Skip to main content

Unlocking the Power and Possibility of Local Enforcement of Human and Civil Rights: Lessons Learned from the NYC Commission on Human Rights (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 2020) (Part 2 of 3)

Part 2 of 3

B. Guidance

Under Commissioner Malalis, the agency began issuing legal enforcement guidance documents for the first time in order to provide transparency and clarity regarding the Commission’s own interpretation of the NYCHRL. The guidance documents, which have long been used by federal agencies including the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, had never been used by the Commission in its history. Under Commissioner Malalis, they have become one of the most critical advocacy tools used by the agency to help further its work and to distinguish the NYCHRL from less protective state and federal anti-discrimination law, which is why the agency generates them so frequently. To develop them, the Commission identified areas of the law that it believed would benefit from further explanation and clarification. These included older provisions of the law such as protections for gender identity and gender expression; new protections that have been added to the law, such as the Fair Chance Act; and clarification about the applicability of older provisions of the law in specific areas of modern life, such as the guidance on anti-Black racism based on hair, particularly where analogous anti-discrimination provisions have not been interpreted in the same way. Unlike rules, guidance documents are longer, and allow for more analysis and examples of discrimination to assist members of the public with understanding their rights and obligations.

C. Rules

The Commission has the authority to promulgate rules to codify its interpretation of the NYCHRL. The Commission’s rules,

codified as Title 47 of the Rules of the City of New York, govern its interpretation and application of the NYCHRL. Prior to Commissioner Malalis’s tenure, the agency had rarely undertaken rulemaking in a substantive area of the law, issuing only a handful of rules regarding gender and general rules of practice. Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission reinvigorated its rulemaking function to preserve and codify its interpretation of key provisions of NYCHRL, typically where the protections are new or where there is a real need for clarity regarding application and impact. Over the past four years, the Commission has issued rules to clarify enforcement of new or expanded protections against discrimination on the grounds of gender; discrimination on the basis of criminal history and conviction or arrest record in employment; and credit discrimination in employment. In September 2019, the Commission concluded a complete overhaul of its rules of practice, which govern the investigation and litigation of cases filed with the agency. This constituted the first update to the Commission’s rules of practice since they were originally introduced in 1998. The overhaul was intended to provide greater transparency and clarity about how cases are handled and to promote principles of fairness and due process. The Commission also plans to issue proposed rules in the areas of pregnancy discrimination and accommodations, lactation accommodations, discrimination on the basis of reproductive and sexual health decisions, and hair discrimination based on race and religion.

D. Hearings and Reports

Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission revived its City Charter mandate of holding public hearings and issuing reports to address critical issues in New York City. Such practices go back as far as the 1970s and 1980s. The Commission convened hearings and published comprehensive reports in the areas of Sexual Harassment in the Workplace and Pregnancy and Caregiver Discrimination, and also released a report following a major survey on the experiences of Muslim, Arab, South Asian, Jewish, and Sikh New Yorkers following the 2016 presidential election. The agency holds hearings and issues reports in order to gather community input, shed light on specific topics of concern, and tailor its responses based on the feedback and information collected.

E. The Fair Chance Act

The Commission’s work implementing the 2015 Fair Chance Act is instructive of the Commission’s holistic approach, highlighting the agency’s principles of legitimacy, transparency and education, relationship-building, and inclusive and diverse representation. Shortly after the start of Commissioner Malalis’ tenure, the Fair Chance Act (“FCA”) was signed into law on June 29, 2015. 137 It amended the NYCHRL to prohibit a variety of adverse actions taken by employers against prospective applicants based on their criminal

conviction histories. 138 Effective July 11, 2019, the NYCHRL was amended again, through a state law change, to prohibit employers from inquiring about or considering a disposition of an adjournment in contemplation of dismissal, even if the criminal case was still pending. 139 The FCA represents a monumental shift in protecting the employment rights of individuals with criminal histories.

The Commission, in response to this major legal change, utilized a comprehensive approach to transform itself into a legitimate venue for FCA enforcement, and took steps to ensure transparency and to educate members of the public on their new obligations and rights. The Commission created an FCA supervisory role and hired one of the leading advocates who helped to draft and lobby for the FCA to lead the unit; issued legal enforcement guidance and undertook rulemaking; created trainings for both people working with individuals with criminal histories and employers; launched a public awareness campaign; and engaged in substantial legal enforcement to fully realize the powers of the new law. 140

The FCA represents one of the strongest Ban-the-Box 141 protections in the nation. It created comprehensive procedural protections for individuals with criminal histories and prohibited

most employers from inquiring about an individual’s criminal conviction history before making them a conditional offer of employment. In addition, if an employer determines, after reviewing an applicant’s criminal history, that it wishes to withdraw the conditional offer, the FCA requires that employers provide applicants with notice and a form demonstrating it followed a particular analysis and a copy of the criminal background information on which it relied.

The FCA is intended to level the playing field for the approximately seventy million adults who have been arrested or convicted of a crime in the United States. It gives them the opportunity to be considered for positions alongside other equally qualified candidates, and prevents them from being barred from employment simply because they have to check a box. Even though Article 23-A pre-dates the FCA and has protected people with criminal records from employment discrimination in New York State since 1976, the FCA and its procedural protections were introduced because the City determined discrimination based on criminal history was still common. Many employers explicitly continued to inquire about applicants’ criminal records during the hiring process, which was then permitted. However, these employers made their employment decisions without weighing the factors provided in Article 23-A, including evidence of rehabilitation; the age of the individual when committing the offense; whether there was a direct relationship between the conviction and the desired position; and whether the individual posed an unreasonable risk to the safety of persons or property, in violation of state and city law.

The FCA outlines the proper process for employers to follow when fielding employment applications and delineates when it is permissible to inquire about an applicant’s criminal history. During the application process, employers are prohibited from declaring any limitation or specification in employment based on a person’s arrest or criminal conviction, and from inquiring about arrest or criminal conviction records. Employers may only inquire about an applicant’s arrest or conviction record after a conditional offer of

employment is extended, and if they do so, they must (i) provide a written copy of the inquiry to the applicant; (ii) perform an analysis of the applicant under Article 23-A and provide the applicant with a written copy of said analysis; and (iii) allow the applicant a reasonable time to respond while holding the position open for the applicant. If, after the Article 23-A analysis, an employer wishes to decline an individual employment, they must follow the Fair Chance Process: disclosing to the applicant a written copy of any inquiry conducted into their criminal history; sharing a written copy of the Article 23-A analysis with the applicant; and giving the applicant at least three business days from receipt of the inquiry and analysis to respond. The FCA also provides numerous other protections.

In sum, the FCA moved the inquiry into criminal history to the end of the employment process, meaning it could only be initiated after the employer determined that the individual was the best person for the job. The FCA process ensured that employers could not rescind an employment offer until after an individualized analysis had been completed and communicated to the applicant.

To further its legitimacy and expertise in this area, the Commission hired an advocate who had helped draft the FCA to lead the unit, investigate and litigate FCA cases, oversee testing and Commission-initiated investigations, and train Commission staff and external stakeholders, including employers. By ensuring that the unit charged with enforcing this new area of law was staffed with a knowledgeable expert recognized and respected by the greater legal community, the Commission was able to demonstrate that its enforcement and policy-making in this area would be thoughtful, credible, and impactful.

After the FCA’s enactment, the Commission launched a public awareness campaign to educate employers and members of the public alike. The Commission’s campaign included subway ads in

English and Spanish that read “Criminal record? You can work with that.” The Commission published an easy-to-digest brochure explaining the FCA in English, Spanish, French, Russian, Haitian Creole, Urdu, Chinese, Korean, and Arabic. 153 The Commission engaged in relationship-building with organizations that assist individuals with criminal conviction histories and made regular visits to correctional facilities, probation sites, parole orientations, and organizations that work with incarcerated or formerly incarcerated clients to educate impacted individuals. In 2018, the Commission offered nearly 250 workshops on FCA protections to almost ten thousand people. 154

In 2015, shortly after the FCA’s effective date, the Commission issued legal enforcement guidance on the Act, including a sample FCA notice that employers could use to undertake the Article 23-A analysis and provide to employees if they planned to revoke a conditional offer of employment based on the applicant’s criminal conviction history. The Commission continues to periodically update its FCA legal enforcement guidance with new changes to inform and educate employers and members of the public.

On June 28, 2017, the Commission adopted FCA rules to further clarify protections available under the NYCHRL for people with criminal histories. The FCA rules codify much of the original legal enforcement guidance. They also codify, for the first time, conduct that constitutes a per se violation of the FCA, including:

declaring, printing, or circulating advertisements and job applications that express limitations or specifications in employment regarding criminal history; inquiring about applicants’ criminal histories before extending a conditional offer of employment; and failing to provide the applicant a written copy of the background check that the employer intends to rely on, or a written copy of the employer’s analysis of the employee’s criminal history, as required under the law.

Finally, in an effort to promote transparency and efficiency, the Commission’s FCA rules include a discretionary early resolution mechanism—the first of its kind at the agency—to allow LEB to respond to per se FCA violations. If LEB, through a Commissioninitiated investigation or a report from a member of the public, discovers a per se violation of the FCA (for example, a job application that still seeks criminal history information), then LEB can send the employer an Early Resolution Notice offering the employer the option to immediately admit liability and pay a fine in lieu of litigation. As established in the FCA rules, Early Resolution is available when: respondents have committed per se violations as defined in Section 2-04(a); there is no other pending or current allegations concerning violations of the NYCHRL; they have fifty or fewer employees at the

time of the alleged violation; and they have had no more than one NYCHRL violation in the past three years. The Commission retains the option of proceeding with a full investigation if it is determined that Early Resolution is not in the public interest, for reasons that may include rampant discrimination in the respondent’s industry or inferences of willfulness regarding the respondent’s violation.

In addition to policy development and outreach to impacted communities, the Commission has undertaken significant enforcement efforts both to create FCA precedent and to convey to employers and employees alike that FCA enforcement is a priority for the agency. FCA cases represent a significant part of the Commission’s employment docket. 158 The Commission’s LEB has vigorously pursued enforcement against major employers and has sought full damages under the law. 159 Since the law went into effect, LEB has conducted nearly 300 tests to determine whether employers were unlawfully asking job applicants about their criminal histories, and in 2017, LEB announced that it had launched major investigations into twelve national and local employers that collectively employ more than 140,000 people for discriminating against job applicants with criminal histories. 160 Since October 2015, the Commission has secured $487,110 in damages for complainants (including attorneys’ fees) and $219,000 in civil penalties in FCA cases. 161

The case of _ Tomas Ramos v. Yelp, Inc. _ is demonstrative of the Commission’s focus on using enforcement as a mechanism to create systemic change by targeting widespread practices against larger employers with a large imprint in New York City. 162 LEB found that Yelp, Inc. had unlawfully run a background check on the complainant prior to making him a conditional offer of employment, and had

unlawfully denied him employment because of a two-year-old misdemeanor conviction. 163 Yelp, Inc., the complainant, and the Commission entered into a conciliation agreement requiring the company to pay $20,000 in emotional distress damages to the complainant, to pay a $10,000 civil penalty to the City of New York, and to engage in extensive affirmative relief. Yelp agreed to train more than 800 New York City-based employees on the New York City Human Rights Law, including the Fair Chance Act; formally commit to ban-the-box at all of its offices nationwide; display the Commission’s Notice of Rights and Fair Chance Act posters at conspicuous locations accessible to all New York City-based employees; and revise and update its internal policies regarding applicants with criminal conviction records. 164 Similarly, the Commission’s vigorous enforcement led to it pursuing a major resolution against a giant in the healthcare industry, Montefiore Medical Center, a large employer which had failed to consider evidence of rehabilitation of a long-time employee before refusing to re-hire him for a twenty-year-old felony conviction. The case settled for $196,674 in compensatory damages and civil penalties—the highest damages collected, and penalty administered in an FCA settlement to date—comprehensive policy changes, and training to relevant staff on the FCA and how to assess candidates with criminal conviction histories. 165

F. Gender Identity and Gender Expression

In 2002, the New York City Council passed the Transgender Rights Bill to define gender-based discrimination to include discrimination based on an individual’s “actual or perceived sex, and discrimination based on an individual’s gender identity, self-image, appearance, behavior, or expression with the recognition that gender identity does not necessarily conform with one’s sex assigned at birth.” The City’s intent in amending the law was to make explicit that the law prohibits discrimination against people based on gender identity and gender expression. The amendment was made in recognition of the profoundly negative impact of gender-based discrimination on transgender, non-binary, and other gender non-

confirming people, for whom gender-based discrimination can have life-threatening consequences. In 2016, the Commission led the effort that resulted in New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio issuing Executive Order 16, which ordered City agencies to provide employees and members of the public access to City single-sex facilities consistent with their gender identity, mandated that all City agencies post signage ensuring people were made aware of their right to use the single-sex facility consistent with their gender identity, and required that all City agency employees who interact with the public are trained. In addition, in 2018, City Council amended the definition of “gender” in the NYCHRL to reflect a broader and more inclusive understanding of gender.

From the very beginning of her tenure, Commissioner Malalis was committed to creating real and lasting impact for transgender and gender non-conforming, and non-binary (“TGNCNB”) New Yorkers. While legal protections existed since 2002, they had been underutilized, and the TGNCNB community either had no relationship to the Commission or had a negative relationship to the Commission. The agency had a reputation for being inhospitable to TGNCNB people seeking to file complaints. To engage in necessary relationship-building with transgender communities, Commissioner Malalis hired a Transgender Communities Liaison and instructed Office of the Chair staff to ensure maximum public awareness of the protections available under the NYCHRL.

Despite having codified protections in the NYCHRL for over a decade, Commissioner Malalis felt it necessary, during a moment in time where transphobic “bathroom bills” were being debated across the country, to clearly and transparently explain the real-world application of gender identity and expression protections. In 2015, the Commission released legal enforcement guidance on discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression, highlighting the ways in which this form of discrimination manifests, and

articulating specific violations of the law. These violations included failing to use the name or pronouns with which a person selfidentifies; refusing to allow people to use single-gender facilities and programs most closely aligned with their gender; gender stereotyping by, for example, requiring people to conform to stereotypical norms of masculinity or femininity; imposing different uniforms or grooming standards based on gender; providing employee benefits that discriminate based on gender (in particular, health benefit plans must cover gender-affirming care); and considering gender when evaluating requests for accommodations (for example, employers cannot deny leave requests to employees undergoing gender transition treatment if they accommodate the leave requests of other employees for different medical conditions). Additionally, the Commission updated its legal enforcement guidance in 2019, including new definitions for “cisgender,” “gender identity,” “gender expression,” “gender,” “gender non-conforming,” “intersex,” “sex,” and “transgender.”

In 2016, the Commission launched a citywide public awareness campaign affirming the right of transgender individuals to use the bathroom consistent with their gender identity or expression, making New York the first municipality in the nation to do so. The “Look Past Pink and Blue” campaign, developed through feedback from focus groups that included both TGNCNB New Yorkers and cisgender New Yorkers, sought to make it explicitly clear that, in New York City, it is your right to use the “restroom consistent with who you are . . . no questions asked.” In 2016, the Commission’s

campaign won the first annual Shorty Social Good Awards for Best in Government and Politics.

Through LEB, the Commission has investigated and conciliated significant cases on behalf of individuals facing discrimination on the basis of gender identity. In 2019, the Commission settled a case against the New York City Department of Homeless Services (“DHS”) and a contractor shelter provider, Acacia Group, for discriminating against a transgender man, Stevin Bonaficio, and kicking him out of his housing because of his gender identity. The complainant was also outed, deadnamed, and misgendered by DHS peace officers at other city shelters. The case settled for $55,000 in compensatory damages to the complainant, a $10,000 civil penalty paid by Acacia Group, and comprehensive affirmative relief, including the development and implementation of a new transgender, gender nonconforming, and intersex (“TGNCI”) policy by DHS, although some of the revisions were already independently underway. The settlement also included training of all staff on the new policy, designating a staff LGBTQ Housing Specialist at the shelter for a minimum of three years, updating DHS’ peace officer policy to require officers to use gender pronouns consistent with an individual’s gender identity, and mandating that Acacia Group establish record-keeping protocols on all gender-based discrimination and harassment complaints, and report violations to the Commission twice a year, for a period of two years.

The Commission has also successfully used its testing program to root out gender identity discrimination in healthcare settings. In 2018, the Commission settled a case against a substance

abuse treatment shelter, Promesa Residential Health Care Facility, that discriminated against transgender patients. The Commission sent testers to the facility, who were told by respondent’s staff that transgender women would be housed with men, and in another test, told that transgender women would be turned away completely unless there was an available private room (the facility only had one private room). Following the Commission’s complaint and investigation, Promesa settled the case for $10,000 in civil penalties, and agreed to implement policies prohibiting discrimination against transgender people including in room assignments, notify organizations that assist LGBTQ people facing substance abuse issues of their updated policies, conduct anti-discrimination training, and be monitored by the Commission. The same year, in response to a public-initiated complaint, the Commission also settled a case against Mount Sinai Beth Israel Medical Center for asking invasive questions to a transgender woman, including asking her “what she had down there,” and insisting that she not room with other women. Following the Commission’s investigation, the Medical Center paid $25,000 in compensatory damages to the complainant, made significant policy changes, and agreed to trainings in an effort to prevent future incidents of discrimination based on gender identity.

G. Combating Sexual Harassment

While combating sexual harassment has always been a core mission of the Commission throughout its history, the agency ramped up its efforts in response to the resurgence of Tarana Burke’s #MeToo movement and public demands for more meaningful and substantive enforcement in this area, building on the legacy of former Commissioner and now Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton. While at the Commission in 1975, Congresswoman Norton held the first ever public hearing on gender discrimination, where the term “sexual harassment” was used publicly for the first time. The

Commission’s ongoing and intensive work to combat sexual harassment is consistent with Commissioner Malalis’ belief in having the agency respond to contemporary issues of injustice that matter to the public. Immediately after high-profile stories began to hit the media, the Commission formulated a response consisting of outreach and education, stakeholder engagement, a public hearing, implementation of new legislation, and a dedicated enforcement unit.

The Commission’s response was fortified by courts’ recognition that sexual harassment claims under the NYCHRL must be assessed more liberally. In its 2009 decision in Williams v. New York City Housing Authority , the New York State Appellate Division, for the first time, interpreted the NYCHRL to reject the “severe or pervasive” standard in assessing sexual harassment claims, and instead applied the “less well than” standard. In other words, under the NYCHRL, an employer that treats an employee “less well” than others on the basis of gender may be engaging in unlawful sexual harassment, a standard much more protective of employees than its federal counterpart. Violations of the “less well than” standard can include even “a single comment that objectifies women . . . made in circumstances where that comment would, for example, signal views about the role of women in the workplace.” The Williams decision was codified into the NYCHRL through the 2016 Restoration Act. In 2013, the Second Circuit followed suit and overturned a lower court’s application of the federal “severe or pervasive” standard 188 to the NYCHRL in the case of a bank employee who had been subjected to sexual harassment by her supervisor, and

instead applied the Williams “less well” standard. In addition, pursuant to the NYCHRL and unlike under federal law, managers and supervisors are liable for sexual harassment where they are the harassers themselves; or where they knew or should have known of the harassment and did not act to stop it, regardless of whether the employer took reasonable corrective action in response to the harassment.

Throughout Commissioner Malalis’ term, the Commission has made combatting sexual and gender-based harassment 191 a priority. As noted above, the first Decision and Order issued during her tenure, in October 2015, was Cardenas v. Automatic Meter Reading Co. , in which an owner of a company harassed an employee for over three years until the employee was constructively discharged, and in which the Commission ordered $250,000 in civil penalties—the maximum allowable under the NYCHRL—along with $422,670 to the complainant in front and back pay and emotional distress damages. In March 2019, the Cardenas decision was upheld in New York State Supreme Court in its entirety. The NYCHRL continues to be a powerful tool to combat sexual harassment, yet many members of the public remain unaware of how robust the law is, further reinforcing the Commission’s desire to increase its education and awareness efforts.

On December 6, 2017, the Commission convened a citywide public hearing on sexual harassment in the workplace, the first public hearing on sexual harassment since 1975. The hearing was one of the first government-sponsored hearings in the country soliciting testimony from workers and advocates on sexual harassment in the wake of #MeToo. Those who testified included advocates, activists, workers, and elected officials representing a broad range of industries, including construction, fashion, media, domestic work, tech, finance, hospitality, and others. All shared their varied experiences with sexual harassment and the challenges they faced in reporting it and obtaining justice. Over twenty-five people provided oral testimony, and the Commission received twenty-one written submissions.

The testimony of advocates and workers highlighted the particular vulnerabilities of workers with intersecting identities, such as low-wage and immigrant workers, workers of color, and LGBTQ workers. Opening remarks were given by former Chair and Commissioner, Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton, and the hearing was moderated by a panel of people serving as commissioners in different City agencies or bodies, including Chair and Commissioner Malalis, Department of Consumer and Worker Protection Commissioner Lorelei Salas, Catherine Albisa, Carrie Davis, and Beverly Tillery.

The public hearing provided an essential opportunity for local government leaders to hear directly from impacted communities and revealed several ways in which the NYCHRL and the Commission

itself could improve by opening up more pathways to justice for individuals who have experienced sexual harassment. The public hearing also became a model for soliciting input from the people most impacted in order to drive policy and legislative change. For instance, the State of New Jersey convened a series of public hearings in Fall 2019, explicitly following the Commission’s model. In addition, the recommendations from the public hearing were useful in assisting the Commission in directing its work, as explained in greater detail below.

1. Recommendations Raised in Hearing Testimony and Takeaways

Hearing testimony identified a host of changes to the NYCHRL that would better position workers to bring claims to the Commission and in state court. These recommendations included extending the statute of limitations to bring a claim of sexual harassment to the Commission from one year to three years; extending protection to all workers regardless of employer size, particularly considering the vulnerability of workers in small or isolated workplaces—such as domestic workers—to sexual harassment; banning non-disclosure agreements around sexual harassment allegations; and reducing dependence on tips by eliminating the tipped minimum wage.

The hearing emphasized for the Commission that employers should: provide multiple avenues for reporting sexual harassment so that employees can choose the manner of reporting with which they are most comfortable; be required to train their employees on sexual harassment in the workplace; and institute clear policies regarding sexual harassment that outline effective mechanisms for reporting, investigating, and resolving complaints. The Commission also received critical feedback on how it could better address sexual harassment in the workplace and took steps to improve its enforcement work after the hearing.

2. The Commission’s Hearing Report

In April 2018, the Commission issued a report summarizing the hearing testimony, including recommended policy and legislative changes as well as best practices for employers to combat sexual harassment in the workplace. The report represented an effort to memorialize the themes and recommendations to further policy developments and to maintain transparency and accountability to the public. The report counseled employers to provide multiple avenues for reporting sexual harassment, so that employees can choose the manner of reporting with which they are most comfortable. The report also noted that employers should be required to train their employees on sexual harassment in the workplace and institute clear policies regarding sexual harassment that outline effective mechanisms for reporting, investigating, and resolving complaints.

The report further outlined recommended initiatives to combat workplace harassment for the Commission. For instance, one recommendation was that the Commission expand its resources for Commission-initiated investigations into workplace harassment and retaliation. Commission-initiated cases can lead to more comprehensive relief, deeper remedies, and policy changes for offending entities; they can also be helpful when individuals are afraid to come forward for fear of retaliation. The Commission also determined that it should develop sexual harassment training tailored to the needs and challenges of workers in various industries, especially considering that vulnerabilities are different depending on employment context. In addition, the report recommended that the Commission increase outreach efforts to educate employers and workers on their legal rights and responsibilities with respect to sexual harassment in the workplace.

In May 2018, the New York City Council passed the Stop Sexual Harassment in NYC Act, codifying several of the recommendations from the hearing and report. The statute of limitations for gender-based harassment claims was increased from one year to three years, giving the Commission extended jurisdiction over such complaints and reflecting testimony describing barriers to reporting to a government agency, including structural inequality and fear of retaliation. Another amendment codified the recommendation to expand sexual harassment protections to all employees, including those who work for employers with fewer than four persons in their employ.

Another amendment requires that all employers in New York City “conspicuously display an anti-sexual harassment rights and responsibilities poster designed by the commission, in employee breakrooms or other common areas employees gather,” with posters displayed at minimum in English and in Spanish. The Commission developed these materials and has published them in English, Spanish, and eight additional languages.

Another amendment requires that employers with fifteen or more employees annually conduct an interactive sexual harassment prevention training for all employees employed within the city of New York and mandates that the Commission create a free online interactive training that all employers may use. Accordingly, the Commission has launched an interactive sexual harassment prevention training for employees, available in English, Spanish, and nine other languages. The training, created by staff within the Commission’s Office of the Chairperson, incorporates feedback from advocates representing workers and employers across communities and industries. The training is robust, intersectional, and

comprehensive. It uses a story-based learning model, and the stories to highlight the ways in which sexual harassment impacts women of color, immigrant workers, pregnant and breastfeeding workers, and transgender, gender non-conforming, and non-binary workers. It also frames sexual harassment broadly to include harassment based on gender stereotypes and sexual orientation. The training is available in ten languages; has alt-text for images, in addition to captions and audio descriptions for videos, in order to make it more accessible to people with disabilities; and it meets State and City sexual harassment prevention training requirements. As part of its outreach efforts, the Commission sent mailers in English and Spanish to over 275,000 small businesses across the City with information on how to access the training. In addition, a multimedia and multiplatform campaign ran citywide in 2018 to increase public awareness of the Commission as a “venue for justice” for sexual harassment claims. These efforts resulted in an almost doubling of sexual harassment complaints brought to the Commission in a single year: in 2017, fifty-six sexual harassment in the workplace claims were filed, compared to 104 in 2018.

The Commission’s expertise in this area has been recognized in other jurisdictions, and its work has helped usher in legislative change. Commissioner Malalis testified before the California State Senate Judiciary Committee on a hearing on sexual harassment, highlighting the NYCHRL’s more generous standard and the

Commission’s work. Deputy Commissioner Dana Sussman testified twice before the joint sessions of the New York State Senate and Assembly, recommending that New York State make four key changes to the New York State Human Rights Law to mirror the NYCHRL to ensure that victims of sexual harassment can seek justice across New York State. Months later, the New York State legislature passed most of these reforms.

The Commission also established the Gender-Based Harassment Unit within LEB to add increased attention to the growing numbers of claims of sexual harassment in the workplace and, in particular, to allow the agency the capacity to intervene in ongoing, active harassment cases with a particular focus on low-wage and other vulnerable workers. This unit prioritizes gathering initial reports from survivors as promptly as possible, taking steps to preserve evidence, and securing relief that, in addition to vindicating the survivor, minimizes the likelihood that harassment will recur. Where possible, the unit intervenes to stop or mitigate the consequences of ongoing harassment. For example, the unit secured a swift transfer for a young worker who wanted to change worksites after being groped by a customer.

H. Pregnancy and Caregiving Discrimination

The NYC Pregnant Workers Fairness Act went into effect in 2014 and requires that employers provide reasonable accommodations to employees on the basis of pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions. Under the NYCHRL, pregnancy

discrimination is discrimination based on sex. However, prior to 2014, claims for accommodations in the workplace relating to pregnancy or for medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth had to be filed as disability claims, meaning that the claimant was required to show their conditions amounted to a temporary disability. Because of this requirement, people with routine pregnancies were regularly denied even minor accommodations. Noting this shortcoming, on October 2, 2013, the City enacted Local Law 78, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which affirmatively requires employers to reasonably accommodate “the needs of an employee for her pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical condition,” without necessitating that the employee’s limitation qualifies as a disability to be protected.

The NYCHRL was further amended on January 15, 2016 to add protections based on actual or perceived caregiver status in employment. The addition of caregiver protections into the NYCHRL makes it easier for New York City residents caring for the 1.8 million children under the age of eighteen, one million people aged sixty-five and older, and roughly 900,000 individuals with disabilities to file workplace discrimination claims under the NYCHRL. The change supports the Commission’s position that

caregivers, being the people who keep families and communities together, should not be treated differently or denied opportunities in the workplace because of the essential care that they provide.

The NYCHRL was further amended on November 17, 2018 to require explicitly that employers provide workers with a lactation room and reasonable time to pump. The first amendment requires certain employers to provide lactation rooms to their employees as well as refrigerators suitable for storing breast milk. The second amendment requires employers to implement a lactation room accommodation policy, “a written policy regarding the provision of a lactation room which shall be distributed to all employees upon hiring.” Following the passage of the amendments, the Commission has engaged in extensive efforts to change work culture surrounding lactation accommodations to reduce stigma, educate employers, support employees, and normalize pumping through its publication of materials on lactation. These have included model policies, FAQs, and a guidance document for employers. These changes reflect the rights of employees to make personal health choices such as deciding to breastfeed a baby or to pump or express breast milk after returning to work from parental leave. Failing to accommodate an

employee who pumps after they return to work can have a significant negative physical and/or emotional impact.

Prior to these legislative amendments, in 2015, the Commission published a notice of rights, required under the NYC Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which clarified that the Commission interprets pregnancy accommodations to include time off to recover from childbirth and to pump in the workplace. This notice of rights was one of the first documents the agency updated under Commissioner Malalis. In May 2016, the Commission issued legal enforcement guidance on pregnancy accommodations and discrimination explaining how the Commission interprets the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, and set the stage for the codification of the lactation room requirements. This practice of drafting legal interpretive guidance or issuing rules on an area of antidiscrimination law has been successful in helping to push for legislative changes both in New York City and in other jurisdictions.

The Pregnancy Guidance was innovative in that it outlined for the first time that employers must engage in a cooperative dialogue—or an open problem-solving conversation—with pregnant employees in addressing accommodations. The cooperative dialogue requirement was later codified into law in 2018, to apply to all reasonable accommodation requests under the NYCHRL. The

guidance also defined “related medical conditions” broadly to include abortion, miscarriage, and fertility treatments. Another major area of distinction for pregnancy accommodations was the Commission’s interpretation that employers may not request medical notes for routine pregnancy accommodation requests such as requesting more bathroom breaks throughout the work day. Employers may only request medical notes for leave not related to the six-to eight-week period after childbirth or for requests to work remotely. The Commission opted to make this change to decrease the burden on pregnant workers, to diminish the impact of any paternalistic responses from medical providers, and to remedy the fact that medical note requirements disadvantage people who do not have regular or easy access to a healthcare provider. The guidance also outlined that it was presumed to be a reasonable accommodation for an employee to receive six to eight weeks of unpaid leave after childbirth absent undue hardship. It also described other accommodations that were also presumed to be reasonable, including allowing a pregnant worker to sit on a stool or chair instead of stand, to carry a water bottle while working, and to adjust uniform requirements.

On January 30, 2019, exactly five years after the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act went into effect, the Commission held a public hearing to address pregnancy and caregiver discrimination in the workplace to learn more about the experiences of people who have faced pregnancy or caregiver discrimination, the impact of the legal enforcement guidance, what more the Commission could do to combat

this persistent and insidious form of discrimination, and what policy, regulatory, or legislative changes could strengthen protections. Those who testified included members of reproductive advocacy groups, the government, representatives from the medical field—including doulas and doctors in private practice, parents, and caregivers. Speakers shared their clients’ stories, their personal stories, and their ideas as to how to best combat discrimination based on pregnancy and caregiver status. Over the course of the hearing—similar to the hearing on sexual harassment in the workplace—it became clear that certain populations were especially vulnerable to discrimination based on pregnancy and caregiver status: low-wage workers, immigrants, and people of color, and populations that were predominantly overlapping in all three of these categories. In addition, it became evident that discrimination existed not just in employment but in places of public accommodation, including in healthcare settings.

In July 2019, the Commission published a report based on the testimony and recommendations from the hearing. The report lays out the legal landscape of the protections from pregnancy and caregiver discrimination under the NYCHRL and state and federal law; examines the common themes that emerged from the oral and written testimony; and highlights recommendations to combat pregnancy and caregiver discrimination.

1. Recommendations Raised in Hearing Testimony and Takeaways

The testimony included recommendations relating to proposed legislation, policy changes, and other initiatives. Legislative recommendations included: amending the NYCHRL to improve protections for pregnancy and caregiver discrimination; amending the NYCHRL to require workplace accommodations for caregiving responsibilities; extending protections under the NYCHRL to all workers regardless of employer size; adding state tax credit for family caregivers; improving state protections for domestic workers; and modifying Child Safety Alert 14, a policy that advocates say “operates often to unnecessarily separate newborns from their mothers,” to

ensure families can stay together when there is no evidence of an identifiable imminent safety concern. Recommendations for employers included requiring employers to provide current and former employees access to their personnel files; requiring employers to have training and policies focused on pregnancy discrimination; and prohibiting employers from adopting non-disclosure policies. Testifiers urged the Commission to take particular action as well, including: formalizing and improving legal enforcement guidance on pregnancy discrimination; improving case processing and how structurally to proceed with cases in LEB; pursuing targeted investigations; promoting greater public education and outreach; and deepening inter-agency engagement with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene and hospitals.

The Commission is in the process of incorporating several recommendations into its updated legal enforcement guidance on the basis of pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions. As with other Commission public hearings, this hearing was a particularly useful tool to help the agency more meaningfully protect the rights of individuals based on pregnancy and caregiver status by having an avenue to receive recommendations from those directly impacted.

I. Anti-Black Racism

The Commission has taken on a number of projects to tackle anti-Black racism, including a seminal legal enforcement guidance prohibiting hair discrimination based on race, public campaigns recognizing the harm of profiling on Black communities, raising awareness through art, and holding community forums and convenings following public incidents of racial profiling, and partnering with community-based organizations to document Black narratives and histories in parts of New York City.

After several high-profile stories reverberated across the country involving Black children being turned away from school because of their locs or braids or being forced to cut off their locs to participate in a high school athletic event, the Commission turned its focus to whether there was any reason why the Commission could not interpret the NYCHRL’s prohibition on race discrimination to include

hair-based discrimination. Federal courts interpreting Title VII have universally held that, because hair is “mutable,” to ban a certain kind of hairstyle, even if it is closely associated with a particular race, is not discriminatory. Commission staff determined that no court had held similarly under the NYCHRL and concluded that the Title VII case law was simply wrong because it ignored the underlying Eurocentric and racist assumptions about what is “professional” and “work-appropriate” by allowing employers and school administrators to deem certain hairstyles associated with Black people as unprofessional and necessitating alteration.

Commissioner Malalis determined that it was important for the agency to speak clearly and unequivocally on this topic, in the hopes that it would serve as a warning to employers and other covered entities, and also serve as a model to other jurisdictions to adopt. In February 2019, the Commission released legal enforcement guidance—the first of its kind in the country—establishing unequivocally that policies or practices that ban or prohibit natural hair or hairstyles most commonly associated with Black people amounts to discrimination on the basis of race.

The Commission’s legal enforcement guidance on hair discrimination outlines its position that race discrimination, specifically anti-Black bias, is regularly expressed through biases based on characteristics or cultural practices associated with being Black. These biases include prohibitions on natural hair or hairstyles most closely associated with Black people. Bans or restrictions on natural hair or hairstyles associated with Black people are often rooted in white standards of appearance. These restrictions can perpetuate racist stereotypes that Black hairstyles are unprofessional, and are prone to exacerbating anti-Black bias in employment, at school, in sports, and in other areas of daily living. The Commission’s guidance is intended to cover federal loopholes and

haphazard interpretations of this area of law by federal courts under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Specifically, federal courts have failed to provide race-based protections for hair because they often deem it to be a “mutable characteristic” and have not recognized the vast physical, psychological, and financial harm of grooming policies on impacted communities who are forced to cut, straighten, or relax their hair using harmful chemicals or heat to maintain employment. The Commission’s legal enforcement guidance emphasizes that the NYCHRL protects the rights of New Yorkers to maintain natural hair or hairstyles that are closely associated with their racial, ethnic, or cultural identities, and that employers that enact policies prohibiting such styles are engaging in racial stereotyping and disparate treatment based on race.

For Black people, the guidance thus permits the right to maintain natural hair; to maintain treated or untreated hairstyles such as locs, cornrows, twists, braids, Bantu knots, fades, Afros; and even to keep hair in an uncut or untrimmed state. The enforcement guidance focuses on policies addressing natural hair or hairstyles most commonly associated with Black people, who are frequent targets of race discrimination based on how they maintain their hair.

The Commission’s hair guidance received international acclaim from sources ranging from the fashion industry to legal experts to racial justice advocates and was covered by media outlets from the New York Times 260 to Teen Vogue 261 to Essence 262 , across the United States, and around the world. Following the Commission’s release of its guidance, California became the first state in the nation

to pass a state-wide bill—called the CROWN Act—banning hair discrimination based on race. On July 12, 2019, New York State, citing the Commission’s legal enforcement guidance on hair, became the second state in the country to ban race-based hair discrimination by amending the New York State Human Rights Law to define race to include characteristics historically associated with race, including hairstyles.

The Commission felt it important to focus the guidance on hair discrimination experienced by Black people, but it also reinforces NYCHRL protections against grooming or appearance policies that generally target communities of color, religious minorities, or other historically marginalized groups. Examples include: “a Sikh applicant being denied employment because of his religiouslymaintained uncut hair and turban,” and “a male server ordered to cut his ponytail while similar grooming policies are not imposed on female servers.” The Commission will codify much of the legal enforcement guidance on hair discrimination into formal rules in 2020.

As with other programmatic areas, beyond issuing this historic guidance, the Commission has sought to combat anti-Black racism and honor and celebrate Blackness using a diverse array of innovative tools, including embracing the power of art to challenge assumptions and create dialogue. To that end, in January 2018, the Commission, through its Office of the Chairperson, welcomed Tatyana Fazlalizadeh, who joined as the agency’s first-ever Public Artist in Residence (“PAIR”). PAIR, administered through the Department of Cultural Affairs, embeds artists within City agencies to address pressing civic issues through creative practice.

Fazlalizadeh’s formal partnership with the Commission grew out of mutual admiration and shared values. Upon completing the

research phase of her residency, in which she embedded herself at the agency to learn about the Commission’s work and get to know the staff, Fazlalizadeh proposed an interactive public mural project focusing on anti-Blackness and gender-based street harassment, two themes that were also central to the Commission’s work. To execute the project, the Commission drew upon its extensive relationships with community-based organizations as well as its in-house outreach and communications expertise and its relationships with other City agencies. Because it was critically important to the Commission and to Fazlalizadeh that the project engage and reflect the thoughts and concerns of New Yorkers, Fazlalizadeh designed and the Commission distributed hundreds of postcards asking people to share their experiences with anti-Black racism and gender-based street harassment anonymously. The artist drew upon the responses she received to conceptualize the murals. The Commission partnered with organizations like Weeksville Heritage Center, Girls for Gender Equity, GRIOT Circle, YWCA Brooklyn, New Settlement Apartments, local NAACP chapters, and others to host community conversations on the central topics which also informed the art. The partnership resulted in six large-scale installations across four boroughs, centering the faces and words of girls and women of color who have confronted misogyny and racism.

In March 2019, the Commission launched a public awareness campaign seeking to address the everyday indignities that Black people face while going about their lives, and to affirm Black people’s rights to work, rent, shop, drive, and engage in other acts of living without being subject to discrimination, including profiling by others and harassing calls to law enforcement. Advertisements were placed in New York City bus shelters and on subways, and on social media, with the goal of educating covered entities—including housing providers, employers, employment agencies, and business owners—of their responsibilities under the NYCHRL, as well as to encourage more New Yorkers to report anti-Black discrimination.

Demonstrative of its efforts to use community-building to address human rights abuses, the Commission, in November 2018, held a community truth and reconciliation event following the #CornerstoreCaroline incident, in which a white woman in Brooklyn falsely accused a young Black boy of touching her in a grocery store and called the police on him. The incident outraged the local community and inspired—yet another—discussion nationwide on the high rates of racial profiling faced by members of the Black community, especially the use of law enforcement for benign activities. The Commission held the event in Flatbush, Brooklyn (in the area of the incident) to provide space for community members to discuss challenges the community is facing in the midst of gentrification and changing neighborhood dynamics.

The Commission also, through the receipt of a Mayor’s Grant for Cultural Impact, completed a six-month long partnership with the Weeksville Heritage Center that focused on collecting stories of Black community spaces and Black-owned businesses in the face of gentrification and neighborhood change. The effort, “Meals as Collective Memory,” documented the social and culinary history behind Black-owned restaurants in central Brooklyn. Through this project, the agency celebrated Brooklyn’s food culture from across the African diaspora (and shared delicious food), promoted discussions about entrepreneurship, and helped connect the city’s resources, including NYC Small Business Services, to Black-owned restaurants and entrepreneurs in Brooklyn. This initiative culminated in the Commission’s first-ever Juneteenth Community Festival, attended by over 100 people honoring the rich history of Black activism in Brooklyn and beyond.

Finally, the Commission’s LEB has launched vigorous investigations into major offenders, and addressed intersectional challenges in creative ways. For instance, while it is not currently illegal to discriminate against tenants based on criminal conviction history, these policies often have a disparate impact based on race or national origin, and therefore may still violate anti-discrimination laws. In 2018, in the first case of its kind in the Commission’s history, the agency entered into a settlement with PRC Management, LLC, a housing management company that controls 100 buildings comprising 5,000 units citywide, after charging it with discriminating against prospective tenants based on their race, color, and national

origin by denying housing to applicants with criminal histories without performing individualized analysis of those records. The Commission filed charges after the 2016 release of U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) enforcement guidelines that addressed the discriminatory effects of criminal history checks on Black and Latinx prospective tenants; these individuals are disproportionately impacted by arrest, conviction, and incarceration rates in New York City and around the United States. As part of the settlement, respondents were required to “pay $55,000 in emotional distress damages to a victim impacted in the case, $25,000 in civil penalties, change and distribute new screening and application policies, train staff on new policy and law, and invite applicants with criminal histories who were previously denied housing to reapply.”

Another part of LEB’s strategy has been identifying and initiating agency action against publicly reported cases of race discrimination by major companies and developing innovative solutions to remedy harm in its conciliations. For instance, in December 2018, the Commission was alerted to the fact that fashion house Prada was selling merchandise using blackface imagery at its stores, causing a massive outcry. In response, the Commission immediately sent a cease and desist letter and initiated an investigation. A civil rights lawyer, Chinyere Ezie, discovered the window display and posted on social media about its disturbing similarity to Sambo-type imagery. Shortly thereafter, she filed a complaint at the Commission. As part of the settlement, announced in February 2020, Prada agreed to hire a Diversity and Inclusion Officer, reporting directly to the top executives at the company, to

review Prada’s advertising and products sold in the United States, as well as review and monitor Prada’s internal anti-discrimination policies; ensure that NYC employees and Milan-based executives receive racial equity training; develop a scholarship program for people historically underrepresented in fashion; maintain Prada’s Diversity and Inclusion Council, launched by Prada in February of 2019, with a minimum of 3-5 members for a period of at least 6 years, with regular reporting by Prada on the council’s progress to the Commission; and consult with Dr. Joyce Brown, president of the Fashion Institute of Technology, who sits on the council. The agreement requires that Prada report back to the Commission on their progress on all aspects of the agreement.

In 2019, Sally Bershberger Salon and Sharon Dorram Color—an employer who was allegedly discriminating against Black employees who wore their hair in natural hairstyles—agreed, as part of the settlement, to partner with a New York City-based hairstyling school to launch the “Working with Natural Hair Program,” through which the employer will offer training opportunities for hairstylists at their New York City-based salons and teach these employees how to cut and style natural hair. The employer also agreed to create internships and increase opportunities for employment within their New York City-based salons for stylists from underrepresented groups, including stylists of color.

J. National Origin, Immigration Status, and Religion

The Commission has engaged in extensive relationship building with communities targeted by the Trump administration, particularly with respect to national origin, immigration status, and religious identity, and has prioritized timely responding to issues as they arise, whether in news reports or in response to complaints raised by members of the public. This has included drafting legal enforcement guidance on discrimination based on immigration status, investigating housing providers who retaliate against tenants’

complaints of discrimination by threatening to call U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”), issuing a report on the experiences of Muslim, Arab, South Asian, Jewish, and Sikh New Yorkers following the 2016 election, holding focus group sessions with advocacy groups during Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month, responding to bias-based incidents through its Bias Response Team, and celebrating religious minorities by hosting interfaith events, often with community-gathering, food, speeches, and performances.

During this period of increased immigration enforcement, coinciding with more and more Islamophobic, xenophobic, and antiSemitic propaganda, the Commission has sought to position itself as a government space that protects, respects, and supports impacted communities. In the fall of 2019, the Commission released legal enforcement guidance on the NYCHRL’s protections against discrimination based on actual or perceived immigration status and national origin. The guidance sets forth that the terms “alien” and “illegal” as applied to immigrants are dehumanizing and potentially harassing, and the use of such terms, where not otherwise required by statute, may be a violation of the NYCHRL. In addition, the guidance makes clear that threats by respondents to call ICE, or to harass or intimidate tenants, employees, or people seeking to access public accommodations, or threats in response to a complaint of discrimination filed with the Commission, constitute prohibited retaliation under the NYCHRL. In 2017, the Commission’s LEB had already set a precedent by filing retaliation charges against a Queens landlord for sharing personal information about his tenants with ICE in response to a complaint of discrimination they filed with the Commission. Furthermore, in September 2019, in a first-of-its-kind

278 . As a result of these efforts, the Commission has received honors. For instance, in 2016, the Commission was honored by Immigration Equality with the Leading Light Award for leadership advancing the civil and human rights of LGBTQ and HIV-positive immigrants. See Immigration Equality to Honor Congresswoman Barbara Lee, NYC Commission on Human Rights Chair and Commissioner Carmelyn Malalis, and Immigration Equality Co-Founder Noemi Masliah at Women’s Leadership Event , IMMIGRATION EQUALITY (Oct. 26, 2016), https://www.immigrationequality.org/immigration-equality-honorcongresswoman-barbara-lee-nyc-commission-human-rights-chair-commissionercarmelyn-malalis-immigration-equality-co-founder-noemi-masliah-womens-le/ [https://perma.cc/6KLH-CBXQ].

case in the country, an ALJ upheld LEB’s finding of liability against a landlord who threatened to call ICE on a tenant, charging her $17,000 in damages and fines for violating the NYCHRL and ordering her to complete fifty hours of community service.

The Commission has also initiated investigations into discrimination based on religion, national origin, and other protected classes. For instance, in 2017, the Commission initiated a major investigation into a condominium board following reports of tenant harassment and discrimination, including displays of Nazi and Confederate imagery, swastikas, and hate symbols in the building lobby. In 2018, as part of the settlement, the board removed all offensive posters, symbols, and materials from the lobby and made changes to the Condominium’s “House Rules” to comply with the NYCHRL, and offending board members resigned.

The Commission has also publicly spoken out against incidents of xenophobia and human rights violations against immigrants. In 2019, the Commission worked with the International Association of Official Human Rights Agencies (“IAOHRA”), a membership organization of human rights agencies, to release a statement and create a video condemning detention conditions at immigration facilities at the border. The Commission also proposed a resolution condemning these conditions, which was adopted by

IAOHRA members in 2019 and published on the IAOHRA website. Finally, to alleviate incidents of discrimination based on immigration status, the Commission worked with the New York City Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs to release a fact sheet on the Trump Administration’s re-issuance of Social Security No-Match Letters, explaining that these letters do not constitute evidence that an employee is undocumented and that adverse action taken in response to these notices may violate the NYCHRL.

In the fall of 2017, the Commission surveyed over 3,100 Muslim, Arab, South Asian, Jewish, and Sikh (“MASAJS”) New Yorkers about their experiences with discrimination and harassment following the 2016 presidential election. This survey project was inspired by a similar report published by the Commission immediately after 9/11 documenting the experiences of Muslim and South Asian communities. To garner responses from as large of a cross-section as possible, including youth and adults, English speakers and non-English speakers, the Commission created survey questions in Arabic, Bengali, English, French, Hindi, Punjabi, Russian, Urdu, and Yiddish, and distributed them widely in partnership with over 150 community leaders, faith-based organizations, and advocacy organizations. The survey reflected an extensive input process. For instance, the survey development and collection process included critical consultations with Commission staff who liaise with these communities and with a wide variety of community stakeholders, including direct service providers, faithbased organizations, and advocacy groups, and those who identify as members of MASAJS communities. For example, during the

process, the Commission developed relationships with New York City’s Sikh communities through its Sikh staff and through its Lead Advisor for Muslim, Arab, and South Asian Communities, whose primary responsibility is to foster these connections. Sikhs have faced significant discrimination and violence particularly after 9/11 because of their religious appearance—wearing turbans and maintaining unshorn hair—and have not previously had strong connections with or access to local government in New York City. The Commission’s relationship with the community helped to improve survey participation rates of Sikhs and provided an opportunity for the Commission to hear directly about the challenges Sikhs face in New York City.

In 2018, the Commission released a comprehensive report assessing the survey results, entitled “Xenophobia, Islamophobia, and Anti-Semitism in NYC Leading Up to and Following the 2016 Presidential Election: A Report on Discrimination, Bias, and Acts of Hate Experienced by Muslim, Arab, South Asian, Jewish, and Sikh New Yorkers” (the “MASAJS Report”). The MASAJS Report is the first of its kind in New York City to rigorously document the experiences of the named communities across a wide variety of topics, including experiences of bias, harassment, discrimination, and acts of hate as well as whether and how these groups report such experiences and outcomes. The MASAJS report confirmed that the incidence of bias and acts of hate against these groups is disturbingly high. For example, “nearly two in five (38.7%) survey respondents had experienced ‘verbal harassment, threats or taunting referring to race, ethnicity or religion,’” and one in four (26.6%) reported they had experienced such harassment more than once. However, rates of reporting bias harassment, discrimination, and acts of hate to community-based organizations, faith-based organizations, the Commission, the NYPD, or elsewhere remain low. Overall, fewer

than one in three (29.2%) survey respondents who experienced discrimination or harassment reported at least one bias incident to a community-based organization, a faith-based organization, the Commission, NYPD, or somewhere else. Other notable findings included the high relative rates of discrimination against the Sikh community: for instance, the report concluded that a Sikh person under thirty-five is nearly twice as likely to experience verbal harassment as a non-Sikh.

The MASAJS report sought to address the experiences of individuals and their obstacles in reporting bias incidents as well as lay out action steps to address bias and harassment, including recommendations on how to encourage victims to report incidents to the Commission. Recommendations for policymakers and advocates to address discrimination and violence against MASAJS communities included: creating a network of community-and faith-based organizations for those who experience bias-related harassment, discrimination, and acts of hate; “partnering with fundraising organizations to encourage increased philanthropic support for community-based and faith-based organizations that service and support local communities of [MASAJS] New Yorkers”; connecting clients to the Commission, other City agencies, and other organizations that can provide legal, mental health, and other forms of support; planning and developing a bystander-intervention training for delivery to City employees who work directly with the public on how to deescalate bias incidents and what resources to offer those who have been involved in such incidents; addressing the mental health needs of [MASAJS] New Yorkers; and focusing outreach and legal resources on impacted communities in order to educate New Yorkers about their rights, and encourage vulnerable communities to report incidents to the Commission.

The MASAJS Report’s release was announced in a media event at the Arab-American Family Support Center in Brooklyn which was attended by the Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs and Community Affairs Unit, dozens of community-based organizations, and community and ethnic media. The findings were intended for use by the Commission and other City agencies, community-based organizations, faith-based organizations, policy makers, elected

officials, and City residents. The Report highlights ways for community members to seek and get help to ensure their rights are protected. The MASAJS report continues to inform the Commission’s work. For example, the Commission formalized a referral network of seven organizations—partners that were instrumental in outreach and data collection during the survey period—to identify potential cases of discrimination and harassment and connect petitioners directly with an identified staff member at the agency to discuss the case and determine next steps. It is an effort to foster and build direct and long-standing relationships with key organizations that are on the ground every day hearing of incidents of harassment and discrimination, and to position the Commission in a way that will allow the agency to respond quickly.

The Commission has also prioritized programming that lifts up and celebrates New York City’s religious diversity. For instance, in 2018 the Commission organized a New York City-wide event to celebrate an important Sikh observance—Vaisakhi 298 —and raise awareness about New York’s Sikh communities, which as mentioned above disproportionately experience hate and discrimination but remain largely unknown to the majority of Americans. The Commission continues to hold the Vaisakhi event every year as part of its efforts to combat discrimination using a variety of holistic solutions and methods. The Commission also hosts an annual Interfaith Justice Seder to celebrate Jewish communities and link the Passover narrative to other people’s struggles for liberation and justice; an annual Iftar in the City, which in 2019 had over 1,000 attendees to come together and celebrate Muslim communities; and annual Diwali events to celebrate Hindu and Jain communities. The Commission’s events are highly successful and widely attended; this is largely because they are heavily community-centered, designed in close collaboration with the respective faith or heritage groups, and include an education component in advance of the event with all Commission participants to ensure that staff messaging and pronunciation are culturally competent and respectful.

The Commission has also engaged in enforcement work in response to incidents of discrimination against members of MASAJS communities. For example, in 2017, the Commission’s LEB launched Commission-initiated investigations into large employers, including on behalf of airport workers at John F. Kennedy International Airport who were denied religious accommodations to pray during Ramadan.

In 2016, after several violent attacks against Muslim leaders in New York City, the Commission launched a public awareness campaign entitled “I am Muslim NYC,” to show support for Muslim New Yorkers and embrace religious diversity in New York City. In 2017, the Commission also launched a broader campaign entitled “You Have Rights NYC,” which affirmed the right of New Yorkers to live free of discrimination and harassment and included video testimonials from members of the public on successful law enforcement actions taken by the agency. The campaign was accompanied by a series of community events to discuss race, faith, culture, and human rights in a variety of neighborhoods throughout New York City. Furthermore, the Commission has built relationships with African Muslim leaders, and in collaboration with other agencies also launched a toolkit for government agencies and non-profits to improve cultural competency with faith-based communities.

As a result of these efforts to build relationships and lift up and support communities under attack, numerous organizations have recognized the agency’s work through various honors. Between 2017

and 2018, the agency received the Arab-American Association of New York’s Community Defender Award, the Commitment to Equal Justice Award from CAIR-NY, and the Muslim Bar Association of NY’s Advocate of the Year award 305 , which recognizes recipients who have made strides advocating on behalf of Muslims in America.