Skip to main content

The Ragged Edge of Rugged Individualism: Wage Theft and the Personalization of Social Harm (University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 2021) (Part 3 of 3)

Part 3 of 3

1. Building Confidence Among Stakeholders

An effective attack on wage theft necessarily requires workers, advocates, and employment lawyers to have confidence in the government agencies responsible for labor standards enforcement. Many low-income people, however, express a lack of faith in government, viewing it as a distant thing defined by ineptitude or, worse, corruption.296 Others, especially those undocumented, are afraid to go to the government for help.297 To address these issues, government agencies must strive to forge close working relationships with local actors, including community organizations, advocates, and employment lawyers.

Whether low-wage workers distrust or are afraid of the government, stakeholder organizations can serve as trusted intermediaries between authorities and community members. Community leaders, labor unions, and advocates interact closely with working people, and often have credible knowledge of wage theft. These actors are able to conduct outreach, collect information, lend the government some measure of their earned trust and prestige, and help low-wage workers navigate administrative processes. By tapping into the energy and knowledge of these stakeholders, enforcement agencies could vastly improve and increase their reach without expending significant additional resources.

Relatedly, government agencies should actively encourage administrative participation by educated activists and attorneys. In some jurisdictions, this might require legislative reforms entitling agency-litigants to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. But even in D.C., where there is administrative fee-shifting,298 attorneys and activists are reluctant to engage with DOES because they report that the agency is unwelcoming and hard to work with.299 Lawyers and

law school clinics, however, can play an important role. Their participation could improve efficiency and justice by helping to ensure that proof and arguments meet a high standard. If done right, it would also build governmental prestige over time as these stakeholders become more confident in referring workers.

Finally, agencies should build relationships with high-road employers, who typically have both a financial and ideological interest in wage and hour enforcement. In many industries, these people are aware of which of their competitors operate in violation of the law, and many would gladly share that information with the government.

2. Disputing and the Power of Education

As discussed, the vast majority of low-wage people who experience employment rights violations do not approach the government for help. Many of these people stay silent because they do not understand their rights, do not know where to go for help, or do not believe that the government will be willing or able to help them. Agencies could address these key issues through widespread education campaigns. These campaigns must teach people about their rights, including where to go for help, and draw publicity to the problem of wage theft in general.

Standing alone, education is not enough. After all, many of the barriers to claiming analyzed in Part III preclude people from speaking up even when they are fully aware of both their mistreatment and their legal options. But when almost 80% of low-wage workers report that they do not know who to talk to when their rights are violated,300 there is obviously much more work to do.

Enforcement agencies should engage in broad and sustained campaigns to inform low-income people of their wage-related rights. To be successful, agencies must understand the lives of working people and make appropriate outreach efforts. Because many low-wage workers do not own cars and rely on public transit, agencies should place posters and signs on buses and trains. Advertisements should play on local radio stations, including in Spanish and other prominent local languages. Most importantly, representatives from enforcement agencies should directly engage with their constituents by going into community spaces, including churches, shelters, and legal clinics. Face-to-face interactions are key to making government processes and actors seem accessible,

dedicated, and caring. So too are communications through the kinds of intermediaries whom community members tend to trust, like social service non-profits and neighborhood leaders.

Similarly, the government must engage with and educate employers. A significant amount of wage theft occurs not out of malice but because of employer ignorance. Agencies should work with employer-side organizations to develop materials that can be used to quickly and easily inform employers and managers about their legal obligations and the consequences for violating them. Although this kind of information is available online, it is not always easy to find and understand. It could, however, be disseminated cost-effectively through existing processes. For example, each time an employer applies for or renews a business license, they should receive key information about their workplace obligations.

Finally, education campaigns must also draw attention to wage theft itself, explaining what it is and why it is wrong. In light of its realities, the government should call wage theft what it is: a crime, a violation of workers’ fundamental rights, an attack on fair competition, and an affront to the way things should be.

California and Seattle provide models for how the issue should be framed. The California Labor Commissioner’s Office has created a dedicated, attractive, easy-to-navigate web page about wage theft. This website has clear information about workers’ rights, promises protection from retaliation (even for undocumented workers), and has simple directions for filing a variety of complaints.302 Similarly, the Seattle Police Department actively encourages victims of wage theft to file criminal complaints and makes it easy to do so through a basic online form.303 These jurisdictions have both made rights knowledge easily accessible and defined wage theft appropriately.

3. Adopting a Model of Proactive Investigations

Perhaps most importantly, administrative bodies must move beyond their one-off, complaint-based approach to enforcing basic workplace laws. The empirical realities presented in this Article lead to only one conclusion: the standard, passive approach is destined to fail. Agencies must be proactive. They must bring to bear

all of their tools, manpower, and authority to pursue comprehensive investigations. This will require both expanding the frequency of directed (agency-initiated) investigations and changing how the government responds to individual complaints.

First, all enforcement bodies must prioritize actions and investigations in industries that are rife with noncompliance, including service, manufacturing, cleaning, construction, and retail.304 These businesses often employ undocumented or otherwise transient workers who are especially vulnerable and unlikely to go to the government for help. The demographics make investigations that much more difficult, but there are clear examples of agencies finding success through smart strategies.

During the Obama Administration, the Wage and Hour Division (WHD) of the DOL made significant efforts to conduct more directed investigations in high-risk industries.305 By partnering with worker centers, workers’ rights organizations, and labor unions, the WHD was able to learn about and take action over schemes that otherwise might have flown under the radar.306

Similarly, California’s Bureau of Field Enforcement has adopted new and unique strategies. Agents surveil businesses suspected of wage theft to gain an understanding of who works there, what typical shifts look like, and how the businesses are run.307 In recognition of the insecurity and fear that low-wage workers often have, they also conduct off-site interviews with workers prior to physical inspections, both to protect these people and to obtain critical information in a context free of employer coercion and intimidation.308

Government agencies have limited resources, so it is imperative that efforts be focused at the greatest points of leverage. A proactive model will include both random audits, like those undertaken by departments of health across the country, and vigorous investigations based on credible information about violations. Significant weight should be placed on tips provided by worker-friendly organizations, as these groups have credibility in the community and can serve as effective intermediaries.309

Finally, complaints that suggest broader problems should trigger employer-wide investigations. When multiple people complain, agencies should respond decisively by examining the entire busi-

ness. But even some individual complaints should spark broad action. Both Ruben and Lisa, for example, complained to the D.C. DOES that they were working long hours without receiving overtime. DOES found in their favors. Ruben and Lisa also had coworkers with the exact same job titles and duties, strongly suggesting that their employers were violating the law across the board.310 After all, why would a business classify only one of its employees with a particular title as exempt from overtime? The agency should have requested all of their employers’ records for similarly situated employees. It did not. Ruben and Lisa toiled alone, which not only decreased the power and the effect of the agency’s sanction, but also left them exposed to the retaliation they later experienced.

4. Utilizing and Publicizing Enforcement Tools

Passing robust statutes is a crucial first step to addressing wage theft, but unused laws are only worth the paper they are printed on. Administrative agencies should invoke their full repertoire of tools and sanctions, but many do not.

The District illustrates this point. As discussed, the government has broad enforcement authority. It may impose significant civil and criminal sanctions; workers are entitled to treble damages;311 the Attorney General can criminally prosecute wage thieves;312 the government may deny business licenses to those who commit “willful” acts of wage theft;313 and, most importantly, DOES has the explicit authority to proactively initiate investigations.314

But these powers do not get used. Overall, DOES assesses liquidated damages equal to less than 100% of assessed unpaid wages.315 The Attorney General has not brought any criminal prosecutions for wage theft, and the District has not denied business licenses to any unscrupulous employers. Proactive investigations are unheard of.

Given the widespread prevalence of wage theft and the anemic enforcement of wage and hour laws in general, these patterns are almost certainly repeated across the country. Utilizing the full range of enforcement powers might be a controversial idea to some. In particular, the idea of criminal prosecution is conten-

tious.316 But while criminal prosecutions probably cannot be the silver bullet to the heart of wage theft, they can be an important and necessary aspect of a thorough and effective enforcement plan. First, sometimes they are simply appropriate, either because employers engage in such egregious schemes that they deserve a harsher-than-normal punishment, or because employers are judgment-proof and cannot be effectively punished by monetary sanctions. The kinds of fly-by-night operators who frequently steal wages in the underground economy are, often, effectively immune to civil judgments because they simply do not have real assets. Private attorneys will not sue them, and even government agencies have a hard time leveling monetary sanctions. As Paul DeCamp, the former head of the WHD under President George W. Bush explains:

[I]t’s a little bit like whack-a-mole. Because a lot of these companies, they pop up, somebody hears about a problem, that company goes away. The person flees, opens up a new company under a different name, maybe in a different state, and you can expend an extraordinary amount of . . . resources trying to track down these folks with [a] questionable return at the end.317

In these circumstances, there cannot be justice or deterrence unless there are criminal sanctions. Prosecutions send a powerful message: wage theft is a crime and the government takes it seriously. Bringing and publicizing criminal charges would help inspire low-wage workers to trust and cooperate with the government and would also signal to employers that they cannot expect to freely violate the law.

5. Adopting an Anti-Wage Theft Mindset

Finally, strategic enforcement requires agencies to adopt smart strategies and the right mindset. They must always keep overall goals in mind and think carefully about how to best apply limited resources to achieve long-term, industry-wide compliance. A failure to embrace this mode of thinking and to understand the lives and experiences of low-income victims of wage theft has led govern-

ment bodies to adopt enforcement strategies that are complaintdriven and ineffective.

To an extent, the standard approach is understandable. Responding to complaints yields short-term successes, and evaluating investigators based on how quickly they dispose of complaints is an easy metric by which to measure progress. But a complaint-driven orientation does not create the kinds of cultural shifts necessary for long-term deterrence. The best strategy for attacking wage theft is not always the one that yields the fastest or most easily-measured results. The best strategy is one that builds long-term relationships and creates ongoing compliance in an industry as a whole. The suggestions in this Part will help accomplish those goals.

For these changes to truly be successful, however, wage and hour agencies must also institute organizational shifts. They must adopt a clear-eyed and empathetic understanding of what the lives of lowwage workers are actually like. Many of the people who work at enforcement bodies might already have this knowledge, but, broadly speaking, that is not reflected in how their organizations operate. Simply put, it is entirely unrealistic to expect a passive, individualized strategy to be effective when it is a fact that the vast majority of workers whose wages are stolen will never go to the government for help.

Some would assert that when agencies adopt the reforms suggested here, they actually hinder their overall mission. The argument is this: government agencies are supposed to be neutral, unbiased, and fair. Bureaucratic processes were created, in part, to impose neutrality and avoid conflicts of interest. Forging close connections with workers’ rights organizations, conducting focused investigations, declaring wage theft to be a “crime”—all of these tactics will decrease the political capital and overall credibility of an agency by marking it as a partisan and biased actor. This mindset is what former California Labor Commissioner Julie Su calls the “myth of neutrality.”318 As she explains, the myth consists of two underlying premises: first, the government should not appear to take sides, and second, it should not disrupt the status quo, because the normal way of doing things is neutral in some way.319

This is the wrong way to think about the role of an agency like DOES or the DOL, and so long as decisionmakers adopt this mindset, wage theft will continue to be a widespread and deeply harmful social problem. The government bodies responsible for enforcing workplace standards are, fundamentally, on the side of the law.

That means they are on the same side as workers who experience wage theft, and they are also on the side of high-road employers who do not commit wage theft but must suffer the unfair competitive consequences. But these agencies are not, and should not even appear to be, sympathetic to employers who violate the law. Nor should they seem to be neutral regarding those businesses or the topic of wage theft itself.

This does not mean that the government should not be fair and evenhanded in its enforcement of the law. Far from it. Like the police, wage and hour bodies are charged with finding, punishing, and stopping a crime, and they must do so vigorously. In other words, a serious policy solution to this problem does not include administrative enforcement agencies accepting wage claims as gospel; it requires only that the agency treat such claims as legitimate, serious, worthy of robust investigation and, if credible, deserving of all available legal sanctions. Embracing this approach will lead to the kinds of institutional cultural shifts that are necessary for strategic enforcement to work as it should.

CONCLUSION

Wage theft is a pressing problem. It inflames the evils of poverty, violates society’s most basic workplace standards, and creates devastating cascading harms. For working people, every dollar matters, and the loss of even a relatively small amount of money can threaten hunger, homelessness, and the loss of the basic necessities of modern life. Workers frequently report powerful feelings of anger and depression, as they feel frustrated by and helpless to do anything about their workplace rights violations. These are the facts even in the District, which has some of the most robust anti-wage theft laws in the entire country.

Individuals are not the only victims of wage theft, though. Every year, wage theft siphons billions of dollars away from communities, rendering millions more desperate, poor, and vulnerable than they would and should otherwise be. It warps labor markets, denies legitimate employers the right to fair competition, weakens key social safety net programs, and hides billions of dollars from all levels of government. It is so frequent, flagrant, and costly that it can only be understood as a social problem.

But by and large, our response to wage theft has not accounted for its empirical realities. While statutory reforms have been important and inspiring, they largely rely on individual empowerment as the primary means of attacking the problem. Even where

the government has the authority to take significant action, enforcement agencies rarely invoke the power of their mandates.

Wage theft is a complex problem, an act that preys upon vulnerabilities and an ill that plagues society at large. It is old, it is common, and it will never go away—not entirely. But much more can be done. Wage theft can be effectively confronted with thoughtful policy solutions. With the right reforms and an understanding that public problems require public solutions, institutions can build frameworks that much more effectively deter the crime, bring justice to low-wage workers like Cora, Earl, and Olivia, and make real the economic promise that undergirds our system: that an honest day’s work deserves an honest day’s pay.