Skip to main content

Unlocking the Power and Possibility of Local Enforcement of Human and Civil Rights: Lessons Learned from the NYC Commission on Human Rights (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 2020) (Part 3 of 3)

Part 3 of 3

K. Disability

In New York City, approximately one million residents, or 11.2 percent of the City’s population, live with a disability. Addressing disability discrimination has been a priority area for the Commission.

The NYCHRL is one of the strongest and most effective disability discrimination laws in the country. It protects individuals from discrimination in employment, housing, and places of public accommodation. The NYCHRL defines disability as any physical, medical, mental, or psychological impairment, or a history or record of such impairment, and includes a full range of sensory, mental, physical, mobility, developmental, learning, and psychological disabilities—whether they are visible and apparent or not. It prohibits disability discrimination in housing, employment, and public accommodations 309 as well as discriminatory harassment and bias-based profiling by law enforcement.

The NYCHRL creates four general causes of action related to disability discrimination. First, it prohibits covered entities from discriminating against an individual based on disability or perceived disability. Second, it requires that covered entities provide reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities to enable

them “to satisfy the essential requisites of a job or enjoy the right or rights in question provided that the disability is known or should have been known by the covered entity.” Third, it prohibits discrimination based on one’s “association” or “relationship” with an individual with an actual or perceived disability. Fourth, in December 2017, the City Council passed Local Law No. (2018), which creates a separate cause of action against covered entities that “refuse or otherwise fail to engage in a cooperative dialogue within a reasonable time with a person who has requested an accommodation or who the covered entity has notice may require such an accommodation.”

The Commission works to address disability discrimination through both pre-complaint intervention via a program called Project Equal Access, and through enforcement. Project Equal Access seeks to address common access issues in housing through pre-complaint intervention. The program helps provide an expedited and efficient solution to members of the public because access and accommodation needs are often urgent and time-sensitive. For instance, if an apartment building lacks a ramp for a tenant who uses a wheelchair, which effectively traps a resident inside their building, Project Equal Access can step in and attempt to secure the accommodation. If these pre-complaint efforts fail, the case is referred to LEB for investigation and assessment of damages. LEB also conducts regular testing to ensure that covered entities are providing accessibility to people with disabilities, including for instance, conducting testing at a local public hospital to confirm whether staff provided American Sign Language interpreting services for Deaf patients. The testing was conducted as part of an investigation into a complaint filed by a Deaf woman against Jamaica Medical Center after she alleged being denied American Sign Language interpreting services when visiting the hospital’s emergency room. As part of the settlement with the Commission, the hospital agreed to pay $22,500 in emotional distress damages to the complainant and to overhaul its policies relating to language access, reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities, and the provision of sign language interpreters in both emergent and appointment-based interactions with patients. The

hospital also agreed to provide comprehensive anti-discrimination training to staff and agreed to Commission monitoring for a period of three years.

Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission has also secured a major legal victory in the New York Court of Appeals on its interpretation of disability accommodation law with respect to housing providers. In the case, the complainant, Irene Politis, came to the Commission seeking a reasonable accommodation to have her landlord install a wheelchair ramp to her first-floor apartment. Her landlord insisted that installing the ramp was structurally impossible. During investigation, the Commission proposed converting a window into a door and adding a ramp, a conversion that the landlord had previously completed in a different but similar building. At administrative court proceedings, the landlord and the Commission disagreed about the feasibility of the conversion and whether the landlord had met its high burden under the City Human Rights Law to prove undue hardship (the landlord did not present evidence about the financial hardship, if any, of such conversion), and the ALJ sided with the landlord. The Commission declined to adopt the ALJ’s recommendation and instead ordered the landlord to install the ramp, awarded Ms. Politis $75,000 in damages, and imposed a $125,000 civil penalty when it issued a Decision and Order. The case was ultimately appealed to the New York Court of Appeals, which in 2018, upheld the Commission’s decision and ruled against the landlord. The case was pivotal in that it reinforced that under the NYCHRL, respondents must provide evidence of actual “undue hardship” prior to denying a reasonable accommodation to an individual with a disability.

Under Commissioner Malalis, the Commission has also settled numerous cases of disability discrimination, summaries of

which are available on its website. While these settlement summaries are a useful technique to alert covered entities of their obligations and people with disabilities of their rights, disability accommodations continued to be an area of great confusion to all. To that end, the Commission decided to release an extensive disability legal enforcement guidance in 2016 outlining the protections for New Yorkers with disabilities in the NYCHRL and the differences between the City’s law and the Americans with Disabilities Act, which was a massive undertaking and prepared in consultation with the New York City Mayor’s Office for People with Disabilities and disability advocacy groups. The Commission’s detailed guidance contains numerous examples of discrimination based on disability, hypotheticals, addresses when medical documentation is needed to support an accommodation request, and provides sample notices, policies, and request forms. The guidance has been critical in enforcing its work to end disability discrimination in New York City and provide accessibility to people with disabilities.

CONCLUSION

Under the leadership of Commissioner Malalis, the Commission has had a powerful re-awakening as a civil rights powerhouse and has demonstrated the impact of robust local enforcement of civil and human rights law. Despite ongoing issues of capacity that are common to many civil rights institutions, the agency has nonetheless played a critical role in strengthening the NYCHRL, sharpening its investigatory and enforcement functions, and listening and responding to New Yorkers on the issues they face under the Trump administration and beyond. The Commission has become a credible venue for advocacy groups and attorneys and a reputable venue for members of the public to safely interact with government. Through public campaigns, reports, settlements, litigation, hearings, guidance documents, rules, amendments, focus groups, and surveys, and most importantly, a diverse and committed staff, the Commission has demonstrated that national change can originate at the local level, and the vital role that anti-discrimination agencies play in ensuring equal opportunity for all Americans and prospective Americans. With committed staff, vision, and willpower, the

Commission’s key to success has been to embrace a holistic response to addressing discrimination, using all of the various tools and programmatic areas at its disposal and being hyper-aware of the current environment. Through this approach, the agency has helped to further the cause of civil and human rights, regardless of ongoing challenges related to resources and capacity that impact all governmental agencies and demonstrated the power and possibility of local anti-discrimination agencies in the age of Trump and beyond.