Skip to main content

Unlocking the Power and Possibility of Local Enforcement of Human and Civil Rights: Lessons Learned from the NYC Commission on Human Rights (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 2020) (Part 1 of 3)

Part 1 of 3

INTRODUCTION

If you ask most people in the United States where to go to file a complaint of discrimination or receive assistance from the government in addressing discrimination, chances are that they will not likely be able to tell you. For those who do have some familiarity, they may point to the United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”), the federal agency that handles workplace discrimination claims under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. A smaller number may be familiar with their state human rights agencies or equivalent. Even fewer will have knowledge about local or city counterparts to the extent that these agencies even exist in their respective jurisdictions. While the federal government has certainly played a powerful and dominant role in furthering civil rights in the United States, the last several years have seen a rolling back of civil rights protections, through federal administrative rulemaking, Supreme Court jurisprudence, and executive orders and other mechanisms. Under the administration of President Donald J. Trump, the federal government has also flagrantly espoused rhetoric and policies that have led to an increase in bias incidents and violence across the country, inspired by a resurgent white supremacist movement.

When human rights and civil rights protections are deprioritized, underenforced, and undermined through federal action, local governments can be powerful incubators of new and innovative ideas for how government can protect its residents and also serve as a bulwark against the actions of the federal government. This article proposes that local and state human rights agencies can and should prominently step forward to push the limits of their mandates, including: adopting a holistic and highly visible approach to combat discrimination in their jurisdictions; building relationships with advocates; steering the national conversation on civil rights; and continuing to create powerful legal precedents to protect society’s most vulnerable.

Municipal and state human rights commissions (or their equivalents) are local agencies that perform a number of functions:

some may be empowered to enforce a state or city anti-discrimination law, some may investigate and resolve discrimination complaints in employment, places of public accommodation, and housing, and some may address institutional and systemic discrimination with a civil rights and human rights lens. These agencies are predominantly funded by state or local governments, and may also be mandated with engaging in community outreach, policy-making, and education efforts to fight discrimination. There are dozens of human rights agencies in the United States that are mandated by state or municipal governments to carry out these functions.

This article will focus on the strategies employed by the New York City Commission on Human Rights (the “Commission”) from 2015 to 2020 under the leadership of Commissioner and Chair Carmelyn P. Malalis, who helped revive a moribund agency and turn it into a national leader. The Commission’s progress during this timeframe has demonstrated that even with limited resources, a local human rights commission can play a prominent role in the civil rights movement. Some of the Commission’s most effective strategies include reviving the Commission’s function to initiate its own investigations and prosecutions to tackle systemic pattern and practice discrimination, bolstering one of the strongest antidiscrimination laws in the country through innovative and bold policy positions, exploring restorative justice remedies and early dispute resolution processes, creating procedural tools to address harm to the public and alleviate uncertainty and fears about interacting with government, developing strong relationships with community partners, timely responding to issues of public concern, and utilizing effective communications and marketing strategies to inform and educate the public on their rights and obligations.

Part I describes the Commission’s background and organizational structure, including the condition of the agency at the

time Commissioner Malalis took over, a brief history of the Commission, the Commissioner’s priorities and how that played a role in re-structuring the different departments of the Commission to increase the agency’s impact, the power of the City’s previously under-enforced anti-discrimination law, and the various ways the different programmatic areas of the Commission work hand-in-hand to improve its policy-making, enforcement, community outreach, and communications work. Part II discusses the Commission’s holistic and value-driven approach in bolstering protections in a number of different thematic areas, including the introduction and implementation of legislation, the publication of legal enforcement guidance and rules, and the use of public hearings and reports. Part III outlines the Commission’s work in specific areas of antidiscrimination protection, including criminal history, gender identity and gender expression, sexual harassment, pregnancy and caregiving, anti-Black racism, national origin, immigration status, religion, and disability.

I. BACKGROUND AND ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE

Commissioner and Chair Carmelyn P. Malalis was appointed by Mayor Bill de Blasio to lead the New York City Commission on Human Rights in November 2014 and took the helm in February 2015. The appointment followed public outcry for more robust enforcement of the New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”) by the Commission 5 and signified a major directional shift for the agency. Commissioner Malalis, a nationally-recognized employment lawyer with over a decade of experience representing workers in

discrimination cases, was explicitly tasked with rebuilding an agency that had been under-resourced and languishing for many years. As one of Mayor de Blasio’s last commissioner-level appointments in his first term, Commissioner Malalis was tasked with rebuilding—or creating—all aspects of the agency, including law enforcement, community outreach and education, communications, and operations on an expedited timeline. Commissioner Malalis was determined to establish the Commission as the national leader in civil rights and human rights enforcement and to build a credible venue of justice for New Yorkers to vindicate their rights under the NYCHRL.

When Commissioner Malalis joined the agency in February 2015, it was severely understaffed and under-resourced, leading to critique that it was a “moribund agency.” The total headcount at the agency was approximately sixty-five people, a far cry from the preGiuliani staff cuts when the Commission had over 240 staff members. Leadership functions had been consolidated such that a single individual was tasked with serving as General Counsel and the deputy commissioner for the Commission’s two bureaus, creating concerns about a lack of independence and possible conflicts of interest. The Law Enforcement Bureau, which is tasked with investigating and prosecuting violations of the NYCHRL, had approximately thirteen attorneys. The Commission had little to no name recognition in New York City, and among attorneys in the civil rights bar, it was a venue to avoid due to lack of capacity, staff, and resources to vigorously prosecute civil rights complaints. The Commission’s other bureau, the Community Relations Bureau, mandated to provide education and outreach, had not had a deputy commissioner for over a year and was similarly suffering from

understaffing. Though that bureau had a dedicated group of human rights specialists, many of whom had several decades of experience, it did not have a coordinated strategy or system in place for effective outreach. The communications team of the agency was limited to one person with no digital media experience. As a result, there was scant media coverage of the Commission’s work, and the agency lacked any presence on social media. Its website had not been updated in months. Though the Commission has a statutory mandate to maintain an Office of Mediation and Conflict Resolution, the office had been effectively shut down. No one on staff had been charged with working on legislative or regulatory proposals, which deprived the agency, as the subject matter experts on the NYCHRL, of the opportunity to offer its valuable input to lawmakers and close loopholes in the law. As a result, the Commission had for the most part simply responded to bills proposed by the City Council without providing significant substantive input, and the agency had not engaged in any rulemaking in decades.

Commissioner Malalis set out to revitalize the Commission by restructuring various areas of the agency, creating new offices within it to focus on key needs, and addressing many of the gaps identified above. She also prioritized hiring staff to ensure that the Commission reached the city’s most vulnerable populations. Commissioner Malalis felt very strongly that communities that had historically been alienated from government due to language barriers, over-policing or surveillance, historic oppression, or other negative interactions were also more vulnerable to experiencing discrimination and harassment and less likely to report it. She felt that these segments of New York needed to know that the Commission understood their challenges and would fight to vindicate their rights. The Administration

empowered her to work with a supportive City Council to effect the agency’s most significant staff increase in decades.

Commissioner Malalis strove to hire staff with experience working in civil rights and human rights, and/or experience with vulnerable communities. She prioritized both linguistic and cultural fluency to reflect New York City’s diverse and underrepresented communities. When Commissioner Malalis began her tenure in February 2015, Commission staff spoke less than ten languages. Two years later, Commission staff spoke over thirty languages. In addition, Commissioner Malalis hired staff who came from diverse backgrounds, expertise, and experience and brought relationships with community-based organizations, neighborhood associations, faith communities, legal services providers, and other stakeholders with them, who could instantly draw from those community connections to build credibility the Commission previously lacked. Commissioner Malalis believed that government should look and sound like the diversity of New York City. For the first time, the Commission created positions to reflect this focus: a Muslim, Arab, South Asian Communities Lead Advisor, an African Communities Lead Advisor, a Jewish Communities Liaison, an LGBTQ Lead Advisor, a Transgender Communities Liaison, a Youth Lead Advisor, and other staff tasked with focusing on racial justice, outreach to Asian communities, Afro-Caribbean communities, Sikh communities, Latinx communities, and more. The religious, ethnic, gender, racial, and other points of diversity represented in these key positions attracted people of a variety of demographics and across lines of difference to staffing positions throughout the agency.

The Commissioner assembled a leadership team of experts in the field of civil rights and human rights enforcement and litigation, community outreach, organizational management, communications,

and policy to implement the agency’s new vision. She provided her leadership team the runway to undertake a complete audit of their areas, build out teams where none existed, create policies and procedures, and raise standards across the board. Specifically, Commissioner Malalis created the Office of the Chairperson, consisting of staff to handle policy and intergovernmental affairs, adjudication, legislation, legal enforcement guidance, interagency initiatives, and to build relationships with elected officials and liaise with City Hall. She created a Communications and Marketing Department to re-brand the agency; build relationships with media, especially ethnic and community media, launch the agency’s digital media presence, create outreach materials in different languages, and develop public awareness campaigns. She also resurrected the Office of Mediation and Conflict Resolution, as well as necessary back-office departments that had atrophied into non-existence.

For the first two years of the Commissioner’s tenure, the Commissioner and her new leadership focused on hiring and developing staff, creating consistent protocols and methods of transparency, elevating standards, working strategically with stakeholders, raising the profile of the agency through public awareness campaigns, events, and strategic outreach, and issuing thorough and clear legal decisions and policy documents. After the presidential election in November 2016 and the subsequent rollback of human rights and civil rights by the federal government, the Commission quickly repositioned itself. It became apparent that local government, including government agencies like the Commission, had to distinguish themselves from the federal government and work aggressively to combat the rising tide of both hate crimes and hateful and divisive rhetoric that the federal administration engaged in and encouraged. It was particularly important for the Commission to situate itself as a counterpoint to the federal government’s constant

undermining of civil rights protections, reminding New Yorkers that despite attempts to curtail civil rights by the federal government, in most instances, New Yorkers’ rights remained robust. For example, the Commission has engaged in countless actions, through community outreach and engagement to policy guidance and strategic law enforcement, in direct response to announcements of policy changes or rhetoric at the federal level. More specifically, the Commission, often in partnership with other city agencies, has submitted amicus briefs or comments to proposed federal rules in order to oppose the rolling back of civil rights protections for, among others, transgender members of the military and LGBTQ people in employment, healthcare, education, and federal contracting, and to address the weakening of anti-discrimination protections.

II. BRIEF HISTORY OF THE COMMISSION

As a result of citywide concerns about race relations following riots in 1943, Mayor Fiorello H. LaGuardia created the Mayor’s Committee on Unity by Executive Order on February 28, 1944. Its purpose was to “make New York City a place where people of all races and religions may work and live side by side in harmony and have

mutual respect for each other, and where democracy is a living reality.”

The Committee had no enforcement powers but was able to effect change through the persuasive powers of its members. By the mid-1950s, however, it was apparent that the Committee could not address the city’s problems of discrimination and bias. In 1955, Mayor Robert F. Wagner and the City Council moved to replace the original Committee with a city agency that had more extensive powers and permanent status: the Commission on Intergroup Relations (“COIR”). COIR was given the power to receive and investigate complaints and to initiate its own investigations into racial, religious, and ethnic group tensions on the basis of race, creed, color, national origin, and ancestry. It was empowered to hold hearings, to report its findings of facts, and to make recommendations to the Mayor. COIR was also charged with studying the problems of prejudice, intolerance, bigotry, discrimination, and disorder caused by intergroup tension, and then developing intergroup dialogue. It coordinated efforts among federal, state, and city agencies to develop courses on techniques for achieving harmonious intergroup relations within New York City.

COIR’s powers were first greatly expanded in 1958 with the passage of the Fair Housing Practices Law (also known as Local Law 80, the Sharkey-Brown-Isaacs Law). This local law gave COIR the power to investigate and hold hearings on allegations of discrimination in private housing, and was the “first in the nation to extend protection against discrimination to private housing.” In 1962, COIR changed its name to the Commission on Human Rights.

In 1965, Local Law 55 and Local Law 80 were amended and combined into Local Law 97, the Human Rights Law of the City of

New York. This amendment “greatly expanded the Commission’s powers of investigation and enforcement, and extended the Commission’s jurisdiction to prosecute discrimination based on race, creed, color and national origin in employment, public accommodations, and housing, as well as commercial space.”

Prominent former leaders of the Commission include Eleanor Holmes Norton, who held the nation’s first hearings on gender discrimination and now serves as a Congresswoman for the District of Columbia, and Dennis deLeon, who was an advocate against HIV/AIDS discrimination and went on to become the president of the Latino Commission on AIDS.

A. The Commission’s Structure and Values

The first step in the revitalization and re-structuring of the Commission under Commissioner Malalis was identifying the core values of the agency to most effectively further its mission of combating discrimination. This was necessary to help guide the agency’s direction and implement goals amidst inevitable resource constraints. The Commission’s structure—as required by statute and further developed under Commissioner Malalis—is thus intended to promote the values that the Commissioner has espoused for the agency. Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission has prioritized the core principles of legitimacy, transparency and education, relationship-building with marginalized communities, responsiveness to contemporaneous events and social issues, and diverse representation among staff. Commissioner Malalis has worked to reinvigorate the agency to transform it into a credible venue for filing, investigating, conciliating, and litigating anti-discrimination complaints, including high impact cases. The Commissioner has also worked to make the agency an accessible space for diverse communities throughout the city to avail of government support. Both of these goals have boosted the agency’s overall legitimacy as a

powerful law enforcement agency that serves to further civil and human rights in the United States.

Commissioner Malalis created the Office of the Chairperson to encourage transparency in how the Commission enforces the NYCHRL. The Office of the Chairperson issues guidance, rules, frequently asked questions, and brochures; is readily accessible to members of the public and the legal community to address any questions about the law; and provides free and frequent trainings to the public to help covered entities better comply with their legal obligations and to educate individuals about their rights. The Office of the Chairperson is also responsible for working with other City agencies to ensure compliance with the law, a practice not commonly engaged in by the prior administration, but critical to helping eradicate discrimination within government and setting a standard for the private sector. As a government agency committed to serving marginalized communities, the Commission purposefully centered programming around relationship-building with groups historically distrustful of government to build connections with and hear from impacted groups directly. This has helped the Commission meet its goal of responding to public needs and contemporary issues. Examples include re-building governmental connections with New York’s different Muslim communities which were historically distrustful of government after experiencing mass surveillance and profiling by law enforcement and responding to civil and human rights issues emerging from the 2016 presidential election, such as the #MeToo movement, the Black Lives Matter movement, and the rise of white nationalism and xenophobia.

By statute, the Commission serves two main functions. The first is as a civil law enforcement agency. The Law Enforcement Bureau (“LEB”), staffed primarily by attorneys, takes in complaints of discrimination from the public, initiates its own investigations on behalf of the Commission, and utilizes its in-house testing program to help identify entities breaking the law. Where LEB’s investigation leads to a finding of probable cause to believe that a person or entity has engaged in an unlawful discriminatory practice, LEB attorneys

prosecute the case at a trial through the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (“OATH”) before an Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”). The ALJs provide reports and recommendations, which may include “findings of fact, decisions of law, and recommendations on damages and civil penalties” to the Office of the Chairperson, who then reviews the recommendations along with the trial transcript and evidentiary record de novo and issues a final decision and order that is reviewable in New York state court under a “substantial evidence” standard.

The second main function of the Commission is to perform community outreach and provide education on the City Human Rights Law and human rights-related issues. This function is primarily the responsibility of the Community Relations Bureau, comprised of Community Service Centers in each of the City’s five boroughs, but staff and leadership across the agency engage in this work regularly. The Commission’s Community Relations Bureau (“CRB”) is also charged with cultivating understanding and respect among the City’s many diverse communities. At a time when the forces of hate and division seem to be disturbingly empowered, CRB works to counter these elements through education, outreach, and relationship-building, and working actively with local community leaders, community-based organizations, houses of worship, elected officials, small businesses, and schools to provide vital know-yourrights and know-your-obligations information.

As the Commission expanded its staff and sought to raise standards and practices across the agency, Commissioner Malalis committed to bringing in external experts and identifying internal experts to train staff on working with the diversity of New Yorkers in a culturally competent manner. For example, in July 2019, the Commission worked with the Perception Institute, a leading industry expert on the issues of racial anxiety and implicit bias in the workplace, to provide mandatory trainings and workshops to all staff 48. In 2018, the Commission also offered anti-oppression training to supervisory staff. In addition, the Commission offers staff training on other issues, including LGBTQ rights, working with people with disabilities, combating sexual harassment, understanding Muslim experiences, Sikh awareness, and discrimination based on race and color. These trainings—some mandatory and some optional—have been crucial both to educating staff and ensuring that the Commission addresses any internal or external problems that may arise in providing services to the public.

As part of its goal of furthering its legitimacy and credibility as a civil rights powerhouse, the Commission also resurrected the agency’s Office of Mediation and Conflict Resolution (“OMCR”) in early 2017. The OMCR continues to develop the Commission’s voluntary mediation program and provides alternative pathways to resolving matters brought before the Commission. The OMCR is staffed by a Director and a Mediation Coordinator. In Fiscal Year 2019, the Mediation Director “successfully mediated 37 cases to resolution—the highest in this category since 2009—representing, in the aggregate, $1,193,500 in damages,” excluding non-economic terms such as “agreements to provide reference letters and conduct trainings.” Through the Commission’s multi-faceted approach to

achieving growth both internally and externally, it has sought maximum enforcement of the City’s anti-discrimination law, the NYCHRL, and its mandate to fight discrimination.

B. The New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”)

The NYCHRL is one of the broadest and most protective antidiscrimination laws in the country. The law includes specific areas of protection that do not exist in many other anti-discrimination statutes, including, for example, bans on inquiring into an prospective employee’s salary history, criminal history, and credit history. Legislative amendments to the NYCHRL have made it explicit that the law must be interpreted broadly to effectuate its remedial purpose—to construe protections broadly and exemptions narrowly—and to consider federal and state analogous statutes as the floor and not the ceiling.

Despite the notable differences between the NYCHRL and its state and federal counterparts, there is, for the most part, a lack of legal analysis of the NYCHRL as a wholly distinct framework, which creates an environment whereby factfinders, including the Office of the Chairperson, have little direction or precedent to draw from and demands that new legal theories and creativity be tested. Because the NYCHRL has not historically been utilized to its fullest extent, neither in state and federal court, nor at the Commission, caselaw applying this more liberal standard or adjudicating some of the newer areas of protection under the NYCHRL is also limited. For instance, since 2009, the NYCHRL has provided greater protections to victims of sexual harassment in the workplace than state or federal law by only requiring employees to prove that they have been treated “less well” than others on the basis of gender, which the courts have indicated may include even a single comment that objectifies a person based on their gender, as opposed to the more stringent requirement of showing “severe or pervasive” treatment to establish a hostile work environment.

In addition, the NYCHRL requires that covered entities provide reasonable accommodations beyond categories required by state and federal law, including for disability, religion, pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions, and for victims of domestic violence, stalking, and sex offenses. Unlike Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, for all categories of reasonable accommodation required by the NYCHRL, the covered entity must demonstrate that it is a significant undue hardship—not just a minimal burden—to deny the accommodation.

In response to federal and state courts’ failure to separately analyze claims under the NYCHRL’s more liberal standard, the New York City Council enacted the 2005 Civil Rights Restoration Act, to specify that the City’s anti-discrimination law must be interpreted “independently from similar or identical provisions of New York state or federal statutes,” such that “similarly worded provisions of federal and state civil rights laws [are] a floor below which the City’s Human Rights law cannot fall, rather than a ceiling above which the local law cannot rise.” The New York City Council passed a second Restoration Act in 2016 incorporating, by reference, three judicial opinions that had applied a more expansive interpretation of NYCHRL protections. While the Restoration Acts have corrected some of the challenges, there remains a lack of case law construing many provisions of the NYCHRL, and the Commission has stepped in to publish legal enforcement guidance documents, promulgate roles, draft model policies, and issue reports to provide transparency to members of the public about how to interpret the NYCHRL’s standards consistent with their intent. In addition, the Commission’s significant enforcement actions under Commissioner Malalis’ tenure,

including its conciliations—detailed summaries of which are available on the agency’s website 60 —Decisions and Orders (“D&Os”), and work with the New York City Law Department to successfully uphold its D&Os on appeal, have helped create powerful legal precedent and further develop the NYCHRL.

C. The Community Relations Bureau

Under the leadership of Commissioner Malalis, the Community Relations Bureau (“CRB”) has reimagined its outreach to include engaging programming, community conversations, responsive outreach, and educational workshops and trainings to meet New Yorkers where they are and promote relationship-building with marginalized communities. This has led to the agency increasing its impact and, on average, reaching 100% more New Yorkers under Commissioner Malalis than under prior administrations. During Commissioner Malalis’s tenure, CRB’s structure was revamped to reflect the agency’s new mission. This revamping included the creation of an Education, Restorative Justice, and Development unit tasked with curating curricula to educate New Yorkers on the various protections under the NYCHRL. CRB also began to incorporate restorative and transformative justice principles in its outreach and engagement with communities who have experienced harm or who are newly acknowledging their role in perpetuating discrimination and bias. Examples of new content, built around developing audiences’ cultural competency in addition to understanding legal rights and obligations, include workshops focusing on Working with Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming Communities, Protections

Against Discrimination Based on Race and Color, and Understanding Muslim Experiences and Combatting Anti-Muslim Racism.

Commissioner Malalis also created Lead Advisor and Community Liaison roles within CRB to elevate the Commission’s expertise in several policy areas and communities. This includes, but is not limited to, Lead Advisor for Youth Initiatives, Lead Advisor for Muslim, Arab, and South Asian Communities, Lead Advisor for Reentry, Jewish Communities Liaison, Liaison for Trans Communities, and Liaison for Fair Housing. These new roles and portfolios have increased the Commission’s focus on community-led programming, where attendees can engage in constructive dialogue on their rights at a community forum or where the agency can foster intergroup relations at a cultural or religious celebration. Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission’s events have attracted anywhere from seventy-five to over 1100 attendees. CRB’s robust efforts and relationships with community partners have allowed the agency to host New York City government’s first-ever Vaisakhi event in 2018 to celebrate Sikh communities, which was continued in 2019, an Iftar in the City for the past four years, an LGBTQ Iftar for the past three years, an Interfaith Justice Seder for the past three years, an African Communities forum for the past three years, and other large-scale programming centering around underrepresented communities.

Due to the steep increase in hateful rhetoric leading up to the 2016 presidential elections and continuing to this day, CRB also relaunched its Bias Response Team. The Bias Response Team addressed and combated bias incidents through the city in the late 1980s and early 1990s, but was dormant for over twenty years. CRB shifted priorities to boost the agency’s responses to bias incidents and to work proactively with vulnerable communities by providing trainings on bystander intervention and addressing ways of being good allies. By coordinating days of visibility, bystander intervention trainings for communities, and other convenings, CRB worked more closely with sister agencies to ensure that these vulnerable

communities were aware of the rights and resources available to them should they be faced with an act of discrimination. Furthermore, in late 2016 and early 2017, anticipating large-scale concerns among the public after the 2016 election, CRB convened a series of roundtable conversations with community leaders and organizations, including immigrants’ rights advocates, workers’ rights groups, LGBTQ advocates, faith leaders, and racial justice advocates, to learn what the agency could do to better serve communities most under attack by the election of President Trump. These roundtables are consistent with the Commission’s practice under Commissioner Malalis to engage with community leaders and stakeholders before diving into any major new initiatives to ensure that the Commission is doing work that is responsive to and informed by community needs. These efforts have increased the reporting of incidents to the Commission, which is a reflection of the good faith communities have in the agency to stand with them when their rights are violated.

D. Law Enforcement Bureau and Adjudications

The Commission enforces the NYCHRL through LEB, comprised of attorneys, human rights specialists, and support staff. The Commission has dramatically improved LEB’s impact by transitioning from a quantitative approach of analyzing success to a more qualitative one. More specifically, LEB made five major changes in its approach: shifting its focus from exclusively investigating individual cases to also identifying pattern-or-practice violations; creating specialized units to address priority or time-sensitive cases; improving its procedural practices and launching Commissioninitiated cases; developing unique and creative affirmative relief including restorative and transformative justice solutions; and ensuring diverse representation among staff.

These changes, in part, helped to ensure that a file-by-right agency like the Commission with an extensive docket could still achieve significant and even nationwide impact instead of merely struggling to stay afloat. Unique among civil rights agencies,

complaints filed with LEB are handled by an attorney from intake to investigation to prosecution. When Commissioner Malalis first arrived at the Commission, the agency was not well known as a reputable source for resolving complaints of discrimination by members of the public and within the legal community. LEB prioritized closing cases and handling issues on a case-by-case basis, rather than considering factors such as the impact that actions had on members of the public, whether they addressed systemic areas of discrimination, expanded interpretation in newer areas of the NYCHRL, or improved settlement outcomes. For several decades prior to Commissioner Malalis’s tenure, LEB was severely understaffed and lacked connections with civil rights groups across New York City’s diverse communities, thereby creating barriers between the government and those most impacted by discrimination. Commissioner Malalis focused her energy on recruiting skilled and passionate civil rights attorneys to staff LEB, with an intentional focus on hiring individuals representing a variety of backgrounds and language skills, including advocates and litigators from the non-profit legal services and private sectors. LEB grew from twenty-five staff positions to eighty-five under Commissioner Malalis’ leadership.

With significant staff growth, LEB was able to focus on its specific needs. For example, LEB built a team of nine multilingual staff to answer the agency’s information line, which is most people’s first contact with the agency. These staff members perform the initial assessments for over 9,000 inquiries a year made by phone, by webform on the agency’s website (another innovation under Commissioner Malalis), and through in-person walk-ins. The team provides a critical triage function by flagging urgent matters in which an immediate intervention may be necessary, or a statute of limitations may be about to run. Frontline staff are trained to identify such urgent matters in specified areas, such as homebound tenants refused disability accommodations, homeless tenants denied a lease

because they present a public assistance voucher, or workers suffering ongoing harassment or retaliation. When these issues arise, staff are trained to address them directly or forward them to appropriate staff for immediate follow-up.

LEB also restructured into teams of attorneys led by supervisors to provide consistent supervision and guidance and increased its administrative staff numbers to provide much needed support to attorneys with respect to case processing and tracking. LEB also created a robust internship program and prioritized professional development opportunities to attract and retain talent.

With dedicated funding for critical enforcement needs, LEB established specialized units including the Source of Income Unit (“SOI Unit”) and the Gender-based Harassment Unit 78 . The Commission designed these units both to bring expanded enforcement power to urgent and intractable situations with high numbers of claims and to focus attorneys’ specialized expertise on these areas of the law.

Since its inception in January 2018, the SOI Unit has achieved hundreds of successful interventions on behalf of tenants denied a lease or threatened with eviction because they presented a public assistance voucher. Because of the nature of the New York rental market, these situations require intervention with the discriminating landlord within hours of the denial to ensure that the unit is not rented to another applicant. The SOI Unit helps address the City’s homelessness crisis by seeking to stem rampant source of income discrimination by obtaining housing for tenants exiting the shelter system and keeping low-income tenants in their apartments. The SOI Unit also brings cases against large housing providers and those that repeatedly violate the law to create systemic change and maximize the impact of the agency’s enforcement power. For example, the Commission ordered a landlord with 15 buildings to pay $20,000 in emotional distress damages and $4,000 in civil penalties for refusing to accept a prospective tenant’s Section 8 voucher. As a

result of discrimination, the tenant had lost their voucher and had to seek alternative housing options. Following an investigation, the Commission was able restore the Complainants voucher, and ultimately, the landlord agreed to train all employees with job duties related to reviewing and accepting prospective tenants, and to post the Commission’s Fair Housing poster in all their buildings located in New York City.

The SOI Unit’s intervention staff have performed several hundred interventions to assist tenants facing eviction, seeking housing with a voucher, facing termination of a housing voucher, and/or attempting to use a voucher in an apartment where they already reside. To educate the community about their rights and obligations, the SOI Unit has also conducted dozens of trainings for grassroots community groups, shelters, legal services providers, brokers, landlords, and even housing court judges. When the SOI Unit receives a complaint, a member of the Intervention Staff performs a holistic intake, evaluating the individual’s current housing and benefits status. If necessary to address an emergency, the SOI Unit makes a direct referral to a legal services provider. In addition, the SOI Unit prioritizes community members who face voucher termination. The Unit works with other governmental agencies to preserve that individual’s housing voucher and helps intervene when community members experience additional housing discrimination.

Under Commissioner Malalis, the agency has also made several changes to reinforce LEB’s authority and transform the agency’s reputation as a venue for “discount justice” to a reputable venue in the civil rights legal landscape. Under its current leadership, damages, awards, and penalties assessed in cases at the Commission are the highest they have ever been in the history of the agency—four times what they were just four years ago. For instance, in Fiscal Year 2019, LEB secured $5,306,052 in damages for complainants of discrimination, and assessed $788,261 in civil

penalties against respondents, a significant jump from prior administrations.

The Commission also began to address challenges that have plagued the agency for decades. Immediate changes included ensuring that LEB staff applied correct legal standards in enforcing the law and properly applied the agency’s administrative rules, improving transparency with members of the public about LEB’s investigatory processes, overhauling and implementing a new case tracking system, instituting regular staff professional development and training, and strengthening investigation and litigation processes. LEB also began to assert jurisdiction in areas the Commission had not previously addressed. This included filing cases of bias-based profiling against the New York City Police Department and reinforcing the agency’s willingness to apply its enforcement authority against large City actors, including the New York City Department of Correction and New York City Department of Social Services as providers of public accommodation.

E. Improving the LEB Investigatory Process: From Intake to Determination

Under Commissioner Malalis, the agency recommitted itself to ensuring that any complainant who stated a claim of discrimination under the NYCHRL would have the right to file their complaint for investigation by the agency as required by statute. In addition, LEB created a process for attorney-filed complaints and permitted complainants, in exceptional circumstances, to file complaints on an anonymous basis.

LEB and the Office of the Chair simultaneously created protocols to implement under-utilized case determination tools, including reviving agency rules which permitted dismissal of cases “not in the public interest” as a form of administrative convenience (the “AC dismissal”) to avoid increased backlogs and case processing delays. The AC dismissal allows LEB to exercise prosecutorial

discretion and avoid using investigation resources on cases unlikely to uncover probable cause while preserving the due process rights of individual complainants. Specifically, an AC dismissal protects the right of complainants to pursue action in state court, akin to a “right to sue” letter in EEOC proceedings.

Most significantly, LEB improved its case investigation and litigation processes and revised its metrics of success. Instead of focusing on closures, the Commission shifted to a substantive concentration on outcomes and increased investigation of pattern or practice violations. This included expanding its Commissioninitiated investigations practice and installing an Assistant Commissioner to oversee its work and testers, focusing particularly in the areas of source of income discrimination and criminal history discrimination to identify and address per se violations and tackle systemic harm.

The Commission’s authority to initiate its own investigations without a named complainant is particularly vital where would-be complainants may be afraid to file complaints and/or are otherwise unable to come forward for a multitude of reasons. Commissioninitiated investigations and cases addressing systemic violations improve LEB’s collaboration with stakeholders and allow the agency to publicly announce its investigations, sending a strong message to potential violators of the law that discrimination will not be tolerated and that there will be consequences. For example, LEB announced enforcement actions against landlords who threatened tenants with immigration enforcement as violations of the NYCHRL’s protections against discrimination on the basis of immigration status and/or national origin. In doing so, LEB brought attention to the mounting problem of landlords and employers exploiting fears fomented by the

91 . See NYC Charges Queens Landlord with Retaliating Against Immigrant Tenants Who Filed Discrimination Complaints , N.Y.C. OFFICE OF THE MAYOR (July 19, 2017), https://www1.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/491-17/nyccharges-queens-landlord-retaliating-against-immigrant-tenants-who-fileddiscrimination [https://perma.cc/GA2N-N4GL ] (describing efforts by NYC Commission of Human Rights to enforce against landlords discriminating against tenants based on immigrant status).

federal government’s anti-immigrant actions. LEB also announced enforcement actions against substance abuse centers that denied access to transgender patients or stated that housing would only be provided based on sex assigned at birth. This issue was brought to the Commission’s attention by transgender rights advocates and confirmed through Commission testing. Finally, LEB publicly announced its settlement against Lenox Hill Radiology for its failure to provide equal access to people with disabilities to obtain mammograms, a complaint that the New York Lawyers for the Public Interest brought to the Commission.

LEB also combined Commission-initiated enforcement actions with individual claims to have the impact of a class action. These actions sought both class-wide relief—damages and remedies for large groups of affected individuals—as well as systemic reform ensuring the elimination of discrimination in the future. This was a particularly useful tool to address housing discrimination. For example, the Commission obtained a significant settlement in a case in which a large housing provider was using criminal history to screen out potential tenants. Under the NYCHRL’s newer provisions on organizational standing, a number of advocacy groups have also filed complaints on behalf of their constituents. For example, in 2018, Make the Road filed an organizational complaint with LEB against the New York Police Department (“NYPD”) for allegedly failing to provide translation services to its clients, and in 2016, Picture the Homeless and the New York Civil Liberties Union filed an organizational complaint with LEB alleging that members of

the NYPD were unlawfully profiling their homeless clients by asking them to “move along” for simply being present on streets or sidewalks.

Other changes included ensuring that LEB attorneys used correct legal determination standards. Under prior Commission leadership, complaint determinations were made by using the preponderance of the evidence standard. The Commission restored the probable cause standard, consistent with agency rules, for determinations. If there was a probable cause of discrimination—i.e. it was more likely than not that the discrimination occurred—LEB investigators were ordered to issue a probable cause determination. Similarly, in another departure from prior Commission practice, LEB now must not issue a no probable cause finding—which extinguishes a complainant’s right to pursue a case in court—without conducting interviews of parties and witnesses, where available.

With respect to investigation standards more generally, LEB developed protocols to train attorneys to engage in more thorough investigations of complaints, including engaging in thorough interviews with respondents and witnesses and engaging in site visits. Pursuant to the Commission’s Rules of Practice, LEB also utilized procedures that allow for motions to compel to be submitted to the Office of the Chairperson to gain stronger compliance from parties with investigatory requests and motions to seek adverse inferences for a failure to cooperate with investigations. Consistent with its efforts to elevate the caliber of litigation, after a finding of probable cause, LEB increased its use of formal discovery, including depositions, and filed more motions for summary judgment prior to trial. LEB also improved the quality of its litigation practice by engaging in moot practice with junior attorneys and offering mentorship and co-counseling opportunities.

LEB started, for the first time, identifying appropriate individual cases that could be used to catalyze systemic change. Where appropriate, investigators demand information about

widespread compliance with the NYCHRL. Where investigations unearth systemic problems, LEB mandates that respondents address such issues through affirmative relief in conciliation agreements, including training, policy changes, monitoring by the Commission, posting, and, where appropriate, restorative and transformative justice solutions. This relief should be consistent with Commissioner Malalis’ vision that all efforts be undertaken to prevent future harm by respondents. In specific areas, LEB has leveraged its enforcement power to obtain statewide or nationwide changes, even where laws outside of the Commission’s jurisdiction do not mandate such reform. In cases involving discrimination based on criminal history, for example, LEB has successfully obtained employers’ agreement to “Ban the Box” nationwide.

LEB also ramped up demanding civil penalties for violations of the NYCHRL in appropriate cases, sending a powerful message to respondents that discrimination in New York City comes at a cost. At the same time, LEB considers respondents’ size and sophistication in assessing penalties so as not to use a cookie-cutter approach. The Commission also offers assistance to smaller businesses, including access to free training on the law.

Additionally, LEB improved its outreach to members of the public by creating informational materials and walking people through its process, in an effort to provide more transparency to the public. LEB translated core documents used throughout the

investigation and determination process into nine languages. It also created a general language insert with a disclaimer in twenty-three languages stating that the enclosed information contains important legal information and providing a direct line to call to receive language translation and interpretation assistance.

F. Adjudications

The Commission’s Office of the Chairperson adjudicates appeals of LEB determinations, including administrative closures and no probable cause findings, and hears discovery-related disputes. The Office of the Chairperson also issues Decisions and Orders in matters litigated at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings before an ALJ, and after the ALJ issues a Report and Recommendation. The Office of the Chairperson has focused on strengthening the Commission’s adjudicatory work under Commissioner Malalis, with the goal of developing the Commission as a leading anti-discrimination forum marked by judicious legal analysis and the availability of meaningful remedies. Since 2015, the Office of the Chairperson has issued over twenty-two Decisions and Orders after trial.

In cases involving sophisticated respondents and willful violations of the law, the Office of the Chairperson has imposed robust civil penalties and awarded compensatory damages on par with those available in state and federal court, moving Commission

cases beyond the level of mere nuisance value for respondents and helping to establish the Commission as a credible venue for combatting discrimination. One of the most noteworthy decisions is Cardenas v. Automatic Reading Corp ., in which a business owner repeatedly engaged, over a three-year period, in unwanted touching of his employee, regularly used lewd and sexually inappropriate language with her, and posted a sexually explicit cartoon of her in the workplace. The Commission ordered the highest civil penalty allowable under the law for the first time in Commission history—$250,000—and awarded $422,000 in damages to the complainant, including $200,000 in emotional distress damages. Respondents appealed the Commission’s decision and it was upheld, in its entirety, by the New York Supreme Court, effectively realigning the range of damages and penalties available under the NYCHRL and setting a new standard for cases prosecuted at the agency.

In cases involving smaller, less sophisticated respondents and less egregious violations, the Office of the Chairperson has generally favored remedial action in place of financial penalties. Similar to LEB’s approach to small businesses that have expressed a willingness to cooperate and that lack resources to pay high civil penalties, the Office of the Chairperson has reversed the former administration’s approach of fining small businesses thousands of dollars for job posting violations, when they agree to stop engaging in the practice. In the cases of In re Comm’n on Human Rights v. A Nanny on the Net LLC and Comm’n on Human Rights v. CU29 Copper Rest. & Bar , the Office of the Chairperson required small or financially-struggling respondents to undergo training rather than pay financial penalties, rejecting ALJs’ recommendations to impose civil penalties. Civil penalties had been the practice under the previous administration even where respondents had no resources, had cooperated in the

litigation process, and had recognized their wrongdoing. In several other cases, the Office of the Chairperson offered a restorative justice option to the parties in lieu of requiring the respondent to pay damages or a fine. In Spitzer v. Dahbi , the parties agreed that the respondent taxi driver, who discriminated against two riders based on their sexual orientation, would perform community service with an LGBT rights organization and provide written updates to the complainants about what he extracted from the experience.

G. Restorative Justice Solutions

Under Commissioner Malalis’ leadership, all conciliation agreements have included non-monetary, affirmative relief designed to address harm to both the complainant and their community. This can include community service, educational programming, and tailored trainings as alternatives to relying exclusively on punitive fines to address complaints filed with LEB. For example, in a landmark settlement involving the Commission’s first resolution of a race discrimination case on the basis of hair, the Commission negotiated a conciliation agreement that required the Respondents. Sally Hershberger Salon and Sharon Dorram Color to partner with a NYC-based styling school that specializes in the care and styling of natural hair and hairstyles closely associated with Black people in order to train current salon employees to cut and style natural hair; and create a multicultural internship program which will provide professional opportunities to hair stylists from underrepresented groups. In addition, business owner Sharon Dorram and senior stylist Tim Lehman (Hershberger Salons), are required to complete 35 hours of community service with a racial justice organization—to be

approved by the Commission—that works to combat hair discrimination and promote Black beauty.

Restorative principles are instrumental in connecting respondents to communities that experience discrimination and seeking innovative ways to remedy harm to impacted people. The goal is not punishment, but rather to foster learning and the development of a deeper understanding of the communities that are facing discrimination. Staff work to educate respondents to help them deconstruct biases and prejudices and “open their minds and hearts,” work with respondents so that they understand the hurtful impact of discriminatory acts upon individuals and communities, and create meaningful opportunities for respondents to serve communities that were discriminated against under the law.

Community service is a frequent restorative approach to discrimination. While it is mandated through conciliation agreements, CRB staff work to tailor community service assignments to both the harm caused by the discrimination and the respondents’ needs. For example, in Spitzer v. Dahbi , the community service experience involved a respondent taxi driver that discriminated against passengers based on sexual orientation. Respondent, with the input and consent of complainants, was ordered to perform community service in lieu of a fine. CRB staff met with the respondent regularly and, with his participation, developed an education and training plan and assessed placement at an LGBTQ community organization. During the months that the Commission worked with the respondent, he participated in core trainings, such as Overview of the Human Rights Law and Working with Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming Communities , and he submitted written assignments demonstrating what he had learned. He also completed other reading and written assignments centered on discrimination and protections for the LGBTQ community, which were topics of discussion during meetings with Commission staff that supervised him.

Respondent reported to the LGBTQ community-based organization and complied with all meetings and community service

hours assigned. During meetings with the respondent, CRB staff observed a positive transformation. Respondent expressed that learning about the LGBTQ community gave him a new understanding of discrimination and how bad it made him feel. He told CRB that during his community service placement, he made new acquaintances and intended to continue volunteering on his own. He also connected discrimination against the LGTBQI community to how, as a Muslim, he has faced discrimination based on his religion. In the exit interview with the Commission, respondent thanked CRB staff and stated how the culmination of this process allowed him to continue with his religious practice with a clean heart.

The Commission firmly believes that restorative alternatives to punitive fines and penalties provide a framework to engage respondents in a process that benefits them through education and service and benefits individuals and communities that have faced discrimination. However, restorative justice is resource-intensive work. The Commission is dedicated to optimizing its current resources to engage in as many restorative practices as possible, and is dedicated to growing its ability to do so. Restorative justice work, particularly community service that is meaningfully tailored, requires an individualized and unique approach for each case, which can be time-consuming and require significant oversight. But the Commission believes restorative efforts—which are almost always transformative for participants—are among the most effective means to change hearts and minds in our divisive society.

H. Communications and Marketing

In many ways, the strength of the Commission’s work is the power of its Communications and Marketing team, which did not exist prior to Commissioner Malalis’s tenure. This programmatic area is one of the most effective tools at the agency’s disposal. If no one knows about the work or knows about the agency, then it is difficult for it to achieve its mandate. The Communications and Marketing team consists of five people who build on the Commission’s relationships with communities vulnerable to discrimination and all New Yorkers by raising public awareness about the Commission’s

work and the NYCHRL in earned, digital, and paid media. The Commission’s Communications and Marketing Office has led some of its most effective public campaigns including the #IamMuslimNYC 111 and #WhileBlackNYC 112 , and other campaigns visible across New York City public transportation and social media. The Communications and Marketing Office also completely revamped the Commission’s website, which is updated weekly and houses the Commission’s extensive collection of multi-lingual fact sheets, brochures, and one-pagers; short videos to educate the public on different areas of protection under the NYCHRL; legal enforcement guidance, rules, and the NYCHRL itself; campaigns; and settlement summaries and Decisions and Orders. Using a combination of organic and paid media, the team revived the agency’s essentially nonexistent social media presence, garnering over 12,000 followers on Twitter and 26,000 followers on Facebook as of January 2020, up from approximately a few hundred on each platform respectively, during Commissioner Malalis’ tenure. The Commission’s improved social media presence allowed the agency to engage in real-time reporting of initiatives and events. The Commission also created accounts and content on different platforms, including Instagram, Medium, and LinkedIn.

The focus on communications has increased the Commission’s visibility in mainstream and national news outlets, including the New York Times , Washington Post , CNN, AP; local New York City-based outlets such as the New York Daily News , WNYC , and Gothamist ; online outlets like Buzzfeed , Huffington Post , and The City ; and community and ethnic media in multiple languages, in print, on the radio, and on television. Commissioner Malalis has frequently written op-eds and letters to the editor that have been placed in such varied outlets as New Amsterdam News 113 , Ozy.com 114 , and the New York

Times 115 . This media outreach has been monumental in maximizing the reach of the Commission’s work. For instance, the Communications team connected with the New York Times to announce its historic hair discrimination guidance, released in February 2019, which helped to elevate the work globally, build momentum for legislative change in multiple jurisdictions, and produce over 750 major media stories on the initiative, in dozens of languages and across the world.

The Communications team regularly engages with the media in this fashion to ensure public understanding of complex changes to the NYCHRL and other policies affecting marginalized communities. The Communications team has prioritized building relationships with ethnic media, which is often its first source of outreach in much of its work to offer the Commission’s public education to key communities. For several years, 100% of the Commission’s media ad buys have been in community and ethnic media. Through all of these efforts, the agency has enjoyed increased visibility and created and contributed to national dialogue around furthering civil rights law at the local level.

III. COMBATING DISCRIMINATION THROUGH LEGISLATIVE CHANGES, POLICY-MAKING, ENFORCEMENT, AND EDUCATION

The Commission combats discrimination by utilizing a systemic and holistic approach, achieved through legislative changes, policy-making, enforcement, and education. The latter two—enforcement and education—have been described in great detail in Section I. The Commission’s role in legislative changes and policymaking originates in several areas: proposing amendments to the

NYCHRL, providing expert analysis and input on legislation introduced by the City Council, implementing and interpreting new laws, enacting official rules, and issuing legal enforcement guidance interpreting the City’s anti-discrimination law. In addition, the Commission has the authority to convene public hearings and publish reports or surveys to further its policy work. This section will center on how and why the Commission holistically combats discrimination and promulgates its work in the areas of criminal conviction history, gender identity and gender expression, sexual harassment, pregnancy and caregiving rights, anti-Black racism, national origin, immigration status, religion, and disability.

A. Amendments

While the City Council is the entity that introduces legislation, the Commission has identified gaps in the law or where case law has narrowly or wrongly interpreted the law, and has drafted legislation reviewed and approved by City Hall. The proposed legislation is subsequently transmitted to City Council for introduction to address those gaps or correct wrongly-decided case law. Over Commissioner Malalis’ tenure, approximately five bills have been introduced by City Council using that mechanism. Overall, since 2015, City Council has passed, and the Commission has implemented, approximately twenty-eight changes to the NYCHRL, all of which required significant input, negotiation, and editing by the Commission, other City agencies, the City’s Law Department, and City Hall before a final vote at the City Council.

Amendments are critical to ensuring that the NYCHRL is evolving with the needs of New Yorkers and that it continues to remain one of the most protective anti-discrimination laws in the country. Often, the specific language and stipulations of an amendment proposed in City Council are the result of countless meetings and conversations between the Commission and relevant stakeholders—community-based organizations, non-profits, community members, legislators, and activist groups, among others. While the process necessarily varies from amendment to amendment, the Commission’s own principles are that amendments to the NYCHRL should both reflect the needs of the City and should be drafted with expert input from litigators, advocates, and attorneys who regularly interact with and use the NYCHRL to advocate for their clients. As such, consultation with those affected by discrimination and inequality of all kinds is a priority in the process of drafting and obtaining amendments. Sometimes, this consultation takes the form of a public hearing. This was the case with the series of amendments passed in May 2018 pertaining to sexual harassment in the workplace. Other times, this consultation takes the form of meetings and conversations between the Commission, community members and community-based organizations, legislators, and other interested parties. In this regard, the policy-facing work of the Commission is inseparable from the work of CRB, which not only informs the public of their rights and responsibilities under the law but ensures that the Commission’s policy agenda is informed by the city’s constituents and the struggles facing its most vulnerable populations.

When major new protected categories are added to the NYCHRL, the Commission commits resources to creating transparent and comprehensive information in the public domain, to providing covered entities with information they need to understand how to comply with the law based on how the Commission is interpreting the law. When the Commission implemented the nation’s first ban on salary history inquiries in October 2017, it published extensive frequently asked questions on its website in direct response to questions and concerns raised through stakeholder conversations and roundtable discussions. Similarly, the Commission published frequently asked questions, three model policies, and additional materials in March 2019, beyond what was statutorily mandated under the law, regarding new lactation room accommodation requirements for employers, to ensure that the agency was providing useful information and tools to employers of varied means and resources.

Other notable additions to the NYCHRL include broadened definitions of sexual orientation and gender to encompass asexuality, pansexuality, and gender non-conformity; a requirement for employers to provide a lactation room for employees who need to pump or express breastmilk; and the requirement that covered entities engage in a cooperative dialogue with individuals entitled to reasonable accommodations in housing, employment, and public accommodations. All of these amendments have benefited from the input of Commission staff, given their subject matter expertise in these areas.