Skip to main content

Worker Rights Handbook (WNYCOSH Worker Center, April 2025) (Part 3 of 3)

Part 3 of 3

Personal Rights

I’m Concerned That My Personnel File May Contain a Lot of False Information About Me What Can I Do?

Your personnel file typically contains information you know about or have given the employer, including some personal information, workplace records like wages and hours, accrued benefits, reprimands if you have them. In fact, however, there is not much control over what information employers can collect and keep about you, if they want. This can include performance evaluations you haven’t seen, comments from co-workers or clients, references or any other information your employer has on you.

Can I find out what is in my file?

There are no federal or NYS laws giving you the right to access, make copies of, or contest what is in your personnel file. (Some other states do provide this right.) You can, and should, ask to see your personnel file, but your employer is not required to comply. You may also want to request in writing that certain information in the file be kept confidential – health information or, perhaps, addresses and phone numbers (for example, if you are concerned about domestic violence). Again, there is no legal requirement that the employer comply with the request.

Can My Employer Spy on Me at Work?

An owner or manager of any premises cannot install or use a mirror, peephole, camera, video recorder, or other viewing device to observe the interior of a fitting room, restroom, toilet, bathroom, washroom, shower, or any room assigned to guests of a hotel or motel. Victims of unlawful observation have been allowed to sue for infliction of emotional distress. There are no laws restricting video surveillance of public places, so an employer can install cameras covering areas of the workplace that are not covered by the above prohibition, such as hallways, lobbies, work areas and parking lots. Employers are not allowed to spy on union activities.

Can My Employer Listen in On My Phone Calls or Check Email?

Under the applicable Federal laws, the Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 and the Stored Communications Act, an employer can monitor your phone conversations with the prior consent of at least one party to the conversation or through an extension phone used in the ordinary course of the employer’s business. Your emails can be accessed with the prior consent of at least one party to the communication. Consent can be “expressed,” such as if you signed a form specifically granting consent to monitoring and/or accessing; or it can be “implied” if you have been notified that the employer will monitor and/or access. If the monitoring or accessing is based on consent, it cannot exceed the scope of the consent. Employers who are providers of wire or electronic communications have somewhat greater latitude in monitoring and accessing communications. If you are using an employer-provided computer, or email address, they are the property of the employer and can be accessed or monitored without your permission or knowledge.

In New York, it is a felony to monitor or record a telephone call or a personal conversation or to intercept or access an electronic communication without the consent of at least one of the parties to the discussion

or communication. New York State law requires employers who will be monitoring electronic communication to notify employees upon hiring in writing, have employees sign a written acknowledgement, and post notice of the monitoring in a conspicuous place, Two federal laws allow victims to sue for violations, but New York does not yet allow a victim to sue, though the NYS Attorney General can enforce penalties if the law has been broken. Union contracts sometimes establish limits on an employer’s right to monitor. Public sector employees might have additional protections under the U.S. and New York constitutions. These laws are extremely complex, and you should seek legal advice if you have a concern.

Can My Employer Search My Desk or Personal Property?

Private sector employees in New York generally have no protections against searches of their lockers, desks or work areas. Your employer may notify you that all personal belongings, such as briefcases and handbags, are subject to search. Your employer cannot open or read a sealed letter or private communication to you. If the search is done in an extremely abusive manner, you might have a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress. Public sector employees might have additional protections under the U.S. and New York constitutions.

Can An Employer Get My Credit History or Get Information about My Lifestyle?

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) does not allow an employer to ask an outside agency, such as a detective agency or credit bureau, to investigate and report on your personal characteristics, lifestyle, character, general reputation or credit standing unless the employer has first notified you in writing that such a report might be obtained and you have given your advance written consent to the investigation. Also, you must be furnished clear written notice of your rights under the FCRA. If an employer intends to take adverse action against you, such as refusing to hire you or firing you, based on the report, the employer must first give you a copy of the report. You have additional rights under the FCRA. The FCRA is enforced by the Federal Trade Commission. Victims of FCRA violations are allowed to file a lawsuit.

Can An Employer Conduct Mandatory Drug Testing?

If you work in the private sector in New York, you have little protection against mandatory, indiscriminate or inaccurate drug tests, even if there is no good reason for your employer to suspect drug usage. The exception is for cannabis, which employers are not allowed to test applicants or employees for, except under specific circumstances. Some jobs, like those in transportation services, law enforcement, and some federal contractors may require regular drug testing under federal or state law. If you work in the public sector, blanket testing of entire workforces is generally not permitted. You may be protected under the Americans with Disabilities Act, such as in the case of a positive test for a drug that was legally prescribed for a disability. Employers may also not single out a group of employees for drug testing, such as testing based on age, race, gender, or other protected groups.

What About Marijuana? That’s Legal in New York State

Marijuana is legal for adults over the age of 21 to consume in New York State. Employers are not allowed to discriminate against employees for using cannabis outside of the workplace, outside of work hours, and not on or using the workplace’s property or equipment. Employers are allowed to prohibit the use of

cannabis during work hours (for instance, on your lunch break or when you are “on-call”) or bringing cannabis onto their property. An employer may be required to take action under another law or be required by federal funding or contracts to prohibit the use of marijuana. If you are high at work in such a way that it affects your performance, your employer can take action against you. This is also the case if your use of marijuana affects the health and safety of the workplace, for example, if you are still high and are using machinery or equipment. Drug testing for cannabis does not prove that an employee was impaired at work and employers are not allowed to test except under certain circumstances, nor is smelling like cannabis proof of impairment.

Can An Employer Make Me Take a Lie Detector Test?

For private sector employees, generally no. The Employee Polygraph Protection Act (EPPA) prohibits private sector employers from asking or requiring an employee to take any kind of lie detector test and from taking any adverse action against an employee for refusing to take a lie detector test. Under a limited exception involving investigations of economic loss, an employer may ask, but not require, an employee to take a polygraph. test, and the employer is required to first provide the employee with written notice of his or her rights under the EPPA as well as other information about the examination. There are a few other exceptions under the EPPA regarding the use of polygraphs. Although New York does not have a general law covering lie detectors or polygraphs, the use of “psychological stress evaluators” (PSE) is strictly prohibited. PSE are devices that supposedly measure truthfulness based on voice fluctuations or vocal stress. An employer cannot even request or suggest that an employee or prospective employee undergo a PSE test. An employer who violates the prohibitions regarding PSE commits a misdemeanor and can be sued by the victim.

Can An Employer Find Out My Genetic Information?

Under New York’s Human Rights Law, an employer cannot request, require, or administer a genetic test to a person as a condition of employment, and an employer cannot obtain an individual’s genetic test results. However, an employer can require a specific genetic test if it is directly related to an occupational environment where an employee or applicant with a particular genetic abnormality might be at increased risk. Written informed consent must be given before a genetic test can be performed.

Can An Employer Make Me Take a “Personality” or “Honesty” Test?

Most likely, yes. Tests that supposedly measure an applicant’s or employee’s personality or “honesty” are becoming more common, but there are no specific federal or New York State laws regarding their use. These are usually paper and pencil tests, but sometimes they are given over the internet or by telephone, with responses to be given by touch-tone. If the use of these tests causes a disproportionate number of persons in categories protected by the antidiscrimination laws to be excluded from jobs, their use might be unlawful. They may also violate the Americans with Disabilities Act if they screen for a trait connected to a particular medical condition. See section on Discrimination for a listing of agencies that might be able to provide more information.

Can I Be Fired for My Political Activities?

Under New York law, an employer generally cannot fire or otherwise discriminate against an employee because of the person’s legal political activities outside of working hours, off the employer’s premises,

and when such activities do not involve the use of the employer’s equipment or property. Somewhat different rules apply to public sector employees, who also are covered by the free speech provisions of the U.S. and New York State constitutions. Public sector employees may also have additional constitutional and statutory protections.

Getting Help NY Civil Liberties Union www.nyclu.org Western New York Regional Office 716-332-4658

Privacy Rights Clearinghouse www.privacyrights.org National Work Rights Institute www.workrights.org

New York State Cannabis FAQ https://dol.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2021/10/p420-cannabisfaq10-08-21.pdf