[T]he fundamental issue that we’re dealing with, wage theft, is if people were just paid the wages that they work [and] that they earn, well, you no longer have a failure to pay rent, which is what I was dealing with [when I worked] at Legal Aid. You no longer have credit card debt collection, which is what I was dealing with at Legal Aid, or a foreclosure case. . . . All these other problems that are generated by a failure to pay wages are resolved.49

According to Jonathan, wage theft lawsuits are “a way to attack the cancer” at the heart of misfortune.50

As Jonathan knows, low-wage workers struggle to meet their most basic needs when they are not paid properly. Harriet, for example, is a DC government employee who has an acrimonious relationship with her supervisor.51 On two occasions, the agency she works for held up her paycheck without explanation, which Harriet blames on her supervisor’s animosity.52 Once, she went unpaid for several weeks. “I had to make arrangements with the rent,” she says, her frustration apparent. “[My landlady] was getting tired, because nobody wants to hear that your job is holding your pay. You’re a government employee! They don’t believe that! So I had to show proof, you know, that I’ve been begging for money [from my employer].”53

This is a common theme. Workers frequently tell of managing their wage theft by borrowing money to pay for necessities. Often, they must choose among those necessities, picking between rent and food, utilities and transportation. Some things are easier to cut out, like trips to the movies or new clothes. It is far more difficult to choose among the basic and common requirements of modern life.

The more severe or chronic the wage theft, the harder it becomes to balance competing obligations. For many, trouble eventually strikes in the form of an unanticipated hardship. While Ameen was struggling to get his former employer to pay him his earned wages, for example, he got sick and had to go to the emergency room.54 This is an expensive stopgap at best, and cost him about $1,500.55 Manageable if he had been paid the more than $40,000 his former employer owed him.56 Unmanageable because he had not. His car was repossessed, and when we met, he was being evicted.57

Eviction is a looming threat in the lives of the working poor, and researchers increasingly recognize it as a significant social problem. In Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City , sociologist Matthew Desmond reveals the stark ways in which eviction is both a consequence and a driver of poverty.58 Poor people struggle with bills and face homelessness as a result. This threat of homelessness,

in turn, leads to a slew of negative outcomes, including joblessness, hunger, trauma, and unstable communities.59 When working people are denied their earned wages, the threat of eviction—among others—looms larger and larger over time. Many people, like Ameen, quickly face homelessness after falling behind.60 Others are lucky enough to have charitable or understanding landlords, but patience runs thin over time. Beyond that, the reality of debt and the prospect of eviction is itself difficult. Carol, for example, is tens of thousands of dollars in debt to her landlord.61 “What judge do you think that won’t tell me to get out, and I won’t even give you 30 days?” she asks.62 Like many, the piling bills threaten to overwhelm Carol, and as the next section explains, the strain of such circumstances is itself harmful.

2. Mental Costs

Most wage theft research discusses its economic consequences. There are also significant human costs, however. Wage theft presents high economic stakes for the working poor, but it is also personally offensive and can lead to severe emotional and psychological strain.

This is not true for every low-wage worker. But those who do not express strong negative feelings about their wage theft are typically unaware of their rights violations. Ashna and Sabbir, for example, did not know that their former employers had illegally denied them overtime, thinking instead that this practice simply reflected a lawful business decision.63 But stories like this present the exception to the rule. Most workers are generally aware, or at some point become aware, of their own mistreatment,64 and their feelings of injustice combined with the stress of wage theft’s cascading economic harms elicits powerful reactions.

Low-wage workers frequently express anger, frustration, and depression over their wage theft. These feelings are understandable. The situation is defined by their illegal exploitation, directly harms their financial security, and offers few opportunities for redress. Miranda, for example, worked for a large department store that frequently shaved time off of her paycheck.65 She began to track her hours, and each time she confronted her supervisors, the store admitted its fault and paid her at least some of her money.66 But the delay carried costs, and the act itself deeply offended her. “[There] was one time that my lights almost got turned out,” she says, clearly frustrated. “I would have to borrow money to pay my gas or my electric bill, you know, because [my employer] was messing up! And I told them that, you know? I’ve earned this!”67

These expressions of anger are common. “It used to be a saying about work, how people go postal,” says Kira, who consistently fights to have her employer follow D.C.’s paid sick days law. “I clearly now understand that meaning . . . .”68 Kira is not going to actually attack people, but she is describing the intense frustration that many feel as a result of having to address pay-related inconsistencies and aggravations that, in their mind, should both not exist and be easily resolved.

These feelings do not just flow from a loss of money. The principle matters. “I’ve been cheated for a long time,” says Will, who discovered that for years his employer had been paying him less than he had been promised.69 “His refusal to pay has even made it worse, knowing that he’s wrong. . . . I think I’m more upset because of his refusal to honor what he’s owed.”70 Others echo Will’s thoughts. Being paid late “makes you feel degraded, like you’re useless,” Harriet says.71 “Worthless,” agrees Cora.72

As these conversations suggest, many also express a deep sadness when talking about their experiences with wage theft. Just under half of the workers I interviewed (16 of 33) expressed feeling depressed, embarrassed, or ashamed over the violations of their workplace rights, including both their treatment by employers and their perceived and practical inability to do anything about it. It

was upsetting for these people to have to grapple with the reality that they were being wronged and that there was no easy, clear, or reliable path to justice.

Wrapped up in work is pride, a sense that a person is a part of the broader American economic landscape, capable of supporting themselves and the ones they love. When this is suddenly not the case, and when it is because of another person’s unlawful acts, the experience can be deeply upsetting. Caleb’s former employer, for instance, underpaid him for more than four years, often drastically so.73 Conservatively, his employer owes him tens of thousands of dollars. Because of this, he lives with his sister and cannot afford to buy birthday presents for his grandchildren. “I don’t feel [like] a man,” he says. “I ain’t a grandfather!”74

The consequences of wage theft can spiral out of control, as the confluence of economic insecurity and mental distress drive some to contemplate suicide. The combined strain of these factors helps explain why suicide is linked to poverty and periods of economic hardship,75 and why raising the minimum wage reduces suicide rates.76 Recall Cora, whose story began this Article. She attempted to kill herself, and only, at the last moment, diverted from that path and entered into therapy.77 Like Cora, James—a grocery store worker—is also in therapy. “I get at the point where I want to kill myself sometimes, you know?” he says. “It’s really rough. It’s already hard enough, and to have to fight just to get the money [] . . . it’s rough.”78

Harriet did not herself attempt suicide, but her father did. He is sick and moved in with her when her mother died. “My father was getting depressed because he was worried about me getting fired, and it was just a mess,” she says. She speaks quickly, clipping her words with anger. “He would try to commit suicide . . . . [H]e was trying to take pills so he wouldn’t be a burden.”79

Although this study has been the first to deeply explore the personal and social consequences of wage theft, these conclusions find support in others’ research. In studying how well Californians are

able to collect on their favorable wage judgments, researchers interviewed low-wage workers who had experienced wage theft and attempted to assert their rights.80 They reported feeling frustrated, angry, and depressed over their treatment, the material hardships caused by wage theft, and the inefficacy of the legal system. One explained that “[t]here were even days where I had nothing to eat, and I had to go look for donations to find food for my family,” which “made me feel very depressed.”81 Another said she “felt upset and powerless not to collect” the money she earned.82

In short, although wage theft research has tended to focus on monetary costs, it also threatens its victims with significant emotional trauma, both because it causes cascading economic consequences and because many of its victims find it personally offensive.

3. Health Consequences

Wage theft also contributes to poor physical health by exacerbating poverty, which has long been linked to negative health outcomes.83 Researchers estimate that minimum wage violations alone artificially force hundreds of thousands of people into poverty.84 Even those victims who do not technically fall below the poverty line suffer a loss to their economic well-being.

Less money leads to a harder life. Poor people, adults and children alike, are more likely to experience a variety of chronic health conditions, including diabetes, heart disease, obesity, stress, headaches, and ear infections.85 Because most of those without health insurance are poor or near-poor, they are also far less likely to seek treatment.86

Like eviction and wage theft, poor health both derives from and worsens poverty. Low-income people live in substandard housing,87 are exposed to more pollution, have less access to healthy food, and tend to live more sedentary lifestyles because fewer safe recreational activities are available.88 Poor neighborhoods experience more violent crime,89 which has devastating long-term effects. Children who grow up in violent communities have lower grades, less interest in school, and do poorly on standardized tests. They simply do not have the same opportunities to flourish, grow, and succeed.

These consequences add up and create stark outcomes. On average, “[i]mpoverished adults live seven to eight years less than those who have incomes four or more times the federal poverty level.”91 Put simply, the chronic and costly nature of wage theft exacerbates the vicious cycle of poverty, imposing severe costs not just on immediate victims, but also on their family members, neighbors, and communities.

C. Economic Costs Revisited: Wage Theft, Market Distortion, and High-Road Employers

Finally, one other group suffers as a result of wage theft: honest employers. Although the issue is often cast in terms of workers versus employers, this is a limited way to think about it. The fact is, many people genuinely seek to run law-abiding businesses. But when they are forced to compete in industries where wage theft is rampant, the struggle of starting and managing a business becomes that much more difficult as they find themselves undercut by their unscrupulous competitors. In many industries, the corrupted nature of the market itself creates a powerful incentive to violate the law.

Aaron Seyedian is one such legitimate employer. He owns WellPaid Maids, a cleaning service in the D.C. and Boston metropolitan

areas.92 Well-Paid Maids is an anomaly in the home cleaning business, which features high wage theft rates.93 Aaron’s employees earn $17 an hour, have health care, get 22 paid days off per year, and have 100% employer-paid short-term disability leave, among other benefits.94

“Most of my competitors lack valid business licenses, do not pay sales tax, and misclassify workers,” Aaron says.95 These illegal practices are very profitable. “Typical margins for a 1099 company in the cleaning industry [are] 40, 45%,” Aaron explains.96 “Our profit margin[] oscillates month-to-month. . . . [B]asically, on paper it’s 20%. After emergencies and crises are added in, it’s around 16 or 17%.”97 That is a stunning difference, to say the least. The only reason Aaron has been able to make it work is because he did not take a salary for the first year he was in business and because he operates only in places where there are enough affluent, social-justice minded people willing to pay his significantly higher rates.98 “[I]f you book a weekly cleaning with some other service in D.C., you can very easily get your one bedroom, one bathroom clean for like $89 each time,” he says.99 “Whereas from us, it’s going to cost $149 or $139, depending on what time you book, right? So, people see that and they balk. Not all people, but a substantial contingent of people, and it’s because they’re used to prices that are set by illegal practices. . . [.]”100

There is an important takeaway here. Wage theft is widespread, its victims are rarely able to find vindication,101 and government enforcement is uncommon and inadequate. For employers like Aaron Seyedian, wage theft distorts the competitive market. In many industries, legal guarantees for workers have become liabilities for employers who wish to be decent but are torn between the moral imperative of following basic workplace laws and the realities of running a business.

1098. 102. See Janice Fine, Enforcing Labor Standards in Partnership with Civil Society: Can CoEnforcement Succeed Where the State Alone Has Failed? , POL. & SOC’Y 359, 360–61 (2017).

The research presented here illustrates the central thesis of this Article: wage theft is not an individualized issue, but one that causes broad and lasting harm to society generally. Violations of our nation’s bedrock employment laws are common and cause significant financial and emotional harm to workers, high-road employers, and labor markets in general.

Because wage theft is a broad, multi-faceted social problem, effectively attacking it requires a concerted, social approach. As discussed in the next Part, however, legal interventions generally do not reflect this idea. Rather than focus on public-driven systemic change, popular reforms instead attempt to empower individuals.

II. WAGE THEFT REFORMS AND ENFORCEMENT STRATEGIES

Over the last fifteen years, activists and workers have mobilized to demand action from elected officials.103 Because of partisan divides and powerful special interests, federal workplace protections such as the Fair Labor Standards Act and National Labor Relations Act have atrophied through congressional inaction.104 Consequently, reformers have turned their energy to state legislatures and courthouses. In many ways, they have been extremely successful. States and cities across the country have reformed and updated existing laws to better attack wage theft.

This Part provides an overview of these legal changes and their implementation. Reforms generally fall into four categories:

1. Laws broadening the definition of “employment”;

2. Laws enhancing civil and criminal penalties;

3. Laws creating or expanding causes of action and avenues for relief; and

4. Laws imposing more stringent recordkeeping requirements.

In both design and implementation, however, these reforms largely reflect the common misconception that wage theft is an individual problem that can and should be solved through personal empowerment and individual mobilization.

A . “Employment” Redefined

The first type of reform broadens the definition of “employment” to empower more people to invoke protective laws. As discussed in Part I, whether a person is classified as an employee or an independent contractor has an enormous impact on their legal status. Independent contractors pay a higher tax rate and are explicitly exempt from bedrock labor, employment, and antidiscrimination laws,105 and cannot access key social safety net protections.106

Whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor depends on how a jurisdiction defines “employment.” Every jurisdiction has legal tests to analyze this issue. Adding to this confusion, different statutes often have different tests.107

One way to address misclassification is to change the legal standard to more clearly include more workers under the umbrella of “employee.” In doing so, people gain both legal protections and the right to sue to enforce those rights.

Most tests analyzing whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor evaluate a number of issues. Common factors include whether the worker is closely controlled, paid hourly, in a long-term relationship with the putative employer, and competes in the marketplace.108 These multi-factor tests can be confusing and difficult to apply. This creates a significant amount of uncertainty, and the grey area provides employers with broad opportunities to (mis)classify workers as independent contractors.

Lately, another test has become increasingly popular. In contrast to traditional analyses, the “ABC Test” is simple. It places the burden on the employer to prove that a worker is an independent contractor by showing that they:

  • A. are free from the employer’s control, both in writing and in fact;
  • B. perform work that is outside of the employer’s usual course of business; and
  • C. are engaged in an independently established business of their own.109

This test represents a significant shift. For example, under many analyses, Uber drivers are independent contractors.110 Under the ABC test, they are almost certainly employees.111 Because both gig work and franchising arrangements have become fixtures of the American economy,112 the ABC test has the potential to drastically change the nature of work in America.

While present in one form or another in many states,113 the ABC test shot to prominence in 2018 when the California Supreme Court adopted the test for wage and hour purposes.114 Then, in 2019, California expanded on this decision by legislatively adopting the ABC test more broadly and applying it to the entire Labor Code with only a few exceptions.115 Given California’s status as both a progressive trendsetter116 and a large economy,117 this decision made waves. Other states are now considering adopting the ABC test in whole or in part,118 potentially re-classifying millions of people.119

B. Enhancing Civil and Criminal Penalties

Perhaps the most popular type of reform enhances civil and criminal penalties for wage theft. This approach relies on the criminological theory of deterrence, reasoning that harsher punish-

ments will result in fewer crimes.120 Jurisdictions frequently allow workers to recover significant damages on top of unpaid wages and empower the government to impose costly fines and penalties.121 Many places now also threaten criminal sanctions.122

There is good reason to support penalty enhancements. They compensate aggrieved workers for their added time and effort and can fund government anti-wage theft initiatives. Crucially, penalty enhancements also reduce minimum wage violations. To evaluate the efficacy of different kinds of anti-wage theft laws, political scientist Daniel Galvin used United States Census Bureau data to analyze minimum wage violations before and after legal reforms.124 He found that penalty enhancements do reduce violation rates; in particular, allowing workers to recover treble (triple) damages causes a meaningful and statistically significant reduction in minimum wage violations.125 Other civil and criminal penalty enhancements might also reduce wage theft, but the evidence is weaker.126

Crucially, it is not enough to just pass these laws. Actual enforcement matters. If the government signals to employers that it is not that interested in meaningfully punishing wage theft, then statutory protections lose much of their power. For example, after Ohio voters amended the state constitution to allow unpaid workers to collect treble damages, minimum wage violation rates significantly declined.127 But when Ohio’s governor issued an executive order waiving imposition of these penalties for first-time or isolated violations, violation rates returned to their pre-reform levels.128

“Enforcement strategies matter” is a common-sense idea, but it has found empirical support elsewhere as well. Florida has an “unusually high” rate of minimum wage abuse, which researchers at the Economic Policy Institute attribute in part to the fact that the state got rid of its labor standards enforcement agency in 2002.129 When employers have little reason to fear punishment for wage theft, they are emboldened to steal from their workers.

C . Expanding Avenues for Relief

While unpaid employees have always had the power to sue to enforce their rights in court, this is far easier said than done. The civil justice system is hard to navigate for the vast majority of people. In particular, low-wage workers do not have legal training, familiarity with the civil justice system, or the ability to hire a lawyer.130 Even if a person does gather the resources to file a lawsuit, they are usually outmatched by their employers, who tend to have more economic and social power and, therefore, greater access to key resources like time, knowledge, and legal representation.

In an effort to address this imbalance, reforms attempt to make it easier to take formal action. This approach includes both expanding administrative paths to legal action and incentivizing attorneys to take on wage theft cases.

Many states (and some large cities) have local equivalents of the federal Department of Labor (DOL) that monitor employment and enforce workplace laws.131 Across the country, workers are increasingly able to file legal complaints with these agencies, which may then investigate claims, hold hearings, and issue judgments.132 In practice, however, the power and efficacy of these agencies varies widely. The D.C. DOES, for example, may investigate all allegations of wage theft and retaliation and order the same remedies as a court, including fines, liquidated damages, attorney’s fees, and injunctions.133 In contrast, Colorado’s Department of Labor and Employment may only investigate claims worth $7,500 or less.134

Workers can also sue their employers in small claims court, although there are upper limits on the value of such cases.135 This is not a heavily-studied forum for addressing wage theft, but recently some scholars have begun to urge reforms to streamline and encourage unpaid wage claims.136

In theory, at least, these alternative paths should provide people with an easy, fast, and accessible avenue for rights enforcement. In

practice, most low-wage workers are unsure where to even begin. Many also lack the confidence to act.138

Finally, the District has had some success experimenting with generous attorney’s fees as a way to induce lawyers to take on wage theft suits. While successful plaintiffs have long been entitled to recover fees and costs under the Fair Labor Standards Act,139 the District’s Wage Theft Prevention Amendment Act of 2014 enshrined high hourly rates for attorneys.140 For example, attorneys with up to three years of experience have a statutory rate of almost $375 per hour.141

According to worker-side employment lawyers in the D.C. area, this fee-shifting provision has expanded access to legal representation by making a broader range of cases financially feasible. As Michael Amster, a partner at a local employment law firm, explains, the law “allow[s] us to take cases that we otherwise wouldn’t take. It allows us to be able to justify taking smaller cases . . . . Because frankly, in a lot of these cases you’re dealing with people who are making very little money and sometimes what is owed to them is not that much.”142 Those smaller cases are now more viable because the law has created a higher return for lawyers.

High hourly rates can only help so many people obtain representation, because private attorneys are unwilling to take on claims with an uncertain payday. There are two main reasons why somebody with a strong wage theft claim will nevertheless be unable to find an attorney. First, many low-wage workers toil for fly-by-night employers who operate on the margins of the system. They regularly skirt labor laws and have few assets, and because of this, they are hard to nail down and collect money from.143

Second, most wage claims are still just too small. Two attorneys privately told me that they refuse to take on clients whose unpaid wages are less than $10,000, a high threshold for workers to meet. The reason this matters is because fee-shifting provisions allow victorious plaintiffs to recover “reasonable” attorney’s fees; this means

that such fees are usually proportionally related to the value of the underlying claim. In reality, most low-wage workers cannot reach these implied threshold requirements to obtain representation.

D . Recordkeeping Requirements

Finally, anti-wage theft laws often impose new or more stringent recordkeeping and transparency requirements on employers.144 This places the burden on the party with the best ability to preserve the kind of evidence (e.g. paychecks) that is crucial to determining whether wage and hour laws were violated. Typically, employers are subject to fines and penalties for not keeping accurate records.145 In some cases, a failure to preserve records reduces the burden of proof for plaintiffs, making it easier to win wage claims.146

In addition, new laws require employers to provide key information in writing to new hires, including the legal name of the employer, rate of pay, and regular payday.147 Finally, many states empower government agencies to proactively investigate wage theft allegations, requiring employers to make their records available for investigators to review.148 Although this right is limited to some extent by the Fourth Amendment,149 it still has the potential to be a powerful enforcement tool.

E. The Realities of Wage Theft Enforcement

This collection of reforms reflects the current gold standard for anti-wage theft laws. On paper, they fairly compensate workers, significantly sanction employers, and smooth the legal process by creating new ways to bring claims, incentivize representation, and ensure the preservation of evidence. These laws also make the government a more active participant in the employment relationship by meaningfully enhancing the power of administrative agencies and prosecutors.

In practice, though, these powers go unused.

Criminal penalty enhancements, for example, draw upon the belief that we should treat wage theft like “regular” theft.150 These reforms satisfy a visceral sense of justice and have made some waves in popular media, but they are largely hollow because few prosecutors pursue criminal sanctions.151 Nationally, the Fair Labor Standards Act has criminalized “willful” minimum wage and overtime violations for decades.152 In some parts of the country, wage theft has long been a criminal offense under state law.153 And yet, prosecution is and always has been extremely rare.154

Likewise, very few labor standards enforcement agencies actually invoke their mandates by engaging in proactive investigations. Instead, the vast majority rely on a passive, complaint-based approach to enforcement. They wait for workers to come forward with complaints and then work to bring a particular employer into compli155 ance.

Part of the problem stems from the government not investing enough resources in these agencies. The DOL, for instance, had as many wage and hour investigators in 2014 as in 1948, despite the fact that the agency now covers a workforce six times the size.156 Many state agencies are even worse off. Six states have no labor standards enforcement agency and 26 have fewer than 10 investigators.157 And these weaknesses show. A 2009 audit by the Government Accountability Office found significant flaws in the DOL’s complaint process, including “delays in investigating complaints, complaints not recorded in the WHD database, failure to use all available enforcement tools because of a lack of resources, failure to follow up on employers who agreed to pay, and a poor complaint intake process.”158 Similar problems exist even in progressive bastions.159

But a lack of resources is not the only reason why the government fails to utilize the tools available to it. Agencies’ passive, waitand-see approach to wage theft enforcement reflects the broader social belief that wage theft is, fundamentally, a personal problem.

Many government actors are unwilling to act proactively and aggressively because doing so would upset the status quo and run contrary to broadly-held beliefs about wage theft.160

The above reforms, while able to make some difference, are premised on the belief that empowering individuals is an effective way to broadly attack this social problem and achieve justice for low-wage workers. As the next section illustrates, this belief is entirely wrong.